News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Chinese Room Argument by Esspe on Saturday February 20, 2010 @05:26PM (#1139609)
In my opinion, this argument have existential consequences: either it's not possible to emulate mind on turing machine or we don't have qualia and consciousness (it's just the illusion, that we have). And i don't like the latter.
Re:The Chinese Room Argument by camccann on Saturday February 20, 2010 @05:42PM (#1139638)
we don't have qualia and consciousness (it's just the illusion, that we have)

An illusion experienced by whom?

What's the difference between having an illusion of consciousness and having the real thing?

Re:The Chinese Room Argument by jerf on Saturday February 20, 2010 @06:54PM (#1139747)
"What's the difference between having an illusion of consciousness and having the real thing?"

Primarily, the word "illusion".

At this point, having read up on these issues for a while, anytime I see the word "illusion" now I tend to just shut the book/leave the webpage/whatever. Have you ever, once, seen someone sit down and say what they mean by "illusion", or give a way of telling you how to distinguish between "illusion" or "reality"? Maybe you have (no sarcasm intended), but I've never seen it, and without that the word basically just marks someone who is trying to sound insightful without doing the hard work of actually being insightful and saying something without leaving an enormous linguistic void right in the center of the argument.

Re:The Chinese Room Argument by DrJokepu on Saturday February 20, 2010 @07:35PM (#1139811)
Whether consciousness is only illusion is of no consequence. This path of thoughts (just like Berkeley's subjective idealism or its modern form, the Matrix movie) ain't leading anywhere (besides madness) hence it can be classified as solipsism.

In my opinion, what matters that you experience consciousness, life, happiness or sadness. Have great meals, love the people who love you, do cool stuff as a 'hacker'. Your life will be as 'real' as it could get, whether it's an illusion or not.

Re:The Chinese Room Argument by ThomPete on Saturday February 20, 2010 @05:37PM (#1139627)
The argument is so flawed I don't even know where to beging.

It's the room that is conscious not the person. Of course the person can't speak Chinese. Neither can the neuron in my brain.

Re:The Chinese Room Argument by foldr on Sunday April 04, 2010 @02:27PM (#1240571)
That's the "systems reply", which Searle addressed in his original article. So I'm not sure which argument you're talking about.
Re:The Chinese Room Argument by Grinnmarr on Saturday February 20, 2010 @05:52PM (#1139661)
It's not just your opinion ;) This argument is about the nature of consciousness more than anything. It fights for a "subjective ontology" of the mental and is not easily dismissed as the earlier commentator would like to believe. The rapidity of upvotes and apparent sympathy to that claim by members of this community is certainly understandable given that the stance is anti-verificationist and presents problems for a purely scientific explanation of consciousness, but imho at our current level of intelligence/intellectual evolution a purely scientific explanation is horribly dehumanizing and insufficient.
Re:The Chinese Room Argument by radu_floricica on Saturday February 20, 2010 @07:03PM (#1139765)
Take a look at "Society of mind" by Marvin Minsky. We already understand pretty well that the mind is a colony of mostly independent system, working in various configurations. Here's the first chapter: http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/minsky07/minsky07_index.html

As far as I'm concerned, qualia is just a fancy synonym for "soul". I don't miss it one bit. Consciousness on the other hand, that we have. Only it turns out to be a more elusive concept then we once thought.

Re:The Chinese Room Argument by shib71 on Saturday February 20, 2010 @05:34PM (#1139623)
And the former isn't a particularly useful conclusion. The results of doing the research have a lot of potential. What potential does not trying have?
Re:The Chinese Room Argument by gphil on Saturday February 20, 2010 @08:07PM (#1139857)
Huh? How do you get from:

(1) It is possible to emulate the mind on a Turing Machine.

to:

(2) We don't have qualia or consciousness.

In my opinion, there's nothing about (1) that entails (2).

Re:The Chinese Room Argument by dhume on Saturday February 20, 2010 @08:21PM (#1139866)
According to the "Chinese room" argument, a machine is not capable of genuinely understanding a language (since it is only looking up and applying transformation rules). It is generally believed that a human can, so that would mean a human mind cannot be fully emulated by a Turing machine. The only alternative seems to be that a human actually has the same limitation as a Turing machine (non-consciousness) and does not really understand language either.