News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by sounds on Thursday March 24, 2016 @11:23AM (#11353511)
I think Robin Murphy, Texas A&M Professor, has the right suggestion for Google. No idea if Google will actually do it.

> If I were a large company with deep pockets, I would accept that robotics is what is called a ‘formative’ market and just like shopping on the web, it will take a decade or so to ramp up. Robots are innovations that do not directly replace people and thus it is hard for people to imagine how to use them—thus the market is formative. The theory of diffusion of innovation indicates that potential end-users, not developers, need to experiment with applications to see what works (and not just physically but human-robot interaction as well).

> However, robots have to be extremely reliable and the software customizable enough to allow the end-users to tinker and adapt the robots, so that the end-user can find the ‘killer app.’ Essentially, you can crowdsource the task of finding the best, most profitable uses of robots, but only if you have good enough robots that can be reconfigure easily and the software is open enough. I would concentrate on creating generic ground, aerial, and marine robots with customizable software and user interfaces in order to enable their regular employees (and customers) to figure out the best uses.

> In order to make sure the development was pushing towards the most reliable, reconfigurable, and open robots possible, I suggest the developers focus on the emergency response domain. Disasters are the most demanding application and come in so many variations that it is a constant test of technology and users. Imagine the wealth of ideas and feedback from fire rescue teams, the Coast Guard, and the American Red Cross, just to name a few! Focusing on emergency management would also have a positive societal benefit.

Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by jpm_sd on Thursday March 24, 2016 @12:10PM (#11353972)
Xoogler here. There is zero chance that Google would get into this market. All the internal talk lately is about "only creating businesses at Google scale" which means $billions in potential revenue, or GTFO.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by grandalf on Thursday March 24, 2016 @12:21PM (#11354073)
Yes. And thus Google treads softly down the path to becoming a defense contractor.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by massemphasis on Thursday March 24, 2016 @01:13PM (#11354550)
That is the only path not available to the dominating robotics countries of Germany, Japan and Korea who are literally under the gun not to develop such arms and weapons (without approval of the US).
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by i_laugh_at_you on Thursday March 24, 2016 @04:34PM (#11356194)
I don't believe you. Virtually maybe but literally? Even if virtual I still do not believe you. Sounds like hyperbole.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by massemphasis on Thursday March 24, 2016 @06:10PM (#11356895)
Literally the US can dictate what kind arms they can develop. It is required they comply to receive consideration for US military aid and to remain under the US nuclear umbrella (from other nuclear armed countries like China, India, Russia, etc...).
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by NotSammyHagar on Sunday March 27, 2016 @04:24PM (#11371389)
Those countries also don't want to spend too much money on their military. So they can't develop nukes, their citizens don't want that. We actually want them to spend more, not less, like Japan. South Korea actually built automatic turret guns that shoot without human control. So I call BS on the evil us wants to stop them from building robots.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by emcq on Thursday March 24, 2016 @12:44PM (#11354309)
This if exactly the perspective at funding large projects at IBM Research. Interesting that the industry R&D labs fund more like top VCs in that regard.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by massemphasis on Thursday March 24, 2016 @01:09PM (#11354517)
That is not surprising since the robotics market is already dominated by other companies from Germany, Japan, and Korea. DARPA made the mistake of opening their competition to Korea, and Korea dominated the competition with an innovative robotic design. It was obviously far ahead in terms of practicality and their design could already be used today.

Google is trying to enter a market already dominated and pieced out.

Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by conceit on Thursday March 24, 2016 @04:19PM (#11356097)
As a German with an interest in computer and electrical engineering looking for a viable career path, I'd like to know, what companies are y'all talking about?
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by eigenvalue on Thursday March 24, 2016 @06:06PM (#11356878)
And KUKA, which makes the best arms in the industry.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by conceit on Friday March 25, 2016 @07:50AM (#11359540)
That's the kinda arms-industry I like.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by rasz_pl on Thursday March 24, 2016 @05:02PM (#11356407)
for example Festo
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by cowardlydragon on Thursday March 24, 2016 @06:05PM (#11356867)
Didn't Microsoft do that game? It was one of the signs of their decline.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by jinushaun on Thursday March 24, 2016 @08:02PM (#11357542)
That sounds a lot like a famous quote from Steve Ballmer as he watched Internet startups pass Microsoft by in the fast lane...
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by Dwolb on Thursday March 24, 2016 @08:11PM (#11357588)
Agreed. The underlying assumption seems to be the employees at Google can spin up billion dollar businesses at will.

...which begs the question if I were able to spin up a billion dollar business at will, why would I work for salary and a minority equity stake at Google?

Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by shas3 on Thursday March 24, 2016 @01:01PM (#11354448)
I can think of few large companies that don't strategize that way, yet there is usually room for widgets.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by DannyBee on Thursday March 24, 2016 @02:53PM (#11355349)
FWIW, this is not "lately". It was the same talk 10 years ago in GPS, etc.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by sounds on Thursday March 24, 2016 @01:07PM (#11354494)
I just hope Google learns from Android (the phone) and applies "lessons learned" when they start making androids (real robots).
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by whitegrape on Thursday March 24, 2016 @03:51PM (#11355878)
The emergency response domain is what you use when you've got nothing better in mind for an application of your hardware. It's a dead-end. (Except I guess for Murphy.)
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by cookingrobot on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:56PM (#11358231)
I agree with the first 2 points, but the last doesn't follow. Disaster response isn't a good domain for end users to play around with different configurations to see what works. Few people are first responders, disasters rarely happen, and when they do it's no time to be experimenting with your homebrew robot.

Something that's closer to a consumer / small business task, and is tedious, common, and not critical to get right would be a better problem space to explore.

Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by robg on Thursday March 24, 2016 @05:27PM (#11356587)
Sadly, this market is very limited. iRobot, who had a lot traction here, just sold off these robots for peanuts relative to what they make on vacuums.

http://media.irobot.com/2016-02-04-iRobot-Announces-Sale-of-...

Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday March 24, 2016 @11:31AM (#11353588)
Isn't this an example of a Scientist speaking outside their area of expertise? Not substantially different from a Physicist speaking on Literature or History.

Personally, I don't see a mission-critical application for robotics any time in the immediate future. Low-risk deployments will yield data, not rescue teams. Firemen have no time to fool with experimental gadgets.

Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by robotresearcher on Thursday March 24, 2016 @11:43AM (#11353699)
Robin Murphy has been doing reacue robots her whole career. Her team had robots at the WTC site. Very few people know more about this area than her.

It's appropriate to be skeptical of course, but don't dismiss the expertise of someone before looking them up.

Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by throwaway287391 on Thursday March 24, 2016 @02:05PM (#11354971)
I really don't understand where GP's comment comes from...you don't even need to look her up; Robin Murphy's byline in the article itself makes it clear that she is a CS professor who directs a center for robotics. How could you possibly compare somebody with that set of credentials commenting on robotics to a "physicist speaking on literature or history"? As someone who's typically a bit skeptical of such allegations, the only explanation for GP's comment I can come up with is sexism... (But I'd be interested to hear any more charitable interpretations or an explanation from the comment's author -- I'm really pretty baffled by the comment.)
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by conceit on Thursday March 24, 2016 @04:23PM (#11356125)
Because econ is usually a different faculty
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by throwaway287391 on Thursday March 24, 2016 @05:32PM (#11356619)
...what? She is a professor of CS & Engineering according to the byline in the article, and upon Googling her, I find no reference to her teaching economics or any other non-CS/Engineering discipline elsewhere. And unless ctrl+f is failing me, "econ" isn't mentioned anywhere in the article (except "economically" once in someone else's comment) or in this comment thread. So I have no idea what you're talking about.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by conceit on Friday March 25, 2016 @07:48AM (#11359531)
She talks about econ and, as you diligently pointed out, that's not her area of expertise, exactly. OTOH I would assume that a professional does have a clue about adjacent topics.
Re:What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with It... by vonmoltke on Thursday March 24, 2016 @11:44AM (#11353712)
> Firemen have no time to fool with experimental gadgets.

TI and Raytheon have used local police and fire departments as test customers for various electro-optical systems for decades. They are amenable, as long as they get the systems and support donated to the department.