News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by joshschreuder on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:59PM (#11451660)
I thought the HR detection on consumer fitness gear wasn't very accurate, yet we are able to base medical decisions off it? Have I been misled?
Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by mindcrime on Thursday April 07, 2016 @10:48PM (#11452277)
I may have been told wrong, but I'm sure I recall being told that some consumer heart rate monitors (the kind with a chest strap) are approximately as accurate as what's used in a doctor's office. Now something that doesn't use a chest strap... I don't know. Probably those are less accurate? And/or maybe I'm the one who's been misled.
Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by abraae on Thursday April 07, 2016 @11:11PM (#11452350)
According to this article http://www.tomsguide.com/us/heart-rate-monitor,review-2885.h..., several consumer products are accurate to within 1 beat of an EKG.
Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by InclinedPlane on Thursday April 07, 2016 @08:14PM (#11451713)
They're not very accurate. But some heart rate symptoms are obvious enough to make even poor quality measurements useful enough to make a medical decision.
Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by abraae on Thursday April 07, 2016 @10:21PM (#11452201)
Like atrial fibrillation, which I UST found out I have. I've been capturing my heart rate from a polar h7 chest band to an Android app, then visualising with grafanas stddev. The pattern is strikingly obvious
Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by gertef on Thursday April 07, 2016 @08:45PM (#11451840)
This is covered in the article.
Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by joshschreuder on Thursday April 07, 2016 @08:47PM (#11451847)
Yeah, the article mentions that they only cover pulse tracking, not arrhythmias, but I was under the impression that even the pulse tracking was somewhat iffy due to the nature of how the tracking is performed.

In fact, the article says there's a class action lawsuit because of it, which means using this data in a medical context could have gone very badly potentially.

Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by cordite on Thursday April 07, 2016 @09:04PM (#11451914)
Given that they were seeing if a precondition is true (arrhythmia started within last 48 hours), and the data showed that there was a significant change over time, it seems somewhat reasonable to act on if the patient wasn't totally sure.

Physicians usually want to know what is different or regular for the specific patient over time, whether or not a value seems high for one person doesn't mean that action needs to be taken--but when that value changes significantly or shows a trend in a particular direction over time, that is information relevant to what procedure they decide next.

It is entirely possible that the fitbit started recording data differently at or after the seizure, supposing it got shifted in the event. However, that does not invalidate the trend of the data as a whole. In this case, the patient was seemingly able to help acquire such data. If the patient said they were one way or the other, or if the patient depended on a device to fulfill that judgement, is it really the physician's fault to choose what the patient provides? IANAL

Re:Doctors used an ER patient's FitBit data to justify elect... by Tharkun on Friday April 08, 2016 @09:27AM (#11454465)
This is certainly true for the optical sensors. I wonder what the long term effect is of shining a bright LED at a small patch of skin like that?