It really is incredible to see tptacek discounting the closed source, completely unaudited nature of this product. A company is saying "we have total end-to-end encryption...trust us", and to believe that you trust the binary that is on your device, that it is managing keys properly (there is usually a fine line between usability and security, and usability usually wins), and you trust that they don't misuse your messages when they pass through their server. They control every aspect of the conversation, and are fully capable of completely undermining your security at any moment (if not already). In practice it's not terribly unlike the widely discredited JavaScript encryption approaches.
It's like IDA Pro and OpenSSL never happened.
I am curious where you looked for these cases that you saw none.
I assure you that this happens quite regularly. And what is wrong with IDA Pro? Why would it need to advance?
This notion that security products are vetted by analyzing the binary code is absurd yet it happens on a regular basis.
It's an example of a topic people will raise to object to the EFF scorecard, not an argument being made against the iPhone.
Anyone but Thomas and this would be dead