News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by bardworx on Sunday April 10, 2016 @09:51PM (#11469169)
Isn't Communism very similar to your perfect world? All the people were provided for and they worked for everyone and everyone was equal. However, that didn't work out too well.

In any system, some folk will always squatter and some will always attempt to gain power/advantage.

Your world sounds too much like Atlas Shrugged.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by ubernostrum on Sunday April 10, 2016 @10:07PM (#11469214)
The thing to realize here is that the number of humans who need to do work building/operating/maintaining the machinery that keeps everyone taken care of decreases over time. It's perfectly reasonable to expect a point in the future where most of the time, zero direct human work is required in order to provide for all humans.

The issue is getting over the mental hurdle of enabling such a society. The technology is actually pretty straightforward, but the politics of it is full of people who just can't stand the idea of that filthy leeching parasite, he doesn't work as hard as I do, why does he get anything at all! He doesn't deserve it! Which in turn is an artifact of an economic system that's already firmly in the past of many developed nations (i.e., one in which all people needed to work constantly in order to produce enough to keep themselves alive).

Of course this is a fundamentally irrational position to hold when one already lives in a society that's content to let people who never work a day in their lives have all their needs taken care of (see: inheritance). It also disregards the fact that many people who have everything literally handed to them from birth still feel a drive to try to do something meaningful with their lives. There are trust-fund parasites who don't do anything, of course, but it certainly isn't 100% of them. Plus, it's pretty well empirically established that humans do get bored and seek things to do even when they have no life-sustaining work left to perform (see: retirement).

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by taneq on Sunday April 10, 2016 @11:34PM (#11469470)
I think we're already past that point, if we define "provide for all humans" as "provide shelter, food, and clean water." However, "provide for humans" is a moving target which is actually interpreted as "provide a living standards not significantly worse than average." These days that includes providing running hot/cold water, range of healthy food, air conditioning, electricity, TV, internet, some form of motorized transport, health care, clothing, etc. etc."
Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by Fjolsvith on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:45AM (#11469847)
Frankly, I don't see that this is perfectly reasonable to expect. TANSTAAFL. Food still has to be produced. Energy still has to be produced. All that stuff has to be paid for somehow or the producers stop producing for the freeloaders.

What you think of as a mental hurdle I see as a way of discerning what is mine from what is yours. Show me a developed nation where a person actually doesn't have any personal property.

Without personal property rights, people will stop producing for others and society will fail. Why would I be willing to trade my load of firewood to you for your butchered hog? I'd just take your hog and not bother with providing you a share of firewood. And, in that system if you came around to get a share of my firewood, you'd disappear.

I believe that if a person doesn't have their needs met, they just don't deserve to have them met. (I'm not talking about a moralistic judgement here. Its more like the universe has just arranged itself in response to the unlucky person's actions.)

For example, 3 years ago, I got a hammer and a saw and started building a shed. I sold it and bought the materials to build another. I sold that one too. Today, I own a company that manufactures sheds and employs a few people.

I'm now much better off than I was because I decided to take advantage of people willing to buy my product. I now have employees who build my buildings and I profit from them, too. Is this a bad thing? I don't think so, because several of my employees were unemployed and needing work when I hired them.

What's fair about Capitalism is that anyone has the opportunity to make something work. If a person doesn't want to take advantage of this and better their lot, then I believe they have no right to bitch about us making money and having nice things. Let them suffer paycheck to paycheck.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by ubernostrum on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:42AM (#11469983)
Food still has to be produced. Energy still has to be produced. All that stuff has to be paid for somehow or the producers stop producing for the freeloaders.

The question is: what happens when most or all of the food and energy is being produced not by human labor, but by fully-automated processes? Why would, say, a farming robot care whether someone is "freeloading" off its labor?

What you think of as a mental hurdle I see as a way of discerning what is mine from what is yours. Show me a developed nation where a person actually doesn't have any personal property.

The idea of a post-scarcity society is not incompatible with the idea of personal property. It is incompatible with continuing to believe that basic necessities such as food, shelter, water, medicine, and possibly other things should be apportioned on a "did you earn it" basis, because that notion dates to a time when it truly was necessary for each person to put in continual effort to ensure enough of those things were produced. These things are no longer super-scarce and no longer require anywhere near the effort to produce that they used to; society should adjust in response to that change.

There is no logical reason, if the capability exists to automatically produce sufficient basic necessities for every human being, why every human being should still have to do a make-work job in order to prove they "deserve" those things. And you could still have all the capitalism you like for anything that isn't a basic necessity; the basic life doesn't have to be one of luxury, just one free from worry about things like food and shelter; the currency of such a society would need to be tied to something other than control of basic-necessity resources, but finding alternative bases for currency is something people already do for fun.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by sokoloff on Monday April 11, 2016 @05:26AM (#11470437)
Food still requires valuable farmland, water, energy, fertilizers, pest control, capital to buy and expand the automation, operating costs and labor to repair and oversee the operations. It's an enormous amount of initial capital investment and a massive on-going operating expenses, and that's just for basic farming.

Now, add all the post-processing and transportation logistics after the food comes out of the ground to get to basic staple ingredients. Then add all the preparation activities, cooking, and packing to get to the Hot Pocket/Pop Tart level of salable food (or food-like) product.

Watersheds need to be protected; water needs to be treated, tested, stored, and pumped under pressure through a distribution network of pipes. Sewerage needs to be piped in the other direction, treated, and disposed of.

Electricity needs space, energy input, capital, and opex and a distribution network that needs on-going maintenance and repair. Gas lines need a lot of the same. Internet distribution needs...

Medicine needs space, energy, [lots of] people with specialized training just to apply the state of today's art. It also has a large research and development component responsible for ensuring that we aren't still using leeches to treat "Bilious fever".

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by majewsky on Monday April 11, 2016 @05:40AM (#11470475)
> Why would, say, a farming robot care whether someone is "freeloading" off its labor?

The obvious rebuttal is that someone has to build and maintain the farming robot, so this is the guy whom you would be freeloading of.

On a more general note: The concept of property only ever arises because of scarcity. For example, you wouldn't describe yourself as owning the air in your apartment, since there is ample air. A diver, on the other hand, would definitely declare ownership in the air in your air bottle.

So how can we implement a post-scarcity society? My best guess would be to work on affordable technology that makes basic things like water, food, clothes or internet access not scarce anymore.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by Fjolsvith on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:40PM (#11474036)
"There is no logical reason, if the capability exists to automatically produce sufficient basic necessities for every human being, why every human being should still have to do a make-work job in order to prove they "deserve" those things. And you could still have all the capitalism you like for anything that isn't a basic necessity; the basic life doesn't have to be one of luxury, just one free from worry about things like food and shelter; the currency of such a society would need to be tied to something other than control of basic-necessity resources, but finding alternative bases for currency is something people already do for fun."

Well, let the people who live on welfare invent and create the machines that will give them free food, water, heat and living space. They surely have a lot of time to devote to that, not having to work for a living.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by ctdonath on Monday April 11, 2016 @08:17AM (#11470995)
"Post scarcity" only exists and continues because of continued efforts which continue only because of reward/profits. No profit => no effort.

The other problem is what constitutes basic necessity. I can build you a "human terrarium" of 100 sq ft, HVAC, clean water, disposal, and 4 bottles Soylent per day - leaving you 18 hours daily to procreate & demand more. What is the limit to your demands? You have ample opportunity & resources to earn your own survival with ease; now you demand I provide your total basic survival needs from my own efforts, taking what I would give my own offspring - ENOUGH! BEGONE!

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by fucking_tragedy on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:20AM (#11471642)
No. Welfare programs are not communism or socialism. The single defining characteristic in both ideologies is the degree of which labor owns its means of production (the resources, facilities and tools needed to do a job).

Welfare programs do not even begin to touch on who owns the means of production.

Communism implies a stateless society after a period of power by labor that is devoid of private ownership of the means of production. Supposedly, this transitionary period should do away with class. According to theory, once class is no longer a factor, the state is no longer needed.

Welfare programs, again, do not touch on this at all.

You've read too much Ayn Rand.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by Matumio on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:17AM (#11470074)
Communism is much more focused about workers and equality. Just providing the bare basic needs for everyone, without expecting them to work or live in a certain way, is a very different concept. What if all basic goods can be produced with hardly any human labour? A rich enough society can be so far beyond those basic needs that forcing anyone to work for survival can only be explained as a form of punishment.
Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by crdoconnor on Monday April 11, 2016 @06:01AM (#11470526)
>Isn't Communism very similar to your perfect world? All the people were provided for and they worked for everyone and everyone was equal. However, that didn't work out too well.

A system where everybody was equal was never tried.

A system where the necessities were guaranteed was tried - in the Soviet Union - and it was, by and large, very successful.

It was successful enough, in fact, that Western elites responded to it in the 50s by implementing similar guarantees - NHS, social security, medicare, etc. (McCarthy's witchhunts and the Vietnam war weren't the only responses to communism).

What made the Soviet Union finally unable to keep up economically was the prohibitive cost of the arms race and declining oil export revenues, not the lack of capitalist profit motives.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by arethuza on Monday April 11, 2016 @07:45AM (#11470868)
I really don't think the UK NHS was created in response to anything the Soviet Union did - the Labour movement in the UK had a long history long before the Soviets were around.

The NHS actually shows the power of democracy over an elite - after all the 1945 election removed Churchill and voted in the socialist Attlee government. Attlee was so effective as a leader that even Thatcher spoke highly of him:

'Quite contrary to the general tendency of politicians in the Nineties, he was all substance and no show.'

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-1194059/A-giant-ma...

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by crdoconnor on Monday April 11, 2016 @09:13AM (#11471209)
On the idea that it was all about Atlee: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Man_theory

Do you think the fact that the UK NHS funding model closely followed the existing Soviet NHS model was a coincidence?

The Tories fought long and hard in the 40s to make the proposed new 'cover everybody' system insurance based (something like Obamacare I guess) and ultimately didn't prevail. They used all sorts of scare tactics that would seem very familiar today.

A large part of that failure was Labour being able to point to the Soviet Union (not yet enemies of the highest order) and go "look, we can achieve the same success in curing infectious disease that they did".

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by kofejnik on Monday April 11, 2016 @07:53AM (#11470903)
Unlike you, I have personally experienced communism and Soviet Union. You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.
Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by dublinben on Sunday April 10, 2016 @10:35PM (#11469304)
>However, that didn't work out too well.

When was communism actually implemented, that it didn't "work out too well" in your opinion?

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by pink_dinner on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:16AM (#11469768)
sigh do we really need to have this discussion and dou you actually think communism would ever work?

The problem is that pesky human nature gets in the way.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by fucking_tragedy on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:27AM (#11471684)
The same problems that plague capitalism plague communist implementations.

In power structures, things are great if you're part of the class that receives political favors and not so great if you're not.

In capitalist societies, capital owning classes have the time and resources to be the political class. In previous communist societies, party and administrative members were the political class.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by pink_dinner on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:15PM (#11473827)
"In capitalist societies, capital owning classes have the time and resources to be the political class. In previous communist societies, party and administrative members were the political class"

This sounds like theory. In practice, capitalism beats communism in pretty much every way. Of course there are people that own capital. Private ownership is one of the main tenets of capitalism.

Capitalism works because it is on the correct side of human nature. It pushes people to earn more capital, which in turn, helps the rest of us.

Do you think our technology would have advanced this far if we didn't have capitalism? The only reason computers, phones, the Internet are getting better and better is because of competition. The more competition in a market, the cheaper the price is to us, the consumer.

Communism, on the other hand, makes everyone a slave to the state. Why would you want to compete and earn more when it will just be taken away from you by the government?

There were many experiments in the 1970s with communism. People created their own small communities and shared everything. Everyone was equal. The end result was always a disaster: jealousy always fueled the collapse of the group.

Would you want the person in school that never studied for his tests and partied every day to earn the same amount as you, who studied for every test and did well? I sure wouldn't.

Communism, in any form, is a failure. I don't know how much death, poverty, and famine we need to go through for some people to learn this.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by mentando on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:26AM (#11469952)
Yeah, in theory it is awesome, but it just does not work in real life...
Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by mruniverse on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:33AM (#11470118)
I think even in theory it's not awesome.

What is awesome is a system where everyone benefits when everyone is self-interested.

Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by TeMPOraL on Monday April 11, 2016 @06:49AM (#11470665)
It's not awesome, it's poison. Cooperation > competition, and artificially forcing everything to be expressed in terms of the latter is cancerous to society. Ignoring conscience and empathy is wasting the in-born qualities that allow us to be more efficient in groups.
Re:What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to... by chc on Sunday April 10, 2016 @11:06PM (#11469380)
Do you mean "actually" or "perfectly"?