I can't fix my car but I can pick a garage based on reviews, etc.
And you have a lot more information available about stocks than you do about fund managers.
If you have this, you can get by with a very small portfolio, often just a handful of stocks. And the only ongoing effort is to periodically re-evaluate whether the market has caught on to the information advantage that you're trading on. You do need to continue to keep informed, but daily trading is ridiculous.
If you do not have this, you will lose your shirt regardless of how much you diversify.
Yeah, exactly my point. You need to spend >20 hours to research a single company and will chose to invest in 1 out of 10. Those are the optimistic numbers.
So 5 stocks is 1000 hours. How many hours to learn how to do your due diligence? How many hours per month, every month to keep an eye on what is going on and optimize if necessary?
- Smartphones > dumb phones (invest in AAPL)
- more dollars spent with online ads than TV and Print (invest in GOOG)
- cloud computing is better than managing your own servers (invest in AMZN)
- eating Chipotle is a better option than McDonalds (invest in CMG)
These information advantages are not necessarily gained by spending many hours of research, but a side effect from every day living and working. Will a research analyst realize the impact of a scalable computing API more than engineers that relies on it for their careers?
A future example: If you're a programmer using Github for every job in the past 10 years, maybe buying Github stock if it IPO's wouldn't be so bad.
Only in Silicon Valley would people give Peter Thiel credit for an concept that's been around for 150 years of investing.
>maybe buying Github stock if it IPO's wouldn't be so bad.
Maybe? That doesn't sound very certain, and demonstrates how difficult it is to pick these things in advance. Do you know, or not?
I mean, it's all well and good to look back at some ideas that were good investments, in hindsight. Do you not think armies of people are trying to find "good" ideas that no one knows about? How many good ideas went nowhere?
Without a hypothetical IPO price, that question is unanswerable.
I honestly still agree with your general point, but that's not specifically a valid argument.
As a retail investor, you have no visibility into any of this. Most asset management companies will not let you interview their fund managers, and most fund managers won't divulge their research strategies if asked. You basically just get their pedigree and resume, which is useless.
With individual stocks, you can at least choose to put in the legwork to do your research. Or as sibling commenters have suggested, you may get it tacitly by being embedded in the same industry as the company you're thinking of investing in. Someone who works in tech and is a user of AWS is in a much better position to judge the importance of a new AWS product announcement than someone who covers Amazon as an outside analyst.
If you have 100k to invest, better put them in the bank and don't bother with "investing".
I've seen this happen many times.
The usual advice for beginners is to revise ones portofolio between long intervals, say, once per year, record the specific reasons a purchase or sale was done, and progress with patience and not running after the market.
Stocks with dividens provide an interest to ones investment regardless how their price evolves in day trading.
If you're not able to take advantage of such things, I really don't understand the appeal.
(but then - having such large sums of money that I need help investing them would be quite a nice problem to have!)
If I've consistently picked terrible stocks for years, performing at 20% less than the market, and then I meet a fund manager who has has consistently performed at 20% above the market, are you suggesting I can't know whether or not he's better than me?
This was after adjusting for survivorship bias.
So, you cannot look at performance as an indicator.
Surely you have an idea why you picked stocks that seemed good ideas but were not. What was the missing piece of information you did not have or the missing model you were not using?
Whether stock picking is luck based or not, there are (almost) no fund managers currently working who performed 20% under the market over the last 5 years.
I'm not sure this is right. You wouldn't say that you should be designing if you think you can hire a designer. There's no reason that hiring a good fund manager is different.
For what it's worth, I'm not good at picking managers or picking stocks with my own money so I choose a parsimonious approach.
If you think you are able to pick out better fund managers, then you should be picking stocks instead. If you're unable to pick stocks, what makes you think you're able to pick managers when you are working off opaque trades and even less information?