News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by clishem on Thursday April 07, 2016 @04:39PM (#11450519)
"As climate change threatens, NASA has options that include hardening facilities against the rising seas with barriers and structures adapted to storms and flooding, or if adaptation is not possible, to strategically retreat."

This article makes it seem as if protecting against rising water levels is an almost impossible feat. For everyone who thinks it is, I invite them to come to the Netherlands. The majority of the Netherlands lies under sea level, yet because it is completely protected by dikes/levees no floods have taken place for decades. In fact, all places that indexed by direct economical damage were a flood to take place; and get protected accordingly. A highly populated area or industrious zone might get a rating that only a flood every 10.000 years is acceptable, while for some rural areas may get a rating that a flood every 300 years is acceptable. https://www.rijnland.net/downloads/floodcontrolrijnland-1-1....

I wonder what rating Dutch dike safety experts would give to the NASA launch platform, but seeing such an important economical site with hardly any protection against floods certainly boggles me.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by jfoutz on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:00PM (#11450680)
Netherlands whole coastline is what, 450 miles? For a 850 billion gdp it makes sense to have a high quality system in place. You guys are facing a billion euro/year to just update the existing system [1].

Nasa needs to protect 70 miles, 1/6th of you're whole country's coast. That far south in the Atlantic has much more extreme weather. So in addition to building a system, they'd need to build a much more robust system, compared to the Netherlands, to deal with the extremes.

Is it possible? Hell yeah, they're smart people. Is it worth it? eh. Maybe just move and have a few more mars explorers instead. The big buildings and tracks are cool, but offices hangars and tracks are much simpler (and cheaper!) to build than a hurricane proof levee system.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flood_control_in_the_Netherlan...

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by dalke on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:17PM (#11450798)
Plus, as the NYT article points out, KSC "sits in the middle of a vast wildlife refuge", which limits what can be done. Also, the ground is permeable - it doesn't help to build a dike if the water can seep up through the ground.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by duaneb on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:20PM (#11450818)
Hey, in Colorado we have plenty of open space a mile above sea level. This is not an impossible barrier.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by jfoutz on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:26PM (#11450865)
Hey, in New Mexico we already have a spaceport. http://spaceportamerica.com/ Also, we have enough open space that occasionally we get nuked. So that's pretty sweet.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by zardo on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:08PM (#11451426)
They won't be able to do orbital flights from spaceportamerica.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by gozur88 on Thursday April 07, 2016 @09:10PM (#11451929)
Orbital flights would be no problem, although equatorial orbits would require more fuel.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by zardo on Thursday April 07, 2016 @10:24PM (#11452211)
I think the FAA would have a very big problem with ballistic trajectories crossing populated areas.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by mikeash on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:26PM (#11450861)
I don't think you have enough space for rockets to launch without parts potentially landing on people. Even the Russians end up dropping spent stages in areas that aren't entirely empty: http://www.russianspaceweb.com/baikonur_downrange.html
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by jessaustin on Thursday April 07, 2016 @08:03PM (#11451669)
Eh, it's difficult to muster much concern for Kansas. Besides, with re-use becoming more popular, there's less reason to drop spare parts downrange.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by mikeash on Thursday April 07, 2016 @09:17PM (#11451949)
Reuse cuts down on the problem a lot, but there's still the possibility of things going wrong and debris coming down on stuff you'd rather stayed not-flat.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by AnimalMuppet on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:36PM (#11450915)
Further south matters. Basically, from the earth's rotation, you get 1000 MPH x cos(lattitude) of free velocity toward orbit, so being closer to the equator is a fairly big deal.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by dalke on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:07PM (#11451071)
It's nice, but remember that Russia launches from 45N, so it isn't that critical. The boost is 880mph for KSC, vs. 790mph for Denver vs. 710 mph for Baikonur. The deltas are only 100-200 mph, vs. the 17,500 mph needed for orbit.

The worst case is Israel, which for geographic and geopolitical reasons has to launch to the west instead of east. Even that's only about a 30% penalty in payload. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_Space_Agency#Palmachim_...

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by mikeash on Friday April 08, 2016 @09:45AM (#11454581)
It depends on what orbit you're trying to reach. Looking at the raw speed needed doesn't tell the whole story, because now that the space race is over and most launches actually try to do something besides set a record, you can't just launch into whatever orbit is convenient.

If you're going for something highly inclined then it doesn't matter at all. Launching to the ISS from Baikonur is no more costly than launching to the ISS from Canaveral or Guiana. Launching into a high equatorial orbit, like for a comsat, is far more costly because you can't naturally achieve an inclination lower than the latitude of the launch site, so you need an expensive plane change. If you wanted to launch into a low equatorial orbit for some reason then it would be even worse, and the high-latitude launch sites would become impractical.

And actually, Israel is far from the worst case. The worst case would be something like launching into an equatorial orbit from a site at one of the poles. This would require something like 25-30% more delta-v, which because of the rocket equation means vastly more rocket for the same payload. But for a polar orbit, launching from the poles would be fine, actually very slightly better than an equatorial launch site because you wouldn't have to cancel out the speed you get from the Earth's rotation.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by dalke on Saturday April 09, 2016 @05:04AM (#11460574)
You make valid objections to my objections of the simplified model of the g'parent poster. We were indeed only talking about putting something into orbit, not putting something into useful orbit.

That said, I pointed out that Israel has geographical and geopolitical difficulties, which force them to launch to the west rather than east. Would it be harder for Israel to place something in GEO from Palmachim, which must first travel west over the Mediterranean before going east, or for Sweden to place something in GEO from Esrange, which requires a plane change?

(I'm trying to be somewhat realistic. I think Esrange is the most poleward launch facility, though they only do suborbital. Otherwise, consider a possible Norwegian launch facility on Svalbard.)

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by mikeash on Saturday April 09, 2016 @12:07PM (#11461844)
Thinking about it more, once you get to the point where a bi-elliptic transfer is the most efficient way to do a plane change, the launch site doesn't make a lot of difference. That's basically Baikonur and up, counting Israel as effectively having a ~150-degree latitude.

Anyway, the penalties can be pretty big, but they're often tolerable. For GEO you want minimal latitude, for others latitude may not matter at all. But other considerations (like Israel having land to the east) can easily override the penalties.

For the particular example discussed here, if you could ignore the problems with squishing people and buildings downrange, Colorado would make a decent launch site. KSC's latitude is better, but it wouldn't be a huge deal. You'd even get at least a little bit of it back because you'd be launching from higher altitude.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by brownbat on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:56PM (#11451641)
And is this counteracted at all by the mile head-start out of the gravity well?

Also, for spent stages, the population density of Kansas isn't that much higher than the Atlantic, they're basically identical after rounding. /s

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by dalke on Thursday April 07, 2016 @08:12PM (#11451708)
No, not really. It's only 1/250th of the way up, and the hard part is to go sideways real fast, not up. https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ .

The lawsuits are $0, after rounding to the nearest trillion.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by brownbat on Friday April 08, 2016 @06:35PM (#11458629)
> The lawsuits are $0, after rounding to the nearest trillion.

Exactly so!

Wait, you caught the sarcasm tag right?

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by dalke on Saturday April 09, 2016 @05:06AM (#11460579)
Yes, I did. It was marred, however, by the image of my Kansas relatives being killed by falling rocket debris.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by brownbat on Saturday April 09, 2016 @03:13PM (#11462790)
As a Kansan myself, I like to think most of my relatives can handle a modicum of dark humor.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by dalke on Saturday April 09, 2016 @03:49PM (#11462963)
Ahh, but I am not a Kansan.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by gknoy on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:06PM (#11451067)
Because eastward launches net you more delta-V, you also benefit a lot from not having anyone to the east of you on whom to drop spent stages.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by correnos on Thursday April 07, 2016 @08:57PM (#11451889)
Plus the closer you are to the equator, the less (very fuel-expensive) orbital correction you need to get to geostationary orbit. Being close to the Tropic of Cancer, Florida's pretty well-positioned in this respect.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by dalke on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:21PM (#11450828)
I'm sorry, but I don't understand your comment. Are you switching to NASA's other option, which is to "strategically retreat", and suggesting CO?
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by duaneb on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:59PM (#11451656)
I am not commenting on NASA's options; I am hardly qualified. I'm simply pointing out that there are plenty of areas on the continent far away from sea-level issues (although as other posters have commented there are other reasons to avoid the area). I'm enjoying the commentary on why the option is untenable.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by justanother on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:03PM (#11451054)
I am not familiar with the geological features of the Netherlands, but much of the Florida coastline is formed from porous oolitic limestone, meaning you can build as many dikes and dams as you want, and the water will go under them and appear to come up from the ground on the side where it is not wanted. This is why so many coastal wells here in Florida have such problems with saltwater intrusion.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by Terr_ on Thursday April 07, 2016 @11:25PM (#11452384)
Ctrl-f'ed for "limestone", not disappointed :)

More info in "The Siege of Miami": http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/12/21/the-siege-of-mi...

> I asked everyone I met in South Florida who seemed at all concerned about sea-level rise the same question: What could be done? More than a quarter of the Netherlands is below sea level and those areas are home to millions of people, so low-elevation living is certainly possible. But the geology of South Florida is peculiarly intractable. Building a dike on porous limestone is like putting a fence on top of a tunnel: it alters the route of travel, but not necessarily the amount.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by cryptoz on Thursday April 07, 2016 @04:43PM (#11450547)
The NASA facilities are routinely subjected to hurricanes! Is the Netherlands prepared to handle huge surges of 30 feet of water all at once?

Is the Netherlands prepared to handle the 10-15 feet of base sea level rise that is coming in the next century? I'm not so sure that they are. In fact, aren't the Netherlands debating similar questions, about building much bigger walls, or, in fact, retreating?

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by kchoudhu on Friday April 08, 2016 @02:46AM (#11452983)
I believe so. The Dutch Delta Works were instituted as a result of the 1953 North Sea Storm, which resulted in a storm surge of (I think?) 20 feet. I'd imagine they built in some excess capacity in the surge protection system as well.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by AnimalMuppet on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:40PM (#11450936)
That sounds bad, but they've got a whole century to deal with it. That rate works out to only 1-2 inches/year. Also, they've got a millennium of experience. They'll probably be fine.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by scott_s on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:51PM (#11451330)
The recent analysis argues that it is unlikely to be a linear process.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by Fritsdehacker on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:56PM (#11451022)
I never heard retreat as an option, but the issue it is definitely discussed here. In 2010 the "Delta" program started, making place along the river sides for the water to flood when needed [1]. There are also projects started to strengthen the dikes and dunes. I live in the Netherlands and I'm not worried.

[1] http://www.klimaatportaal.nl/pro1/general/start.asp?itemid=3... (in dutch)

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by merpnderp on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:16PM (#11450788)
"10-15 feet of base sea level rise in the next century"

Maybe if you go by the NOAA histrionics. But if you go by scientific consensus, we're looking at 1-3 feet.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by cryptoz on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:19PM (#11450815)
Estimates of sea level rise are very difficult and always changing. New research suggests that it could be "several meters", as published in a paper a few weeks ago. There is no scientific consensus on how much the sea level "will rise" - since it depends very much on our behavior as a species in the near future.

> Without a sharp reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, the global sea level is likely to increase “several meters over a timescale of 50 to 150 years”

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2016/mar/22/sea-level-ri...

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by at-fates-hands on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:18PM (#11451470)
>> Estimates of sea level rise are very difficult and always changing.

Trust me, I'm pretty sure the people in the pacific islands are going to be a bit more paranoid about these changes than we are. And yet, some of the predictions have been wildly off the mark. Remember the United Nations Environment Programme who said in 2005:

Imminent sea-level rises, increased hurricanes, and desertification caused by “man-made global warming” would lead to massive population disruptions. In a handy map, the organization highlighted areas that were supposed to be particularly vulnerable in terms of producing “climate refugees.” Especially at risk were regions such as the Caribbean and low-lying Pacific islands, along with coastal areas.

The 2005 UNEP predictions claimed that, by 2010, some 50 million “climate refugees” would be frantically fleeing from those regions of the globe. However, not only did the areas in question fail to produce a single “climate refugee, by 2010, population levels for those regions were actually still soaring. In many cases, the areas that were supposed to be producing waves of “climate refugees” and becoming uninhabitable turned out to be some of the fastest-growing places on Earth.”

Whoops.

When I read stuff like this, it makes hard for objective people like myself to determine where the hype ends the facts start.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by greeneggs on Friday April 08, 2016 @01:42AM (#11452775)
> When I read stuff like this, it makes hard for objective people like myself to determine where the hype ends the facts start.

You are confusing a political prediction with a scientific prediction. What scientists were saying that there were going to be large sea-level rises between 2005 and 2010?

(Assuming that you are serious, since you don't point to any source, and your text is incorrectly quoted.)

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by Houshalter on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:40PM (#11451571)
Some people do blame the civil wars in the Middle East on climate change, though its a bit indirect. That worse weather caused food prices to soar that year. That did happen around that time and caused a refugee crysis.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by jessaustin on Thursday April 07, 2016 @08:05PM (#11451681)
Food prices in the Middle East have far more to do with Mubarak's disastrous cronyist agricultural policies than with global warming.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by Houshalter on Thursday April 07, 2016 @11:13PM (#11452356)
But there were bad droughts that year that affected food prices world wide, and it wasn't just Egypt that was affected.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by jessaustin on Friday April 08, 2016 @12:39PM (#11455971)
You're looking at the short term. Yes, grain prices would have been high that year anyway. But Egypt is not naturally dependent on imported grain; it took decades of mismanagement to make it so. If planting decisions had been made by independent farmers as they had been for millennia, Egypt would have retained the wheat-growing capacity that it had for millennia. In that situation, higher grain prices would actually have been good for Egypt. Instead, through Mubarak's twisted cronyist version of land reform, farmland was taken from real farmers and given to shadowy corporations who misused it in various frivolous schemes like growing flowers for Europe for a few years until it was unsuitable for further agricultural use.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by vonmoltke on Friday April 08, 2016 @09:52AM (#11454633)
So, if the government is capable of developing contingency plans for handling droughts and doesn't, it's the drought's fault when shit hits the fan?
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by Houshalter on Friday April 08, 2016 @09:56PM (#11459517)
Do you not understand that events can have multiple causes? Rarely does disaster require just one single thing to go wrong.

In any case, it wasn't just egypt that had uprest that year. Egypt wasn't even the first country to have problems.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by merpnderp on Friday April 08, 2016 @09:19AM (#11454424)
I go by what the IPCC states. As poor as its past performance has been in refining the science into accurate predictions, it is by far the best source of "scientific consensus" we have. And there have been many papers published over the last 20 years claiming a whole number of things.

James Hansen has been wrong so many times in the past, I'm not sure why anyone still listens to him. And if you have any feel for the data at all, several meters of sea rise in 50 years should strike you as nearly impossible. There's certainly no strong (or even weak) evidence for this.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by vonmoltke on Friday April 08, 2016 @09:48AM (#11454599)
Hansen, at this point, is about supporting his preconceived notions rather than trying to understand what is actually going on with the climate system.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by criley2 on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:58PM (#11451032)
". But if you go by scientific consensus, we're looking at 1-3 feet.

Lol you can't just invent things and call it consensus, or disregard actual sources as "histrionics" because what they say is inconvenient for you.

Here's actual consensus:

>With successful, strong mitigation measures, the experts expect a likely rise of 40-60 cm in this century and 60-100 cm by the year 2300. With unmitigated warming, however, the likely range is 70-120 cm by 2100 and two to three meters by the year 2300 [Source: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277379113... ]

10-15 feet, or 2-3 meters, is the currently accepted consensus estimate of a worst case scenario (total polar ice melt). It's also conveniently the consensus estimate of historical water levels before the current ice age millions of years ago.

The water on Earth being 3 meters higher than today is not revolutionary, is not without precedent, and will absolutely certainly occur on this planet in the future.

Of course, once we warm enough for the arctic methane positive feedback loop to rapidly warm the climate, the worst case scenario becomes far more likely in the 100 year window instead of 300 year window. Only with strong mitigation does scientific consensus agree that we can delay the worst case 2-3m estimates caused by total polar ice melt.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by mattb314 on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:17PM (#11451140)
Worth noting that (a) this is an analysis of scientific consensus, so environmental effects (like the "arctic methane positive feedback loop") should already be included in the numbers if such effects are significant, and (b) GP was referring 1-3 feet in the next century, which matches your quoted numbers of 70-120 cm reasonably closely.

Still, interesting source.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by criley2 on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:20PM (#11451156)
"(b) GP was referring 1-3 feet in the next century, which matches your quoted numbers of 70-120 cm reasonably closely."

Critical difference is that 1-3 feet is consensus in one case: dramatic mitigation measures.

1-3 feet is NOT the estimate for 100 years of no-action. In that case, "histrionics" as the other poster condescendingly and incorrectly called it, are far closer to reality than rosy projections of strong mitigation that simply is not manifesting in any industrialized nation. Heck, with the global recession of 2008 depressing economies and fuel usage and thus carbon emissions, many nations believe they have made progress when economic downturn is the source. We are not mitigating at all so 1-3 feet is hopelessly optimistic under today's reality...

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by vonmoltke on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:01PM (#11451390)
Read it again. 70cm - 120cm is for "unmitigated warming", per your source. The person you are quoting is correct.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by douche on Friday April 08, 2016 @07:14AM (#11453851)
> 10-15 feet, or 2-3 meters, is the currently accepted consensus estimate of a worst case scenario

In what archaic system of measurement is a meter five feet? 1m ~= 3.28 ft

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by tremon on Friday April 08, 2016 @11:26AM (#11455332)
The Netherlands is accounting for up to 1.3 meter (4 feet) of sea level rise by the end of this century, and 2-4 meter (roughly 12 feet) by 2200 [1]. Note that the report is not just focusing on the sea level rise itself, also its secondary effects (increased salinization of land and prolonged droughts) which would make fresh water more scarce.

[1] (2008, in Dutch) http://www.deltawerken.com/1392

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by tobltobs on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:31PM (#11451224)
It absolutely baffles me that those climate change deniers do not even understand that the rise of sea levels will not be the same everywhere.

But maybe gravity is only a invention of some "gravity histrionics" also?

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by douche on Friday April 08, 2016 @07:25AM (#11453878)
You know, they could go to south Texas, where there's plenty of inland areas with low population density east out to the Gulf. It'd be on the same, or lower, lattitude than KSC. It'd also be closer to Johnson Space Center, where they already have Mission Control and astronaut training. It's probably cheaper to rebuild/move everything from Kennedy than to try to save Florida.

The only thing that might be a problem is if the political pork-barrel process can't stomach not distributing NASA money across two areas instead of one.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by nkrisc on Thursday April 07, 2016 @04:53PM (#11450636)
Storm surges during hurricane Katrina reached heights of nearly 12.5 meters in some places. Would Dutch protections have held against that?
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by gozur88 on Thursday April 07, 2016 @09:17PM (#11451950)
Did Florida's? If you're planning to deal with multi-meter storm surges there's no point in worrying about a 1-3 ft increase in MSL.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by czechdeveloper on Thursday April 07, 2016 @04:41PM (#11450527)
Rising water is no problem in comparison with big storms which are not known in Netherlands. At least as far as I understand.
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by tosseraccount on Thursday April 07, 2016 @05:22PM (#11450834)
"The majority of the Netherlands lies under sea level"

Clarification: "26 percent of the country is below sea level"

http://www.reuters.com/article/us-climate-seas-idUSTRE61C1V4...

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by clishem on Saturday April 09, 2016 @12:18PM (#11461896)
Thanks for your correction! I was genuinely unaware and made a mistake interpreting a map. The majority of the Netherlands (55%) is actually at risk of flooding.

Fun fact I found while checking the source of my mistake; the IPCC report of 2007 also made this error: http://www.pbl.nl/en/dossiers/Climatechange/content/correcti...

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by Joof on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:07PM (#11451424)
How we use language vs reality. It's still a lot though!
Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by pilsetnieks on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:09PM (#11451088)
> A highly populated area or industrious zone might get a rating that only a flood every 10.000 years is acceptable, while for some rural areas may get a rating that a flood every 300 years is acceptable.

Or until a king decides to flood the country to stop an army from advancing.

Re:NASA Is Facing a Climate Change Countdown by tobltobs on Thursday April 07, 2016 @06:36PM (#11451252)
Sea level rise at the Netherland coast will not be as high as the sea level rise in Florida. They could be lucky and their coast is just at the sweet spot where the sea level will neither decrease (which would suck for Rotterdams harbour) nor rise.