Urbanites & Europeans don't seem to grasp how far it is between the affordable/cheap housing and the "tech centers" in downtown wherever (or how vast the USA is in general). I've got a reasonably good housing price in the 'burbs, but that means a 40+ minute drive in (leaving before 6:00AM, every minute thereafter = a minute longer drive), and 90+ minute drive back (leaving at 4:00PM prompt, again gets worse the later I leave). Sure, there's lots of cheap land not far out, but a major media company isn't going to relocate there, and us contractors aren't going to relocate just to be close to it.
We also average bigger homes, roughly twice the size as in Europe.
Well, I'm probably an exception, as I've travelled all across the US (several coast to coast road trips and such, from Highway 1 to Route 66 and loads more).
But I don't see a 10, 20 or 30 mile commute as a problem. He have those in Europe too, and in much worse highways or congestion in some cases (e.g. inside the city one can spend 30 minutes to get across 5 miles).
>We also average bigger homes, roughly twice the size as in Europe.
True, but also a lot of trailers and projects, which one doesn't see much, if at all, in Europe. The closest will be some small, confined, old buildings in Eastern Europe. (And I think our "projects" equivalent are much better).
On the commute you're assuming that because driving 30 miles down the highway is easy you don't also have to cross through the city once you get there to get to the office. Take that 30 mile commute, say that takes 20-25 minutes to get 25 miles of it down the highway to the city, now you're in the city, so now you add the 30 minutes it takes to get through those last 5 miles now that you're in the city dealing with the same traffic as a city resident. Now you have the reason why the commute is worse. You still have the same commute through the city, unless the office and is on the edge of the city and you live on that end as opposed to the opposite side so you don't have to go through or around.
But certain urban centers have become popular living locations for (mostly) people right out of school. They may also be near customers, especially in finance and related industries. (Even when engineering offices were in the suburbs/exurbs, it's always been fairly common for enterprise tech companies to have downtown sales and consulting offices.)
Access to transit (if you're in the boonies I can't get there without a car)
good coffee shops
Decent bike infrastructure
Ease of physical meetings with clients and other companies, which still matter
etc.
Which is an (invisible) cost created by big lot sizes. Which has many nasty consequences. It creates scarcity of housing, longer commutes, requires more infrastructure (roads, power lines, drainage, internet, etc). It in turns makes the economy as a whole less efficient, and in consequence less competitive. Salaries are insufficient, etc.
Houses out in the country are indeed pretty cheap but if you work in the city, then you pay for it in terms of a long, ugly commute.
If you are a remote tech worker, or your job happens to be in the next town, then you can have a large, inexpensive house on many acres of land with a 10-minute commute. Lots of people happily live like this, but they have no presence on HN. I know people who bought their first houses in their early 20's but they lived in towns you will never hear of.
$64/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/504-1st-St-Rolfe-IA-50581/...
$142/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/288-Gilly-Holw-Cumberland-...
$156/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/1522-11th-St-Columbus-NE-6...
$160/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/4309-Polly-Ave-Gillette-WY...
$168/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/2516-Jefferson-Dr-Bluefiel...
$174/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/716-Main-Ave-Denton-MT-594...
$177/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/1418-8th-St-S-Virginia-MN-...
$206/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/415-Routon-St-Paris-TN-382...
$212/mo: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/912-17th-St-Racine-WI-5340...
Even something like Section 8 ends up putting upward pressure on housing prices (it removes some of the bottom end of the market by paying landlords the difference between the market price for rent and what HUD deems the renter can afford). I don't object to the idea of the program, but it is easy to look at it and see that paying landlords the prevailing rental rate is going to dis-incentivize the creation of cheaper housing.
There's also a lot of friction in zoning processes, so incumbents have a fair shot of overriding good sense.
I'd argue though good schools in NC is a relative term. (I'm a native, and a product of their schools which I often argue I'm successful in spite of, so I can make that criticism.)
I do know lots of tech workers that live in the middle of no where, work remote, and make 6-figures and live like kings while living on large plots of land paying very little in taxes and have mortgages equivalent of a car payment, but they live 2 hours from anything and I'm not sure what they do for Internet beyond basic DSL. If you have a purely WFH job this is doable. They only have to leave their house once or twice a week maybe for a trip into town on the weekend and end up making up for it by traveling heavily to central offices or customer locations for big projects or F2F situations.
You can ask the same question of companies, I often wonder why SF companies are even based in such an expensive cities when their workers can do their job from almost any physical location. The issue still is proximity, they want their workers to be close to each other and close to a talent pool they can pull from.
Even with highways and fast travel times to the city doesn't stop you from suffering the same issues with traffic and other commuters once you get to the city. I live outside the city I work 30 miles away and 50% of my commute is getting from the city's edge, to the city center, dealing with tons of lights, random traffic jams, finding parking, and walking blocks to my office. I lose 2 hours of my life a day of personal time for cheaper housing, and I've considered many times moving to a more expensive location just to gain almost 8 hours of my week back.
In many cases, not even that. I have coworkers who live in rural areas who only have satellite as an option.
I'd live in the mountains, miles from anyone, and work remote if I thought I could get decent broadband and find a company that was okay with me working 100% remote. Finding the job is the easier of the two, most place I want to live have little more than electricity and telephone services.
But the US has huge empty countryside, vastly expansive residential areas, AND, for the most part, houses that to European sensibilities seem like made for dolls (thin wood panels for walls, cheap construction, no concrete or real bricks to be seen, etc). And parts are much cheaper than in Europe.
Both of these factors should keep prices very very low. $600 per month micro homes? You can get $600 per month regular, spacious home, in a city like Berlin -- and much lower in other places.