also, if you actually read the link you'll see that it's placed in context, with the "systems reply" explained in detail.
To a software person who's given AI some thought, the holes in Searle's argument are glaring. I had a very awkward conversation in college with a philosophy student who had just been taught it and was taking it very seriously; I guess they have a lot of reverence for Great Thinkers who hand down Deep Insights, whereas to me this guy Searle sounded like an imbecile.
Despite my initial horror at someone's taking the Chinese Room argument at face value, I realize it raises interesting questions about the chasm between AI's starting point (e.g. playing chess with S-expressions) and real human-like intelligence. I think we have more perspective on the problem these days for countless reasons -- work on understanding how subsystems in the brain work, being able to build or simulate neuron-like systems, applying powerful computers to a wide variety of problems.
The big questions that remain are ones like whether a human brain can be simulated; how brain-like a machine would have to be to "understand" things -- self-aware? neural-network-like? embodied? -- and to what extent constructs like language reflect deep structure of the mind (i.e. human firmware we have to reverse engineer and duplicate) rather than universal logical constructs.
Have you ever read the Chinese room article? It's pretty clear if you read it that Searle isn't an imbecile. The vast majority of "refutations" of his argument simply miss his point entirely. (Which is basically, "Why on Earth would you think that merely performing the same computations as a human brain could cause conscious experiences?")
> I guess they have a lot of reverence for Great Thinkers who hand down Deep Insights
Really? I've never met any philosophy students who fit that description.
An illusion experienced by whom?
What's the difference between having an illusion of consciousness and having the real thing?
Primarily, the word "illusion".
At this point, having read up on these issues for a while, anytime I see the word "illusion" now I tend to just shut the book/leave the webpage/whatever. Have you ever, once, seen someone sit down and say what they mean by "illusion", or give a way of telling you how to distinguish between "illusion" or "reality"? Maybe you have (no sarcasm intended), but I've never seen it, and without that the word basically just marks someone who is trying to sound insightful without doing the hard work of actually being insightful and saying something without leaving an enormous linguistic void right in the center of the argument.
In my opinion, what matters that you experience consciousness, life, happiness or sadness. Have great meals, love the people who love you, do cool stuff as a 'hacker'. Your life will be as 'real' as it could get, whether it's an illusion or not.
It's the room that is conscious not the person. Of course the person can't speak Chinese. Neither can the neuron in my brain.
As far as I'm concerned, qualia is just a fancy synonym for "soul". I don't miss it one bit. Consciousness on the other hand, that we have. Only it turns out to be a more elusive concept then we once thought.
(1) It is possible to emulate the mind on a Turing Machine.
to:
(2) We don't have qualia or consciousness.
In my opinion, there's nothing about (1) that entails (2).
The purpose of philosophy is to protect us from bad philosophy.
Nicely put. I like Wittgenstein's way of putting it as well, "What is your aim in philosophy?--To shew the fly the way out of the fly-bottle." (Philosophical Investigations 309)