News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own?

What scientific or intellectual area is open for a single person to tackle and answer problems within the domain? For example, it is theoretically possible for a person to be a self-taught Mathematician but it is not feasible given the lack of credibility, and given where Maths is going, it is more and more a group effort.
( 9 comments | 10 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by Someone on Sunday April 03, 2016 @06:18AM (#11415614)
If you think "lack of credibility" would be a problem in math, little remains, as math is one of the most objective sciences (Yes, unless you find a proof that Fermat could have written in the margin of one of his books nobody will read your P=NP proof if it is the first thing you publish, but chances are that that Proof contains a few new ideas that you can present in isolation)

In biology, almost everything not genetics or biochemistry is easy to enter. You can easily (as in: focus and persevere) become the world expert in, say, spider or mushroom species in your local area and possibly discover some new species, or study the behavior of some animals in the wild and publish new findings. It's unlikely you will find a huge audience for it that way, but that's not to be expected, even if you work at a well-funded institution.

And it is possible to become somewhat well-known using this route. For a (semi; he has an education in biology) example, see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kees_Moeliker

You can also fairly easily go on expeditions such as ones trying to find out whether species X truly is extinct. It mostly requires not being asocial, being truly interested in the goals of the expedition, and paying for it yourself (see it as a holiday)

Other fields probably are similar: look where the money goes, choose a different subject area, and it is likely you can contribute.

Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by dmfdmf on Sunday April 03, 2016 @01:47AM (#11415088)
I think physics is ripe for a revolution. We know Einstein's theories are incompatible with Quantum Mechanics but the path to reconciliation is not obvious or it would have been done already. Its unlikely to come from inside the profession, even by "fringe" groups like the Perimeter Institute, which isn't really fringe but pretends to be.

Math is the ideal place for the independent outsider. The "group" mathematicians are just pushing the current fields to their logical conclusions, nothing wrong with that but its unlikely to create a new area of math or find anything profound. Its like mathematical engineering, using the tools/ideas that are known, and a safe career path. If an outsider has a proof people will listen.

The only other area I can think of would be computer science and inventing a true AI and not an AI mimic like Microsoft's recent twitter embarrassment, but in my view that would really be a development in epistemology with AI as its first application.

So do you think you are a genius? How old are you?

Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by T-A on Sunday April 03, 2016 @05:35AM (#11415528)
Special relativity was unified with quantum mechanics in the 40s. The result is called quantum field theory; it's the most successful physical theory we have.

Attempts to quantize general relativity abound. A handful which anyone interested will mention off the top of their head: http://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2015/12/17/what-...

The problem is not just conceptual or mathematical, it's a total lack of experimental data. Even if you write down the correct theory of quantum gravity, you have no realistic way to test it - but you can rest assured that everybody pursuing a different approach will be right there telling you that you are an idiot.

Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by schmatz on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:47AM (#11414968)
I think what you said about mathematics applies for the rest of science in general - it's more and more of a group effort. That being said, I think there is ample room for innovation in emerging areas like biohacking.

There is also something to be said for analyzing all of the new datasets coming online and trying to gather new insights (this is also the least capital-intensive option!)

Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by dluan on Sunday April 03, 2016 @10:34PM (#11419043)
Almost any scientific pursuit can be independent, but it's more a matter of dedication and determination rather than feasibility.

It just happens that most people who achieve a lot on their own usually stay out of the limelight or public eye. This is especially true in ecology or biology.

Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by arvinsim on Sunday April 03, 2016 @10:39PM (#11419057)
I would agree with the other comments here. Pushing the limits in an area means getting all the help that you can. Peers help you on some blind spots that you are not aware of.
Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by danieltillett on Sunday April 03, 2016 @03:58AM (#11415341)
I think most new comets are discovered by amateurs.
Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by T-A on Sunday April 03, 2016 @05:19AM (#11415489)
Re:Ask HN: Scientific pursuits that are feasible on your own? by danieltillett on Sunday April 03, 2016 @05:25AM (#11415507)
The amateurs are the ones combing the SOHO data :)