Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by Freak_NL on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:58AM
(#11416535)
That is the only correct answer.
.+@.+
In human language: an email address consists of something, an @, and something.That's it. The name part can be anything; so don't validate it beyond having a character.
We don't have one-character domains yet, but there is no reason to exclude them. It is already possible to arrange your own top-level domain if your pockets are deep enough (.google), so don't be surprised if some megacorp starts using a top-level domain without any subdomains. Don't validate the domain part beyond having a character.
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by userbinator on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:20PM
(#11416606)
Sending an email is the only way to be sure.
Absolutely this. The check for an '@' and something before/after it is for sanity, and anything beyond that would involve actually trying to use the address.
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by s_kilk on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:18PM
(#11416597)
> If you were to ask me for a regex, I'd say /.+@.+/
How about "one@two@three@[email protected]"?
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by mcv on Monday April 04, 2016 @03:58AM
(#11420132)
Any validation is also going to allow "[email protected]", unless you send an email to it.
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by ketralnis on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:24PM
(#11416622)
Yes there are loads of invalid email addresses it allows. It's not supposed to be perfect.
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by Freak_NL on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:44PM
(#11416706)
Yeah, the point of checking for the @ is chiefly to prevent inexperienced users (e.g., elderly) from entering the wrong type of data. For example, enter a line from their postal address instead of their email address.
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by LinuxBender on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:27AM
(#11416432)
# get email addresses
grep -EiEio '\b[A-Z0-9._%+-]+@[A-Z0-9.-]+\.[A-Z]{2,4}\b'
# censor email addresses
sed -r 's/(<)[[:alpha:][:digit:]\._%\+-]+@[[:alpha:][:digit:]\.-]+\.[[:alpha:]]{2,4}(>)/\1--removed--\2/g'
If email doesn't meet those, I drop them on the floor. Then again, I drop email on the floor for lesser reasons.
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by Symbiote on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:19PM
(#11416603)
So you're blocking email from your local .museum, from anyone who has an Irish name like O'Connor, all international TLDs, and most newer TLDs.
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by LinuxBender on Monday April 04, 2016 @09:53AM
(#11421850)
Yes.
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by lstamour on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:13PM
(#11416582)
So any new gtld longer than four characters would be dropped on the floor? E.g. .software? If you're trying to censor email addresses from a file, that doesn't work that well. :)
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by LinuxBender on Monday April 04, 2016 @09:53AM
(#11421848)
Yes. Actually for the longest time I rejected the connection with "Your name is too awesome!"
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by mcv on Monday April 04, 2016 @04:01AM
(#11420144)
This would not allow email addresses with an = in them, which I've had. The point of my overly tolerant regex is exactly that: any more restrictive validation is going to drop some perfectly legal email addresses. Sending an email is the only way to be sure.
That's the easiest and most accurate way to do it by regex. Sure, some invalid addresses may still get accepted, but that is unavoidable. Even the most thorough validation[0] is going to accept nonexistent addresses.
[0] Except those that validate by sending a mail to it. Sending an email is the only way to be sure.