News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by hackuser on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:17PM (#11338644)
A rarely discussed benefit to minimum income: The higher the social benefits, then I think the greater the labor market liquidity, for both employers and workers.

Currently everything else depends on your job: Either you have one, and you have income, benefits, and all that goes with them in a society where everything costs money; or you don't and you have nothing (or very little). But if you don't lose you house, still can afford decent healthcare, and your kids still eat and go to college, etc., then employees can be more flexible:

Firings and layoffs are less of a crisis; when everything doesn't depend on having that job then I expect there will be fewer lawsuits. Protections for jobs in law and regulations can be reduced.

Also, workers, especially those with mortgages and kids, would be less desparate to keep their jobs. I think that is a healthy thing; they can take more chances and invest more in training and skill acquisition. Also, they are not compelled to do odious or unethical things (such as working off the clock, tolerating abusive environments, particpating in and/or not reporting illegal activities, etc.) due to a sort of employment extortion. It probably would be better for managers to get more honest feedback too (though some would have to learn ways to motivate people besides abusing them!).

Some of that is speculative but I believe a European country, I think Denmark, worked out a compromise of high and long-term unemployment benefits in return for making workers easy to terminate.

In part it's also a political solution to the concentration of wealth: If you are going to accumulate so much of the wealth due to the way the economy is structured, then in return pay for these social benefits and we all can retain labor market liquidity and maintain political harmony. U.S. workers have less to bargain with: They gave away many of their labor market protections and lost negotiating power by weakening their unions.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by manyoso on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:28PM (#11338729)
Some other major reasons people support UBI are:

* Eliminating poverty and reducing economic inequality

* Simplifying the social safety net

* Preparing for a future where jobs have been automated

* Stimulating entrepreneurship

* Giving people the freedom to pursue their passions

* Paying caregivers for their economic contributions to society

* Recognizing a livable income as a human right

* Paving the way for a new American Dream in the 21st century

Taken from this survey: https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/5NFBGBV

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by pborowicz on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:15PM (#11339651)
Something I haven't seen talked about, but seem obvious to me. This would revitalize so many rural communities that lost or never had a major industry supplying jobs. This would stem the flow of youth out of places like Kansas or Upper Michigan. Can you imagine how much this would mean to communities like this?
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by pyoung on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:56PM (#11339891)
This could potentially have some positive secondary effects on the more populated areas as well. SF rent/home prices are insane, and part of the reason is due to the supply of good jobs. With less pressure to relocate to job centers, we could see an easing of demand in those areas. And this is a good counter-argument to those that claim a BI would just results in higher prices for everything.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by jpadkins on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:48PM (#11339451)
> Recognizing a livable income as a human right

I was with you until that one. The fundamental right to other people's wealth is a very slippery slope. I believe human rights should only be negative rights.

> Paving the way for a new American Dream in the 21st century

reads like political marketing fluff. dilutes the message.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by hackuser on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:29PM (#11340090)
> The fundamental right to other people's wealth is a very slippery slope.

All rights - everything a society does - require contributions from others. The premise that people somehow create wealth all by themselves and therefore have no obligation to share it is false.

Everyone's wealth depends on enormous contributions from everyone else, current and past. How did they build their app without the free K-12 education (and the education of your teachers), the roads, telecommunications, laws, protocols, police ... the economists whose centuries of work have provided the wealth your investors and customers have; the scientists who developed the theories; all the open source developers who gave away their work and set open statndards; the soldiers who work for paltry wages in the crappiest working conditions in the world, and some of whom died, to provide the security necessary for our economy and society to survive; the political leaders who generation after generation have built democracy and civil rights ... whoever developed English and the ones who developed C++ ...

All these people give us the opportunity to thrive. Do you think we would do so well without them? Are many startups happening in Somalia or Syria? Why should you or I be excluded from contributing and pulling our weight?

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by gwright on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @07:36PM (#11340846)
> All rights - everything a society does - require contributions from others.

The concept of positive and negative rights is pretty well defined. If you are going to assert that all 'rights' are positive rights you need to do a tad bit more explaining.

> The premise that people somehow create wealth all by themselves and therefore have no obligation to share it is false.

You are throwing up a straw man. No one asserts that wealth is created 'all by themselves' at least according to the definition you seem to be using. It is also difficult to know what 'obligation to share' means. Does that mean "obligated to pay my taxes" or does it mean "obligated to support arbitrary redistribution schemes and government policies" or does it mean something else?

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by sre_ops on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:21PM (#11339216)
It will be swallowed by an immediate increase of the price of goods and services UBI would be spent on.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by DiffEq on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:01PM (#11339046)
Yet nowhere has this been "field tested" for any length of time. Unless one makes the case that it has been tested in the form of several countries in the 20th century. Places like the the Soviet Union, China, etc. We see that it failed in those places and in Soviet countries it failed fantastically. The fatal flaw in all of this...who is going to pay for it?
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by sbuttgereit on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:24PM (#11339241)
That and what economic activity will be suppressed as capital moves away from prior uses. Nobody is talking about generating new wealth to make this happen: it's pure consumption and some of that will be at the expense of capital investment. The seen and the unseen indeed. Unless there's more than hand-wavy dismissive talk about the negatives such schemes bring, one is foolish to think that this does anything positive at all.... and that's just the utilitarian perspective.

Morally, that any one person, by virtue of their relative wealth alone, is judged a provider, at gunpoint if necessary, to others who, by virtue of their relative lack of wealth alone, is considered worthy of substance, is such an inversion of right and wrong as to warrant some serious soul-searching about what makes one worthy of punishment or reward. Yes, poverty is a problem. Yes, there are institutional barriers to getting out of poverty. I don't see how doubling down on those problems does anything than ease the conscious of the haves.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by kbenson on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:42PM (#11339390)
> Morally, that any one person, by virtue of their relative wealth alone, is judged a provider, at gunpoint if necessary, to others who, by virtue of their relative lack of wealth alone, is considered worthy of substance, is such an inversion of right and wrong as to warrant some serious soul-searching about what makes one worthy of punishment or reward.

That makes quite a few assumptions about the nature of money, the ownership of money, and how it is accumulated. Given, those assumptions are shared by most people in capitalistic systems, but that doesn't mean they are sacrosanct and we should reexamine them from time to time.

For example, one possible interpretation is that it's the system that allows this accumulation of wealth, and that the system favors certain people and starting conditions over others. If we accept that the system is responsible for quite a bit of the wealth (could the same be achieved in a drastically different system, say, North Korea?), then it can be viewed less as taking money from one and giving to another as much as fees and discounts, or incentives and disincentives built into the system in the hope of either making it more efficient in the end or better in some desired respect.

Note: I'm not necessarily pushing the above view, but instead using it to illuminate that perspective informs our opinions quite a bit, and that stepping back and reexamining our assumptions may have benefit or change how we think. At worst it will be a waste of time and we'll come away with the same opinion.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by mikeash on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:53PM (#11339492)
Helping people in need is not an inversion of right and wrong. What's an inversion of right and wrong is declaring somebody to be unworthy of even the most basic sustenance merely because they possess an insufficient quantity of green paper.

Basic human morality is that those who can help those who can't. Once we moved beyond the tribal village the whole question of how that works exploded in complexity and has never been satisfactorily answered, but that basic principle remains.

If Basic Income doesn't work, then obviously that's problematic. But I see no moral problem with the concept.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by shkkmo on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:02PM (#11339555)
> Nobody is talking about generating new wealth to make this happen: it's pure consumption and some of that will be at the expense of capital investment.

I've been talking about how minimum income can make the minimum wage obsolete and thus allow for the existence of a wider variety of jobs (and creation of wealth) that was previously unviable while also fixing the market inefficiencies created by putting an artificial price floor on labor.

> Morally, that any one person, by virtue of their relative wealth alone, is judged a provider, at gunpoint if necessary, to others who, by virtue of their relative lack of wealth alone, is considered worthy of substance, is such an inversion of right and wrong as to warrant some serious soul-searching about what makes one worthy of punishment or reward.

No, completely wrong.

> by virtue of their relative wealth alone

Wealth exists only within an economy and thus is a social construct that makes it's owner intrinsically beholden to that society. Wealth thus increases the moral obligation to the society from which that wealth is derived.

> by virtue of their relative wealth alone, is considered worthy of substance

It is not their lack of wealth, but their mere existence that makes them 'worthy of substance'.

> warrant some serious soul-searching about what makes one worthy of punishment or reward

Taxes on wealth are not a punishment, they are the cost of maintaining and improving the society and allows the wealth to exist.

Minimum income is not reward since it is given to everyone.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by gwright on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @08:00PM (#11340947)
> Wealth exists only within an economy and thus is a social construct that makes it's owner intrinsically beholden to that society. Wealth thus increases the moral obligation to the society from which that wealth is derived.

This notion pops up quite a bit in HN discussion of basic income. Can anybody provide some references to any sort of scholarly work on this concept? Presumably it has been described and discussed in depth and I'd like to be able to understand it better or even associate a name to the concept.

In any case, I'm not sure I follow the logic in this particular description. Why does wealth being a 'social construct' make the 'owner intrinsically beholden' to that society? What does 'intrinsically beholden' mean? These seem like arbitrary and poorly defined assertions to me.

> Minimum income is ... given to everyone.

Define minimum income. Do you imagine it enough to provide food, shelter, clothing? If so explain what other mechanisms would prevent the emergence of a large group of people who simply lived off the efforts of others as a choice. What mechanism would keep that sort of system in equilibrium rather than the consuming group growing and the producing group shrinking and the resulting tensions escalating? And don't we want to construct a system that moves towards a state that maximizes the number of self-sufficient people rather maximizing the number of dependent people?

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by hackuser on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @09:13PM (#11341364)
> Why does wealth being a 'social construct' make the 'owner intrinsically beholden' to that society?

A stab at it: 1) Money is a social construct, as are many other things necessary to make wealth valuable and meaningful; 2) Any person's wealth is due to the 'society' they live in, to a great degree. Consider the roads, laws, political system, safety, education (of the wealthy person, their employees, and customers), wealth of customers/vendors/investors, science, etc. Compare the prospects for wealth and the value of it (i.e., uses for it) for someone in Syria with someone in the Bay Area, for example.

I agree; I'd like to find something more authoritative bout the topic.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by shkkmo on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @01:49PM (#11346640)
> Can anybody provide some references to any sort of scholarly work on this concept?

I didn't realize this concept wasn't self evident. If you have a million dollars, but the economy doesn't value dollars, you have no wealth. I don't have any scholarly references but I would guess you would find discussion of this in the philosophy of economics.

> What does 'intrinsically beholden' mean? These seem like arbitrary and poorly defined assertions to me.

Beholden means "owing thanks or having a duty to someone". 'Intrinsic' (like 'Natural') is a rather empty word, but I was intending it to express that the beholdenment to society arises from the wealth's reliance on society for its existence.

Since the value and existence of your wealth is due to your presence within an economy and society, you are beholden for your wealth to that economy and society in that your wealth would not exist without that economy and society.

> Do you imagine it enough to provide food, shelter, clothing?

Eventually? Yes. I would personally slowly phase in the minimum income as I phased out the minimum wage. Ideally this would cover basic needs and then it would be up to society to determine how much past basic needs would be covered.

> If so explain what other mechanisms would prevent the emergence of a large group of people who simply lived off the efforts of others as a choice.

We all 'live off the efforts of others'. I do not farm the food that I eat, nor do I enforce the laws that allow me to live in safety.

I think what you mean instead, is probably more along the lines of 'live without working'.

Our current model of being dependent on perpetual growth is unsustainable. We already do not have enough low skill jobs for our low skill population. As automation and machine learning take more and more jobs, this problem will only become worse. The new jobs that are being added, tend to be higher skilled knowledge economy jobs.

Thus, we are left with two choices:

1) don't allow people who don't work to live

2) allow people who live without working.

Since I don't support genocide, I feel we have to go with option 2), and the best way of doing that is providing a Minimum Income.

I would also point out, that there is a great deal of work that gets done without expectation of financial reward. This ranges from volunteering time working on open source software, to creating art, to caring for sick friends and relatives. Thus I don't buy into the "work only happens when people are paid" and I think plenty of value will be produced by people who rely on minimum income.

Besides money: Boredom, Social Status, Altruism and Passion can all be strong motivations to work.

A final point here is that by replacing the minimum wage with a minimum income, we greatly increase the number of jobs that can be profitably created. I may not be able to afford to pay the current minimum wage to have a gardener take care of my yard, but with a lower minimum wage I might.

> What mechanism would keep that sort of system in equilibrium rather than the consuming group growing and the producing group shrinking and the resulting tensions escalating?

This is not an easy problem, but I would point out that we have a similar problem with wealth distribution currently.

As far as reducing tensions, I think we need to make an effort to keep classes from segregating themselves socially.

As far as maintaining equilibirium, I don't have any easy answers but I do believe they exist and probably involve some clever use of markets to maintain the equilibirium.

A slow initial introduction of the minimum income helps find tools to maintain the equilibrium as we go.

> And don't we want to construct a system that moves towards a state that maximizes the number of self-sufficient people rather maximizing the number of dependent people?

Like I said before, we are almost all dependent on each other and very few of us are truly self-sufficient.

I don't want to maximize the number of self-sufficient people. I want to maximize the number of people who have the opportunity to do what they love. I want to maximize the amount of enjoyable work that is accomplished.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by Retric on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:44PM (#11339412)
Innovation often happens from the ground up. Harry Potter for example was written by someone on housing assistance. Clearly the England made far more money from her than the cost of her benefits.

Further, if you tax a company at 10% or 20% the same investments are going to profitable. So, for the most part they behave the same which makes corporate tax breaks a very poor investment.

PS: More generally, people with a safety net are far more likely to invest in things like a home.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by dTal on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @07:16PM (#11340724)
Nitpick: Harry Potter was written in Scotland, not England :)
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by nmrm2 on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:38PM (#11339361)
Life isn't fair. So either it isn't fair because a poor person can't claw their way out of poverty while a lazy dullard skates through life doing easy work for Father's friends, or it isn't fair because an enterprizing capitalist who scraped his way up from the bottom is taxed heavily to pay for another's laziness or stupidity. (to fairly characterize both side's straw men.)

Appeals to fairness as an argument for or against various wealth redistribution schemes always strike me as odd for this reason. Neither side gets an exclusive claim to fairness. Both situations can end up equally unfair for equally reasonable definitions of fairness. No society-level policy -- especially doing nothing -- can possibly hope to be remotely fair in at least an infinitely of possible senses of the word.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by VLM on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:37PM (#11339347)
Capital investment and production are effectively dead sectors in our economy. Central bank manipulation that theoretically used to create both, recently has only created financialization bubbles and corruption. That operation model is dead, but still shuffling like a zombie... for awhile. If the factories ARE never coming back, there is no point in being concerned about financing them or goosing the economy to try to encourage them. Its kinda like the transition from agricultural economy to industrial economy, economic terms and theories and S.O.P. and problem areas that used to work are simply obsolete.

If an economic system exclusively rewards the lucky and the corrupt, like ours, then it deserves its destruction. Wealth has no virtue if its source is exclusively non virtuous. Or rephrased, where did the virtue come from that wealth supposedly has? Certainly not from honest labor and skill, not in this economic system, not in the future we're headed toward.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by kbenson on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:30PM (#11339300)
While I would agree Minimum Income is more along the spectrum towards Socialism that Capitalism from our current point, I don't think we can fairly equate it with Communism. There are a few places trying it out though[1][2][3].

> The fatal flaw in all of this...who is going to pay for it?

Well, the simple, possibly simplistic answer is "the same people that pay for wellfare". Which is everyone not receiving it. To be sure, it would need quite a lot of work on the details to even be possible in an economically viable way.

Edit: Added more references.

1: http://www.businessinsider.com/this-dutch-city-is-giving-bas...

2: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11273482 (Alaska)

3: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11273482 (Ontario)

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by warfangle on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:31PM (#11339309)
Soviet Union and China didn't really have a universal basic income. They had a state defined income, if anything. Which meant you couldn't make more than that, either.

It actually has been "field tested" - and in the US of A, no less.

The entire state of Alaska has a guaranteed minimum income.

Granted, it isn't much - on average it's been about $1,000 per anum.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by scrupulusalbion on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:37PM (#11339352)
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by tankenmate on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:42PM (#11339395)
Actually it was tested in Canada; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by Mithaldu on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:06PM (#11339958)
Please review my comment here to consider whether it counts as "field testing": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11339951
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by zanny on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:24PM (#11338695)
Giving workers bargaining power in wage and work condition negotiations is only a good thing, absolutely. It should be obviously unfair to the vast majority of people that you bring two people to the table when you apply for a job (in effect, at least) - a capitalist business owner seeking to profit and accumulate wealth through markets, and someone who doesn't want to starve or go homeless. Those kinds of negotiations are anything but fair.

UBI would see a dramatic shift in the valuation of jobs, in the ways employers can treat their employees, and in what work society values having done. I postulate often how I believe a lot of the tremendous flow of working into the advertising and service sectors has been due to the subconscious social desire to avoid the collapse of work, so we produce fictitious work with minimal or no net productive gains or utility to keep people busy. There are millions of white collar workers who wake up every day in fear of their job being replaced with software, and of truckers fearing the inevitable self-driving vehicle revolution on the horizon, because we are not starting on the path towards automation, we have been on it for decades, we have simply subliminally skewing our society to try to compensate for the implication that real productive labor has been moving out of the hands of human beings for a long time now.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by roymurdock on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:17PM (#11339196)
1. UBI can be thought of as large-scale debt forgiveness. You are simply giving people the means to escape (often, but not always) self-imposed debts.

2. UBI would lead to a huge jump in inflation (as a %, nearly as much as the initial UBI stimulus % of total money in circulation) as the vast majority of UBI recipients would have a large propensity to immediately spend that money, thereby simply releasing it into circulation and ramping up inflation. If UBI were made into a sustained payment, the market would simply adjust prices up on consumption goods accordingly.

UBI doubled the amount of money in circulation? Bread, milk, eggs, and rent cost 2x as much. Of course the effect would not be immediate (rent is sticky) but UBI would not leave much (if anything) left over for the poor today. In the mid-long run the poor are no better off, other than having a few immediate debts paid off through the first few rounds of UBI.

3. UBI leads to the misdirection of resources. People who are not financially secure enough to bring children into this world will suddenly find themselves with the resources to have children. Some, not all, will. We observe fewer and fewer jobs available to the general population, but we have hit a glut in productivity. We do not want to redirect resources to bring more labor into the economy before we hit another period of high productivity brought on by whatever technology drives forward the next paradigm shift in information/goods transportation and synthesis.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by mikeash on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:24PM (#11339242)
I don't understand #2. UBI wouldn't increase the amount of money in circulation, unless you paid for it by printing money or borrowing. But everything I've seen advocates for paying for UBI with taxes.

For #3, the overall trend is that people have fewer children, not more, when they have more money. Maybe UBI money would be different somehow, but since you're positing the opposite effect from what we've seen so far, I think it needs way more support.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by roymurdock on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:09PM (#11339600)
#2 is assuming UBI is a one-time cash injection to stimulate aggregate demand, similar to QE. I have a hard time seeing the path forward to the (substantially) higher taxation on the middle and upper classes needed to make UBI a reality with the current political and economic climate in the US. But this is subject to debate. You are correct that a redistribution of the tax burden, if feasible, would not lead to inflation.

#3 - yes, in agrarian societies poorer people have more children to help out with labor-intensive work. I think the situation would play out different in a services-based economy like the US.

The monetary aspect of UBI would not influence the wealthy, educated cohort's decision to have more children (usually capping out at 3). It would give lower-income individuals an incentive to have more children in order to claim more benefits, as is common for contemporary social services programs. If UBI was substantial enough to allow lower/middle income individuals to quit their jobs, they would also have much more time to have and raise children - not out of necessity, but out of ability.

Agreed that the effect on population size is uncertain and needs an actual study.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by andrewfong on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:43PM (#11339399)
> 1. UBI can be thought of as large-scale debt forgiveness.

Not everyone receiving UBI would be in debt.

> 2. UBI would lead to a huge jump in inflation

Your argument assumes a fixed supply of resources. In a perfect market, rising inflation means higher prices means higher profits for suppliers which then results in increased production and, eventually, lower prices again. The market isn't perfect of course -- supplies for some resources (e.g. real estate) expand very slowly, so we might see increased rent eat up a lot of UBI in the short term.

But the increased liquidity mentioned by the parent post counters that problem. For instance, in theory, rising rent prices should encourage renters to move elsewhere. But in reality, the cost of moving itself (plus the difficulty of finding a job in a distant location) is high enough to discourage people from making that move. UBI alleviates both concerns by helping pay for moving costs and by providing some cushion for job-seekers.

And most markets actually do a decent job of increasing supply in response to spending. At most, this argument calls for phasing in UBI a pace slow enough for markets to adapt rather than not doing it.

> 3. People who are not financially secure enough to bring children into this world will suddenly find themselves with the resources to have children.

Empirically, this doesn't seem to happen as much you might think. Poverty reduction usually results in a drop in birth rates. Bill Gates raises this point quite a bit when discussing public health. http://www.gatesfoundation.org/Who-We-Are/Resources-and-Medi...

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by dllthomas on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:35PM (#11339335)
> UBI doubled the amount of money in circulation? Bread, milk, eggs, and rent cost 2x as much.

This assumes that production of these things won't rise - almost certainly false.

For milk in particular, we've recently had price supports.

And for rent, a basic income inherently increases the supply of "real estate near enough to sufficient income".

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:35PM (#11339333)
My impression is that many people, given more money, would use most of it to pay down debt, rather than to spend on new stuff. (That may reduce the probability of bad debt, which may increase the safety of the financial system. On the other hand, it may not increase consumption to the degree expected, and therefore may not work as well as expected to "get the economy moving again".)
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by manyoso on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:22PM (#11339232)
This is simply wrong and has been shown to be wrong empirically. Details here: https://medium.com/basic-income/wouldnt-unconditional-basic-...
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by notahacker on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:45PM (#11339419)
It's simply laughable to use a $900 Alaskan dividend or dollar a day stipends for the extreme poor in the developing world as "empirical evidence" of what would happen if a developed country offered >$10k per annum with the stated social purpose of discouraging people from taking jobs they don't want.

Sure, demand-pull inflation fears are slightly overblown since any remotely feasible plan relies on taxing the hell out of the middle classes responsible for much of the discretionary spending in the economy, and the poor generally get enough to eat through other subsidies anyway. But basic income will have a whole host of negative effects, many of them region or size specific, and those will undoubtedly include things like huge relative price rises in certain types of labour, sharp rises in property prices in working class districts of expensive cities and "baby farming" if the child grant is the same as or a sufficiently large portion of the adult grant. This is true of most welfare programmes, but BI happens to be the most expensive and least flexible of all possible options.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by Mithaldu on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:05PM (#11339951)
I'm from Germany. We have all the upsides you mention, with a system that's less drastic than Basic Income.

There are more details involved, but roughly speaking: If you fulfill certain minimum requirements of being in training, beyond retirement age, medically inhibited from working or prove to the state that you send at least two job applications per month, the state guarantees you a certain quality of life.

You're guaranteed decent housing (rent, phone, internet, water, electricity, heat other utilities), health insurance (and various other small insurances), and in addition to that receive (currently) 391€ per month per person, and if you have extraordinary expenses (usually medical or social stuff) they're covered for you. (And yes, my own sister lives on this. She's well cared for. It's honestly an amazing boon on the rest of the family.)

And despite all this workers here aren't even easy to terminate. For early termination the workplace has to prove active illegal acts, or prove that they informed you of low performance and you did nothing to improve, with limits on both lay-offs or quitting usually being between 3-6 months (depending on the contract).

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by debacle on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:30PM (#11338750)
Exactly this! If you create UBI and have universal healthcare, entrepreneurship, makership, lifestyle businesses, etc, are going to explode.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by Domenic_S on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:52PM (#11338962)
"and have universal healthcare" is the functional clause here, but it's thrown in as an afterthought. All the BI in the world isn't going to help you if you incur a $200k broken arm 'cause you didn't have health insurance.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by debacle on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:02PM (#11339051)
It's not really an afterthought - the cost of universal healthcare is close to 50% of the cost of UBI.

But we're already paying out the nose for universal healthcare in the US. It's just done poorly, and has a lot of fraud and abuse, as well as insurance companies taking a lot off the top.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by mhurron on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:13PM (#11339166)
That's because what was put in place in the US was quite possibly the absolutely most retarded and idiotic way of looking at the issue.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:38PM (#11339363)
$200K seems pretty extreme for a broken arm, even if it required surgery. I'd guess $1K max for non-surgical, $10/20K for surgery.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by debacle on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:49PM (#11339466)
A compound fracture + ER visit could easily hit $30k. Not sure about $200k.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by Domenic_S on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @07:05PM (#11340659)
Ok, $153k for a rattlesnake bite [0], whatever. It was an illustrative example.

[0] https://np.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/3dngld/this_is_the_cos...

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by Domenic_S on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:51PM (#11338946)
This handwaviness is typical of pro-BI rhetoric. If there's a tech implosion and 500k workers lose their jobs, is $900/month in BI really going to offset their $3,000/month mortgages meaningfully?
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by devonkim on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:55PM (#11338991)
It's the difference between living on the street homeless like a lot of families experienced in the Rust Belt and getting some breathing room to make a move elsewhere where there may be jobs available. My big concern with BI is that costs of many staples could simply rise as consumer spending goes up due to such depressed wages for most people and we'll be back in the same situation where a shocking number of people still can't afford healthy food or a roof over their head.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by jonnycowboy on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:02PM (#11339048)
In a limited supply environment staples will rise (ie: real estate in certain cities) but with BI you can move anywhere and have a roof over your head. Food prices will not raise meaningfully.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by tankenmate on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:23PM (#11339237)
Especially considering that most OECD nations produce more than enough food to cover reasonable consumption; there is plenty of waste, direct, indirect, diversion of foodstuffs to ethanol production etc.
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by notahacker on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:36PM (#11339784)
But then, in theory "getting some breathing room to make a move elsewhere where there may be jobs available" is exactly how a properly designed welfare system for people unemployed and looking for work is intended to function, without the added expense of extending the subsidy to stay-at-home spouses, early retirees and trust fund kids.

There may be many design flaws in the system that prevent people most in need of getting those funds from getting them, but "not being available to every citizen" isn't necessarily one of them. Plus if you're saving huge amounts by not subsidising the voluntarily economically inactive, you have an awful lot more to spend on helping those actually desperately in need.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by dllthomas on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:47PM (#11339436)
> is $900/month in BI really going to offset their $3,000/month mortgages meaningfully?

... yes? They aren't breaking even, and they'll have to find something to do for more income (or move) pretty soon, but it certainly extends their runway.

Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by imgabe on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:50PM (#11339473)
Is it better than the $0 a month that they would get if that happened now?
Re:Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income by Domenic_S on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:08PM (#11339969)
You're asking rhetorically, but I actually don't know the answer. At first, maybe. It seems by simple algebra "EVERYONE has $900" is the same as "everyone has $0", except now you planned your life around that extra mine-as-a-human-right-$900, but the mortgage companies know you're getting it, because everyone gets it. So now your minimum payment isn't X, it's X+$900.