Re:John Tierney: Salt Good or Bad? Nobody Knows (Yet)
by ukdm on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @02:33PM
(#1146186)
It was opinion. They don't know with concrete scietific evidence how much salt is good or bad for you. I'd suggest that too much of most things is bad for you therefore I choose to have everything in moderation and follow guidelines given out by the Food Standards Agency (http://www.eatwell.gov.uk/healthydiet/fss/salt/). Whether you follow that advice or not is up to the individual. Am I overweight? No, Is my blood pressure high? No. Is this due to controlling my salt and fat intake? I have no idea. But it works for me.
Re:John Tierney: Salt Good or Bad? Nobody Knows (Yet)
by jodrellblank on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @04:09PM
(#1146435)
If it's not due to controlling your salt and fat intake, then it doesn't work for you, it's just correlated with some behaviour which does.
Re:John Tierney: Salt Good or Bad? Nobody Knows (Yet)
by CWuestefeld on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @12:18PM
(#1145813)
The stakes on this stuff are high, you'd better be damned sure you're right before you make public health pronouncements.
Unfortunately, this seems to be the standard process when government steps in. Whether the topic is an economic bailout or taking action on AGW, it seems to be driven more by the desired means than a well-understood model of how to get to the ends.
Re:John Tierney: Salt Good or Bad? Nobody Knows (Yet)
by sailormoon on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @12:11PM
(#1145799)
Amen to that.
I find myself wondering how many more times we're going to read things like "Before changing public policy, Dr. Alderman and Dr. McCarron suggest trying something new: a rigorous test of the low-salt diet in a randomized clinical trial. That proposal is rejected by the salt reformers as too time-consuming and expensive. But when you contemplate the potential costs of another public health debacle like the anti-fat campaign, a clinical trial can start to look cheap." (Emphasis mine.) No, your judgment is not so awesome we can just bypass the scientific process, for any value of "your judgment".
Might I also add that you still seem to be stuck on the "public health debacle like the anti-fat campaign"; I find the scientific evidence against saturated fat to be wanting. As that paragraph implies, ultimately they did the same thing you're advocating here for salt: They skipped over science because we had to act now!!! and it was OK to substitute their judgment for science. We'll be another decade or two minimum flushing out the wrong idea that fat is bad for you, decades in which those wrong ideas will cost hundreds of millions more their lives and health. (Excluding transfats, which I think the evidence is clear that they are.) The stakes on this stuff are high, you'd better be damned sure you're right before you make public health pronouncements.