So fundamentally VR has more potential than AR. Things like nausea may take some time to work out but they're not unsolvable. For example, if the issue is the disconnect between the acceleration/orientation sensors in your ears and the virtual reality we can just bypass those sensors and inject a signal directly into the relevant nerves. It might even be possible to do this through the skin in combination with training. The frame rate/resolution issues will also improve until eventually virtual reality will be indistinguishable from reality (ignoring tactile input for a sec). Sure physical movement in this environment is another problem. But the end game is something that is simply incredible/unimaginable.
With AR- sure you can add more synthetic information over reality. You still have tactile challenges (you can't touch it or interact with it). It is very difficult to combine seamlessly with the outside environment to make it more than just a fancy heads-up-display.
Not saying AR isn't cool and full of potential but I don't think we can compare its potential with VR. VR is the holodeck... AR is ... a heads-up display? Not to mention the need to carry AR with you wherever you go if you want to use it in the "real world", power it, compute, etc.
EDIT: One more thought while I'm at it. You can always inject the real reality into VR and thus make it AR but you can't remove reality from AR... Or if you could the two would basically merge. So AR can be seen as VR with "transparency" ... And VR is a superset of all ARs where you can't completely remove reality.
Fundamentally, VR just has a different potential than AR.
> Not to mention the need to carry AR with you wherever you go if you want to use it in the "real world", power it, compute, etc.
You need to carry the VR headsets and their host-devices with you too.
I believe we should clearly delineate the definitions of VR vs AR first.
Virtual Reality should be things like The Matrix. A reality that an individual experiences without modifying the real world for anybody else. Current technology simply shoves a screen right up against our eyes but the goal is obviously to plug that content straight into our very brains.
Augmented Reality should be things like an audio speaker or a video display; devices that "inject" manmade media into the real world; devices which generate reproducible experiences that everybody, even animals, can see, hear, touch and smell.
In AR a single device may provide content passively to multiple viewers. Like your music system or television or a hologram generator. Even your pets can see and hear whatever's playing and they certainly don't to purchase or wear anything.
VR aims to interface with your neurons and you're guaranteed to experience the full content. AR projects content into the real world which may or may not bounce on to our senses.
TL;DR: VR replaces reality. AR enhances reality. But that's just my opinion. :)
And to maybe extend the discussion abit, what about devices that plug right into the centers of consciousness. Is that just more invasive, arguably better AR or is it VR? What do better hearing aids that sample at 10 ghz and connect directly to the nerves instead of hair cells. What are they considered? What about when I pipe my FLAC uncompressed music through the hearing implant -- VR or AR? It seems like the future is a combination of the two in far more complex ratios than just one or the other or split screen. VR probably has limits of perceptiveness if it fails to take model of logical non chaotic reality. It therefore can eventually become an abstraction of an existing event or well..present stimulus. Anyhow, I think the ideas are all really profundo. Looking forward to replies.
[1] https://teddybrain.wordpress.com/2013/08/28/a-brief-review-o...
TV can be considered a primitive form of reality augmentation. As I said even your cat can see and hear what's on. Even aliens who see in an entirely different spectrum (or don't have any vision at all) will be able to pick up the colors and sounds generated by that TV, through their monitoring instruments (just as we can "see" infrared and detect magnetism etc. through our tech.) A television set modifies reality in the space occupied by that set, for everyone, however minor that modification may be. By that definition I suppose even paintings can be considered AR.
Again this is just my opinion. I don't know how the Star Trek holodeck exactly works (in-universe) but it would be AR, as I'm assuming that anyone outside the holodeck will be able to see the generated visuals if they were to peek in through a hole, as it were.
Or looking at it another way, isn't VR just AR with the lights off?
See, that definition is much much technically simpler.
I couldn't agree more completely. I live in a physical world, and my god I wish I could connect it better to the information world.
I don't care at all about VR. I'll try it because it's new, but I have close to zero interest in gaming and beyond that there a very few use cases where it is interesting. Design maybe, but a lot of these uses cases actually work better as AR anyway.
You argue that we can bypass the orientation senses by injecting signal into nerves, but that the tactile challenge in VR is impossible?
Yes, you have to wear it. But glasses aren't a big deal - and will keep getting better - and AFAIK you have to wear VR gear too.
Mmmh... you say you agree with the previous poster but your message seems to disagree completely.
So AR is the superset of VR, where a physical cover makes them identical when it is on.
And VR doesn't cause nausea. Bad applications cause nausea.
You can interact with others, your environment, and other systems without the isolation or nausea of VR. On top of that, being able to supplement the real world instead of only temporarily replacing it seems far more valuable to me.
Now we just gotta shrink it down to contact lens size, and we're good to go!
edited for formatting