News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by joshschreuder on Monday March 21, 2016 @06:26PM (#11332687)
On a similar note, here's what the devs of Game Dev Tycoon did with pirates of their game.

http://www.greenheartgames.com/2013/04/29/what-happens-when-...

Previous discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5624727

Interesting article that after reading it made me go out and buy the game (so a solid marketing effort too!)

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by throwaway2048 on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:53PM (#11333591)
These sorts of things are silly revenge fantasies at best, they are just as easily cracked and removed as any drm features.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by PhasmaFelis on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:11PM (#11333942)
That's not the point.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by deelowe on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:58PM (#11334127)
For a dose of reality, I recommend browsing r/piracy. The mental gymnastics people go through to justify their actions is mind boggling.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by over on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:38PM (#11334265)
Maybe, but for the silent majority it's pretty straightforward: 1) we view information as fundamentally different from currency, goods, and services; 2) we don't want to pay for information if we don't have to and we're not going to get caught.

The gymnastics are mostly about just trying to figure out whether we're bad people or not - because everyone else's favorite game is Shame the Pirate - but once you realize you're not a bad person and that you're okay with doing something illegal then it all just sort of fades into the background.

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by oldmanjay on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:58AM (#11334692)
Yes, we all understand the linguistic gymnastics are a way of rationalizing an action you know is wrong.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by over on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @06:17AM (#11335480)
On the contrary, I think the people who know whether an action is right or wrong don't spend a lot of time arguing either way, they just go ahead and do what they think is right. It's the people who don't know whether an action is right or wrong that get all worked up trying to handle their conflicted feelings about it.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by supermatt on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @07:18AM (#11335670)
This isn't about whats legal though. Its about you taking advantage of someone else's hard work. Its theft in the moral sense, and its that what makes you a bad person.

That said, its still a grey area moralistically.

I do not see a small indie developer and a large corporation in the same light as the corporation is taking advantage of the hard work of its employees to make a profit.

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by bitJericho on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:32AM (#11334437)
Well you probably are a bad person though. A good person by definition tries to do good by other people.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by scotty79 on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @08:02AM (#11335825)
I prefer people that try to not do bad to other people. Those that do good can be risky.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by over on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:46PM (#11339434)
I think quietly doing good is okay, it's the people who talk about it that are risky.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by manigandham on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:37AM (#11334617)
> but once you realize you're not a bad person and that you're okay with doing something illegal then it all just sort of fades into the background.

Doing illegal things makes you a bad person.

This isn't some fight against tyranny, it's theft (or illegal copying, more specifically).

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by akerro on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:48AM (#11334805)
Hey mate! Helping homeless is illegal in my city, as well as collecting wild berries, tenting in forest. Just because law is not realistic and doesn't protect anyone and was made only for profits from tickets doesn't make it a good law and me a bad person. I have a 100GB seedbox where I seed old books that are unavailable on paper in my country and scientific zip. How bad am I?
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by manigandham on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @10:38AM (#11336895)
The only reason I added that last line is to highlight certain scenarios where laws aren't correct.

Illegally copying content is not one of those scenarios.

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by toyg on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:42AM (#11334635)
Good != legal.

Bad != illegal.

A legal system that reflects everyone's moral system 100% of the time has not been invented yet (and is likely impossible).

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by throwaway2048 on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:41PM (#11334070)
If its shown to be ineffective what is the point exactly?
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by kbenson on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:27PM (#11334235)
I think the point is that unless evidence is shown otherwise, there's little reason to believe that a significant portion of the people that pirated it got his purposefully seeded cracked version, as it was prior to it being possibly cracked otherwise, and there's little incentive for some cracking team to crack it if it appears it has already been done.

That is, it's not that it's hard to work around his change, but that many people that could or would have done so may not have known it was needed. Of course, I'm sure that situation didn't persist.

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by ChrisDutrow on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:54AM (#11334993)
Just read through the Game Dev Tycoon article: http://www.greenheartgames.com/2013/04/29/what-happens-when-...

I was on the edge of my seat waiting for him to say something like "We used the pirated version that we released to communicate with all the people who pirated the game and we were able to convert 30% of them into paying customers!"

But it didn't happen... It sounds like he just used it to really subtly hint that the people should have bought the game. Seems like a wasted opportunity. I feel like a popup that said something like this would have converted a bunch of people and turned the pirating problem into a marketing opportunity: "Haha, you are playing a pirated copy of this game, that's why you are losing all your money to game pirates. Its all good, but if you upgrade to the paid version this problem will go away, here is a link to buy the game. Happy gaming!"

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by supermatt on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @07:07AM (#11335640)
If they knew they were using a doctored copy, they would go and pirate an undoctored one.

Anecdote:

This reminds me of the anti-griefer mechanism I put in to heyreddit/reddit roulette back in the day.

If you received a verified report (following a forced match with myself), you would only got matched with other griefers.

No-one realised why the penis-to-chat ratio was so low, but its because eventually all the penis flashers would only be exposing themselves to each other.

Of course, if I had told people that they would have actively tried to get around it :)

Yes, the downside was a manual verification step :(

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by ChrisDutrow on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:17PM (#11338642)
Cool anecdote, sounds like an elegant way to deal with the griefing problem.

I think there is more to this pirating scenario though. A lot of people probably pirate games because because they aren't sure if they will like them. Once they are at the point where they are losing the game because of the pirated version, they already know they like it. Some of the people who get to this point will want to pay the $8 because they won't want to risk putting more effort into the game and losing progress again because of the pirating. Other people will be more comfortable paying because they no longer have to worry about paying for a game that they won't play.

Even if they convert only 10% of the pirates, they will have increased their sales more than 33%, making them over $800,000 more money.

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by supermatt on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:39PM (#11339369)
Yeah, i definitely agree with the premise, but as soon as that alert pops up, people would rate the torrent/whatever and say its a bad copy, and then future pirates would download an alternate seed.

Maybe they could "leak" a few different torrents in future and do some testing! :)

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by ChrisDutrow on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @08:01PM (#11340956)
Ah, interesting. I'm not super familiar with torrents and didn't know about that feature. I suppose he could release many versions with their own unique hashes. Would people be less likely to put the effort into creating a cracked version if they felt there were already a lot out there? I always wondered who does software cracking and how hard it is.
Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by Vaskivo on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @10:30AM (#11336846)
I think they are just using the medium effectivelly.

Instead of going and tell them "I know you pirated our game. Please don't do that." they made the game simulate the consequences of piracy to game development studios.

Instead of having the someone tell them they are wrong, the player comes to that conclusion themselves (hopefully).

Re:Punch Club has been pirated over 1M times by ChrisDutrow on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:21PM (#11338671)
I agree, I don't think it would be super effective to say "Please don't pirate", like an after school special or something.

What I think they should have done was used it as a marketing opportunity and given the pirates another opportunity to buy they game and get more value after they have already been playing it and know they like it. (Get more value by removing the severe pirating problem within the game so that they can progress farther)