News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't become an expert by oostevo on Monday February 22, 2010 @11:52AM (#1143070)
I think he's missing the point.

So many people (Gladwell, Cohen, and apparently the Brazen Careerist person) have referenced this 10,000 hours claim, but no one has cited the actual research paper that came up with this notion. The paper actually addresses almost all of his points.[1]

"There are more high school swimmers than ever, therefore more opportunities to find and train great swimmers. They have access to diet, training, technology, and facilities that didn't exist years ago. That's all." Yes! That's the point! The authors of the research point out that "the fastest time for the marathon in the 1896 Olympic Games was just a minute faster than the required entry time in ... races such as the Boston Marathon," _because_ people now know the proper way to focus their efforts at practice.[2] 'Practice,' here, being training and diet. But it still takes 10 years or so of _deliberate practice_ to become world class. It's just that the bar for world class has been moved.

"I'm a case in point: I practiced the piano for an hour a day for more than ten years. I became good, but there were others who practiced twice as much who were worse, and still others who practiced less and are much better." Again, he is unwittingly supporting the 10,000 hours claim. The study points out that "the view that merely engaging in a sufficient amount of practice, regardless of the structure of that practice leads to maximal performance has a long and contested history."[3] It is not just 'putting in the hours' that matters (because then one falls into the trap of assembly-line-worker syndrome, where "improvement of performance was often arrested at less than maximal levels"), but rather what it calls "deliberate practice," which takes quite a bit of very hard work and practice tasks that are defined in a very specific way. (There's a good description of the characteristics of deliberate practice on p. 367 of the study). That is, people who just practice for hours without much thought as to what that practice should be and how it will challenge them in new ways are doomed to be less successful than those who are coached through a process of deliberate practice. It's quality, not quantity.

All that being said, I don't think being an entrepreneur actually has anything to do with being an expert. It's much more luck and hard work. Cohen gets around to saying this too. I agree with him. I'm just not sure why he felt the need to try to refute the current literature on becoming a domain expert to say, "Hey, becoming a domain expert probably isn't your goal. Your goal is to become an innovative entrepreneur."

[1] http://projects.ict.usc.edu/itw/gel/EricssonDeliberatePracti...

[2] Ibid, p.366

[3] Ibid, p.365

--> Edit 1: matrix cited a more recent text by the same author I was describing: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1142983

--> Edit 2: Oops. The Harvard Business Review article that Penelope Trunk talks about was actually written by the same person who wrote the paper that I cited and the book that matrix referenced, so my "but no one has cited the actual research" claim was inaccurate: http://www.coachingmanagement.nl/The%20Making%20of%20an%20Ex...

Re:Don't become an expert by smartbear on Monday February 22, 2010 @01:10PM (#1143287)
Thanks for the excellent critique of my article!

You're right, the point I'm making is that becoming THAT KIND of so-called "expert" isn't the point of a company.

Actually I'm not refuting arguments about how to become an expert in the first place, I'm refuting the idea that you NEED to do that. I believe that theme is pretty clear throughout.

Finally, if it really does take 10k hours and ONLY if it's a special kind of dedication, then it's almost a tautology, and an irrelevant activity for almost anyone on Earth.

Re:Don't become an expert by skmurphy on Monday February 22, 2010 @03:42PM (#1143659)
I think Jason is ignoring is the core of Ericsson's insight, the value of deliberate practice.

Jason highlights the value of getting started, that startups are a "come are you are party" but seems to suggest that passion can substitute for learning from your mistakes. This sounds like the "Little Engine That Could" model (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Little_Engine_That_Could ) of repeating "I think I can, I think I can,..." which is no substitute for learning from your mistakes.

What's the best way to learn from your mistakes? What Ericsson calls "deliberate practice." Here is a simple example that I think most entrepreneurs would find readily applicable, taken from an interview with Anders in Fast Company (see http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/110/final-word.html ):

"Medical diagnosticians see a patient once or twice, make an assessment in an effort to solve a particularly difficult case, and then they move on. They may never see him or her again. I recently interviewed a highly successful diagnostician who works very differently. He spends a lot of his own time checking up on his patients, taking extensive notes on what he's thinking at the time of diagnosis, and checking back to see how accurate he is. This extra step he created gives him a significant advantage compared with his peers. It lets him better understand how and when he's improving. In general, elite performers utilize some technique that typically isn't well known or widely practiced."

This model is certainly directly applicable to both engineering and sales & marketing problems.

Re:Don't become an expert by smartbear on Monday February 22, 2010 @04:58PM (#1143850)
To me, "deliberate practice" is a cop-out. If you practice like crazy and still aren't good, it's because it wasn't the RIGHT practice?

It's like the horoscope saying "keep your eyes open for an opportunity today." If an opportunity doesn't appear, it's because I wasn't open enough.

You can't tell me Michael Phelps is fastest because no one else practiced as deliberately.

It sounds like an excuse to avoid admitting that there are also innate differences between people, and luck.

Re:Don't become an expert by lief79 on Monday February 22, 2010 @05:39PM (#1143954)
Well, it's rather obvious that 10,000 hours of practicing golfing strokes without spending any time learning how to aim would be a waste of time.

From what I can see, this doesn't inherently conflict with your claims about innate differences or luck, but it does indicate that there is value in practicing things correctly and potentially little value in practicing things incorrectly. Obviously a fully grown 4 foot individual won't become center for the basketball team, but only practicing 3 point shots won't help someone who is 7 feet tall do much better in the pocket (under the net).

Can you please explain what I am missing?

Re:Don't become an expert by smartbear on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @10:43AM (#1145569)
What you're missing: That many people do "deliberate practice" and yet there are large differences in skill.

Of course flailing around isn't practice. The notion that "perfect practice makes perfect" or "practices doesn't make perfect, it makes permanent" has been around forever, no need for special studies to explain that.

But everyone at the Olympics, for example, has done extreme, deliberate practice, and yet most of the competitors are so bad they don't even televise it.

Finally, the point of the article IS NOT about HOW to become an expert, it's questioning the notion that becoming an expert is necessarily the goal.

Or, saying that you become successful at [anything] as a by-product of your work, not because you become "an expert" and THEN do interesting work.

And further, that people (like Penelope) shouldn't get hung up on being "an expert" by some arbitrary definition when she's in fact quite successful and could be just focussed on what to do next.

Re:Don't become an expert by lief79 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:37PM (#1149030)
I agree with the last 3 points, I was only responding to your previous post.

Take a look at the original studies, or the Scientific American article for a quicker read. (I read it in paper form, so you can probably find it as easily as I can).

As for deliberate practice, the idea sheds some light onto the right and wrong ways to do it. It seems to come back to the theme of "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance". Deliberate practice is paying attention to the quality of the practice, and continuing to improve the quality. If this is accurate, then it should increase the differences in skill, as the individuals address their own various physical limits. It seems that the difference in the quality of the practice is one of the reasons people pay more for experts to teach them. I think the Olympics can just as easily be used to support the idea, as everyone's practice routines will vary.

Furthermore, studies of conventional wisdom often reveal conventional wisdom to be wrong, so I can't dismiss them. If the results make it easier for people to successfully perform "deliberate practice", then they will probably be well worth the money spent.

Re:Don't become an expert by skmurphy on Monday February 22, 2010 @06:11PM (#1144029)
My answers are yes, yes (everyday gets opportunities every day, but as Edison observed "too often they are dressed in overalls and look like work"), mix of ability and practice, and I agree that people are different and different teams get different opportunities.

But it sounds like relying on luck and innate differences is an excuse for not learning from your mistakes. This is a "Random Walk" model for startup success where you begin at a random point (your innate abilities) and wander buffeted by luck in some kind of entrepreneurial Brownian motion.

Clearly luck plays a role, but I believe, like Pasteur, that "inspiration only favors the prepared mind." You have to know what you are looking for in advance. And it turns out this skill can be learned as well.

Reasonable men may differ, but I think there is considerable evidence that experience helps startups differentiate beyond naive ability or luck, and that deliberate practice prevents you from experiencing the same event over and over without learning from it.

For another take on this see Carol Dweck's mindset model at http://www.mindsetonline.com/ which documents research that folks who believe that effort makes a difference learn faster than those who trust to innate ability.

What's most pernicious about this belief is that it can lead you to manage people in a way that doesn't admit of their ability to improve.

Re:Don't become an expert by orc on Monday February 22, 2010 @01:29PM (#1143349)
I think this is an important question - do you "NEED" to become a 10,000 hour "expert" ?

I would never want to stereotype the entire population of earth and say that you're a failure if you're not an expert at something. Is it good to be an expert? Of course. But it's not required - there are many paths to life.

Re:Don't become an expert by gcheong on Monday February 22, 2010 @02:49PM (#1143542)
"All that being said, I don't think being an entrepreneur actually has anything to do with being an expert. It's much more luck and hard work."

Isn't that kind of the unifying theme between the 10k hour domain expert and the innovative entrepreneur? That both require the ability to work and persevere through setbacks beyond what most people care to do in order to be successful?

Re:Don't become an expert by yason on Monday February 22, 2010 @01:54PM (#1143409)
In short: becoming world-class is getting to the top N percent and depends on the number of people willing to practice for being world-class.

It seems that currently we've settled to 10 000 hours because 10 000 hours seems to reduce the number of candidates enough to make each "survivor" a real expert.

If suddenly more people started to practice 10 000 hours, you would possibly need 15 000 hours to distinguish yourself back to the top N percent among the horde of damn good (by our current standards) piano players, programmers, or whatever.

Being world-class also depends on the subject: the world can take only so many world-class piano players because the audience is somewhat limited, but it can absorb many more programmers because there are roughly infinite number of interesting and useful project to be done.

Re:Don't become an expert by lmkg on Monday February 22, 2010 @01:06PM (#1143275)
> It is not just 'putting in the hours' that matters (because then one falls into the trap of assembly-line-worker syndrome, where "improvement of performance was often arrested at less than maximal levels"), but rather what it calls "deliberate practice," which takes quite a bit of very hard work and practice tasks that are defined in a very specific way.

As my wrestling coach always told us, "practice doesn't make perfect, perfect practice makes perfect."

Re:Don't become an expert by mhb on Monday February 22, 2010 @02:13PM (#1143452)
That and genetics.
Re:Don't become an expert by ConceptDog on Monday February 22, 2010 @12:22PM (#1143145)
Yup. Missed the point. Entrepreneur ship ends up being a very subjective experience, where the measure of success doesn't always end in profit.

The 10k hour rule tends to apply to subjective accomplishments with little variable reward. The reward for practice is very linear (depending on the person), you usually get better and improve the more time spent. Someone could spend 10k hours being an entrepreneur and fail depending on the context.