The idea that Bitcoin developers are competent and Ethereum developers aren't is simply not borne out by basic observations of what the two camps have been doing lately. And the market is responding to that. Hence, this article.
Proponents of cryptocurrencies could easily fix this by creating one that grows by k% forever (like Friedman's k-percent rule). But they won't because this destroys the "get rich quick" aspect of the technology which they won't admit is the main thing they are drawn to.
If they were serious they would have fixed this problem and made sure bitcoins generate long run inflation.
Could bitcoin's popularity stand on its own with just its net benefits as a transaction medium after the allure of ponzi investment has been removed?
Plus, Bitcoin isn't deflationary by any standard definition of the word. It's not inherently price deflationary of course, since that's dictated by demand. And the money supply inflates, albeit at a known predictable rate which slowly decreases over time.
This supports the hypothesis that cryptocurrencies are not useful as currencies and people mostly like them for their ponzi investment allure. This would make them not viable in the long run, the digital equivalent of gold but with even less intrinsic fallback value.
The latter I'd say are better served by a currency that encodes a price stability algorithm rather than a hyperdeflationary one. The former on the other hand...
Bitcoin or Altcoins are not a get rich quick scheme. They provide value for users by making transfer of wealth globally possible. The traditional infrastructure cost for this is many trillions of dollars (you pay it with taxes and inflation).
Otherwise, it basically blocks net aggregate marginal investment. It transforms people's savings from being tied to real physical things that are going to create value in the future when they want to redeem those savings to an accumulation of idle bits that won't be able to produce anything.
This is also the reason too low inflation in the eurozone for example, is so destructive.
Bitcoin is volatile, but its extremely useful as money (if you live in Argentina or Zimbabwe, etc.). Descendants types will be far superior to government debt as money. Deflation basically means price-appreciation versus other assets. Inflation as its currently happening is fraudulent accounting on a unprecedented scale. The blockchain by contrast offers honest computer based accounting.
Because they were late in their money printing, velocity dropped and they had to print much more getting much less effect per unit and yes did put the world at risk of future spike of inflation if this money starts moving.
Sufficient high, well controlled, early enough inflation prevents velocity from dropping, prevents the investment and labor markets from jamming, prevents from having to print too much, prevents large stockpiles of idle money from accumulating and prevents later difficult to control spikes in inflation.
You mean, it could be useful as money in theory, but in practice it is not. It is not practical to meet one's needs transacting in bitcoin even in affluent regions where computers, internet access and general computer literacy are ubiquitous, so those economically strained regions where citizens are struggling just to meet their basics needs are places where bitcoin is a complete non-starter; it is not at all viable.
There is no evidence whatsoever that "too low inflation in the eurozone is so destructive". You're mistaking dogma with fact.
I disagree. When I learned about what can be built with the Ethereum Virtual Machine, I quit my job to build decentralized applications full time.
You can either wait for decentralized apps to work their way into your life, or you can ignore the naysayers and find out for yourself if these tools are worth building with.
It's not great, but if you look at Ethereum you'll see the same distribution (2 pools have 50%, 4 pools have 75%) and Ethereum does not have anywhere near the same throughout load, which is where most of the centralization pressure comes from. Further, Ethereum is supposedly much more vulnerable to selfish mining attacks, which means a pool that decides to start doing selfish mining should be able to overtake the others in terms of profitability very quickly.
Any details on this?
- https://twitter.com/lopp/status/673398201307664384
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3vn0go/photo_on_sc...
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/3vn984/decentrali...
Work -- any form of work -- is subject to industrial scaling effects and economies of scale:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_scale
Meanwhile all these POW-based currencies have deflationary economics and deflating mining revenue due to rising difficulty. That makes less efficient mining less profitable over time, driving smaller miners out of business and accelerating the effect. Any proof of work based system like Bitcoin or Ethereum will in the end be monopolized by whomever has the cheapest electricity, cooling, and hardware, and the most labor-efficient mining operation.
This is the most powerful bearish argument on Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies that I have. Gold and other hard currency materials are randomly distributed by geology and physics, helping prevent total monopolization of mining. Paper currencies are monopolized by default, so you know it's controlled by the Fed or some government... the devil you know. But these things are guaranteed to be monopolized by... uhh... we don't know yet. You could end up with a currency controlled by Kim Jong Un or Dr. Evil and his white Persian cat. (I'll take Dr. Evil.) Serious global organizations are not going to adopt a reserve currency whose future control is up for grabs by whomever can build the most efficient data center and/or snow over the development community most effectively.
That's why Chinese miners have so much power on the Bitcoin block chain. Cheap coal and a total lack of an EPA makes power very cheap for them, and they also have local access to very cheap labor and cheap hardware production.
In the very long term if Bitcoin or any other POW-based currency became cumulatively worth enough, someone in a chilly place like Russia, Scandinavia, or Canada could build a hydroelectric powered arctic circle (free cooling) super data center full of ASICs and own the entire block chain. There are places on Earth with unbelievably cheap power (big hydro, constant prevailing winds, etc.) and free cooling due to a cold local climate. A coastal location in the arctic using arctic seawater for cooling and a dam on a local river would be ideal. Nobody would be able to compete with that.
Bitcoin has two big things going for it, at least insofar as the mainstream market is concerned:
1) The 2008 financial crash and its terribly bungled and corrupt aftermath destroyed peoples' long term faith in the "devils we know," creating essentially a market niche for a competing financial system that offers better governance and transparency. Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc. and the many companies working in these ecosystems are trying to address that niche.
(Side note: I wish the West's leadership would wake up and realize just how profound a loss of confidence occurred in 2008-2009. I don't think the effect has manifested yet. It's too deep and profound a loss of faith and the population is still processing it.)
2) Existing methods of sending cash overseas like Western Union are absolutely freaking horrible. We've used Bitcoin to pay overseas contractors because it amounts to only one root canal vs. Western Union's three or four tooth extractions with pliers per payment. Bank wires requires that I physical visit a f'ing physical bank, which is even worse.
That means though that Bitcoin's advantage would disappear if:
1) Entities like the US Federal Government and the Federal Reserve took actual steps to reform themselves and implement a plan of action for dealing with things like the 2008 crash that is more honest, equitable, and well thought out than "yank money out of our arse and hand it to other Yale alumni until the fires go out."
2) Companies like Western Union realize they are in the 21st century and act accordingly, implementing low friction easy to use methods of wiring money with low fees.
Bitcoin would still have a niche if those two things happened, but its niche would be smaller and probably further outside the mainstream of commerce.
Of course if Bitcoin ends up controlled by the Chinese PLA, none of those above advantages might matter much.
This requires having enough miners willing to mine at a loss, just like we have millions of people willing to play the lottery at a loss.
In fact mining should be made to resemble an ongoing lottery as much as possible, by
1) limiting the custom hardware efficiency advantage to less than an order of magnitude, using a memory bound PoW
2) allowing users to mine with a single click, either to install an app that mines on their smartphone while charging overnight, or from their WebAssembly supporting browser
You could argue this would be morally superior to one sustained by bloodshed and political power mongering. (Fiat currency is ultimately backed by state power, a.k.a. violence.)
Maybe a workaround is to make a banking institution that cannot be corrupted by people. It buys and tests (maybe prints?) it own hardware, it check-sums itself continuously. It patrols its own perimeter. It fixes what it can and it crashes gracefully forever when it finds itself compromised. Of course, the research (yet alone engineering) problems it presents are huge and I doubt that a sovereign computer system is something desirable.
Bitcoin's major problems are scale, miner centralization, and developer centralization. Ethereum is worse than Bitcoin in all three respects. Transactions on Ethereum are heavier, develoepment is very heavily controlled by the Ethereum foundation and by Consensys, and the block algorithm in Ethereum more strongly favors larger miners as compared to Bitcoin (which already favors bigger miners).
Further, the Ethereum develoepment team is under qualified. There have been several ametuer mistakes, including allowing negative balance, leaking private keys, and putting consensus at risk by advocating that different users should be running different consensus codebases. Most of the highly capable developers in the cryptocurrency ecosystem avoid Ethereum because it's not been constructed well, nor does it's design suggest strong resistance to adversarial environments.
Bitcoin did go through similar growing pains. Bitcoin did have many ametuer mistakes when getting started. But those have all been fixed, and there is a positively enormous amount of competent mindshare powering Bitcoin, and the thoroughness of decentralization in Bitcoin is unmatched by any altcoin, including Ethereum.
Ethereum has offered a lot of cool tricks with its turing complete scripting language, but is standing on a house of cards. It scales less well than Bitcoin, it's design more heavily promotes centralization, it's development is more ametuer, and the potential applications offered by its fancy scripting language are not actually that much stronger than what you can do with Bitcoin. The showcase applications such as Augur and Slockit suffer from weak cryptographic fundamentals and under-qualified developers even worse than Ethereum does.