Sure, generic sort algorithms come "off-the-shelf", but that is not true for all algorithms. Not all algorithms are public knowledge if they are patented, proprietary, or restricted in use/distribution.
You really need both - algorithms and data, right? And systems of execution for algorithms... and networks to interconnect the systems... and potentially humans to review the algorithm's output... and..... and... and..
I think the key is, algorithms can also represent embedded capabilities (information? knowledge? insight? not sure what to call it) generated from data. I mean, look at a RNN - the values/weights/etc. calculated inside the model are calculated from observations/training on the data. Once you disconnect the algorithm from the data itself, the algorithm alone now has embedded value without the data, potentially enormous.
Or, expert/rule-based systems which contain algorithms explicitly designed to embed human knowledge - those algorithms may not even be trained on actual data, they are simply a simplified expression of codified human knowledge.
If you go one step further and try to make some assumption that the way our brains work is by codifying inputs we receive into algorithmic models... and then using those algorithms to calculate based on new inputs from the environment... we can't keep all the data in our heads, but we can probably keep more algorithms than data.
Maybe I'm being too philosophical, but in my opinion, it's not just about the data.
Philosophically you can reduce them to the same thing, but practically speaking you wouldn't really want to.
Hence, companies like Palantir and Pivotal that provide this service. To say that the ability to interpret data is ubiquitous is simply wrong.
Algorithms are public knowledge, commodities to be written and rewritten at will by common, workaday developers.
I don't think the article is talking about sorting a linked list. Clever and non-trivial algorithms are being researched and discovered everyday both in academia and the industry (take ML as an example). Programs = Algorithms + Data (Structures). You can have a competitive advantage on either or both.Facebook - good luck having a news feed algorithm with no actual stories and status updates
Google - good luck having a search algorithm with no actual search index
Amazon - good luck recommending products to others if you zero data on what others are recommending.
With all 3, you can at least create a minimum viable algorithm if you have the data.
That being said I agree that having access to data that no one else has is a massive competitive advantage and with your skepticism about the concept being presented.
For those of us who have no data, algorithms are the most valuable things.
E.g. with Google Search it is was perhaps the algo at first but now I'd say it is partly that and partly the high barrier to entry in obtaining all the data (although the data itself is freely available)
Data is where the value is, because you're the only who has it. It's your competitive advantage. It's your secret stash that no one else can access. And if you're willing to ship it halfway around the world to a microservice provider based on flashy marketing, well, I've got a bridge to sell you before your VC money runs out.