Re:Montana's No Speed Limit Safety Paradox
by dutchflyboy on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:29AM
(#1147627)
I agree, the fact that the german Autobahn is compared directly to US highways is laughable. It's comparing apples and pears: not relevant.
Re:Montana's No Speed Limit Safety Paradox
by moron4hire on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:50PM
(#1148899)
Why can't you compare apples and pears? They're both fruit that grows in trees and they both have similar use culinary purposes. I can make cider out of both, and the results are actually quite similar.
Anyway, this generalization
> The lower–than–US fatality rates on the German Autobahn (where flow management is the primary safety strategy), and now Montana's experience, would indicate that using speed limits and speed enforcement as the cornerstone of US highway safety policy is a major mistake.
is totally out of line in an article that doesn't even address the technical question of statistical significance or deal with potential biases Montana's or Germany's automotive demographics put on the data.