News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WhatsApp Rolls Out End-To-End Encryption to Its Over 1B U... by tptacek on Friday April 08, 2016 @05:14PM (#11458033)
People need to stop writing this exact comment. Even if you're right about open source and security, you can't be right about it for this reason, because this comment is false.

You are not in fact stuck with Facebook's "say-so" about what WhatsApp is doing. Obviously, if you have the executable binary, you can straightforwardly validate its functionality with a disassembler/decompiler. There are thousands of people that do this professionally.

There might be some other reason why it's important that WhatsApp's code be published, but it can't possibly be this one.

Re:WhatsApp Rolls Out End-To-End Encryption to Its Over 1B U... by antihero on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:52AM (#11477685)
Has anyone actually done this? I lack the skill to but for a piece of software this important, surely someone is working on this? And will it be repeated for every update?

Personally if I was the NSA or GCHQ I think it would be a wicked smart plan to release this and have it be actually secure, have it audited, gain trust, let people use it for a while then after a while release an update that shoved all the messages in memory to a server somewhere once people let their guard down. Implausible yes, but that's the issue with trust. And I'm not sure releasing the clean source would really help this. The only thing would be to hold up on updating the app until a trusted party had audited the updated binary. More paranoia: Also would have to audit the specific binary for every country with wierd laws (e.g. UK's RIPA) appstore to make sure we didn't get a nice local flavour of poison.