News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by andrewljohnson on Monday February 22, 2010 @03:51AM (#1142291)
FYI, Apple has been super-fast recently in approving updates. My last two updates were both approved the following day, and the last app I submitted took four days to approve. I think the review process should be abolished, but they are making it better at least.

And I agree with other posters - this screw-up is mostly the developer's fault. Even if he's not savvy enough to do automated testing, if he played his own game, then he would have caught the bug while the app was sitting in review.

Re: by tehdik on Monday February 22, 2010 @02:54AM (#1142217)
Wait so the developer screwed up, and then he screwed up... again? Why is this Apple's fault and how did this make it into my rss feed?
Re: by bensummers on Monday February 22, 2010 @03:31AM (#1142270)
I think his objection is that the process means bug fixes are really slow to appear, and he has no way of communicating with his customers.
Re: by pyre on Monday February 22, 2010 @03:44AM (#1142283)
Seems more like he's upset that it took a week for Apple to approve the update, and somehow with a week of 'review' they didn't catch his bug for him, which is a ridiculous notion. Does he really believe that Apple's reviewers spend 8 hrs/day for a week reviewing just his application?

Aside from that, the AppStore approval process does not claim to be his software QA team. So he should really stop complaining and do more testing before he releases a product, because approval process or no approval process, when you submit your App to the AppStore you are publishing your code to the world. If it's not up to snuff at that point, it's your own damn fault.

Re: by DeusExMachina on Monday February 22, 2010 @04:07AM (#1142304)
Yes, I know that was my fault, I think I made it clear, but obviously it wasn't clear enough. I updated the post.

What is really upsetting is that now I have no means to fix my error. I know I'm not the first one to complain about this.

Sorry for the misformulation.

Re: by j23tom on Monday February 22, 2010 @03:28AM (#1142266)
Apple's approval process is screwed, because of delay. It's simple isn't it ?
Re: by jrockway on Monday February 22, 2010 @02:48AM (#1142204)
Apple is not your automated test suite. Add a test for "game is possible to lose", and make sure it passes before you release.
Re: by lurch_mojoff on Monday February 22, 2010 @03:27AM (#1142264)
More like not his QA department.

And to the author of that blog post, dude, how bloody entitled do you have to think you are to bitch that Apple didn't catch an obscure bug in your application. What do you think they do, play through every scenario of every game? If you had made a, say, unit converter, do you think that Apple would check if all your conversion formulas are correct? Do you think they should?

The review process is in place for one purpose - so Apple can protect iPhone users from things that are obviously detrimental to them and their experience with the device - things like obvious crashes, like obvious use of private APIs (which would lead to obvious crashes at some future point), and like obviously inappropriate content.

Re: by dbz on Monday February 22, 2010 @03:41AM (#1142278)
Well. Developer is at fault for not testing his software. Apple is at fault for taking weeks to approve a bug fix.

Quality of the app store is irrelevant because it appears apple is just trying to be in control and stop viruses and the like.