Re:Py1040 – A U.S. personal income tax calculator
by sigil on Monday March 21, 2016 @07:49PM
(#11333247)
> They don't spend the hours I do playing "what if". Sometimes certain deductions can apply in different places for very different outcomes.
Good point. Now you've got me thinking about what a simple optimizer could do given the small search space of legal inputs. Why does TurboTax even require you to play "what if"?
Re:Py1040 – A U.S. personal income tax calculator
by jjnoakes on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:17PM
(#11333978)
Everything I've read seems to imply that schedule c vs schedule e is not a choice the taxpayer makes, but is a function of the particular situation.
Are you saying you believe situations arise like simple property management that do afford a choice?
Could you elaborate?
They usually bill a fixed rate, and even if they do an hourly rate, they try to do them quickly to get through more of them. They don't spend the hours I do playing "what if". Sometimes certain deductions can apply in different places for very different outcomes.
An example: You manage a property for a friend. You collect the rent and then send it over to them minus a small fee for yourself. You can claim this one of two ways: You can file a schedule C or a schedule E. Each has a very different effect on your final total depending on the rest of your tax situation and the other forms you have filed.
For example, the schedule E increases your AGI, even though you can deduct all the rent you paid back to your friend. The schedule C does not, because only the total counts against your AGI, not all revenue.
So now when you go to deduct your medical expenses, the 7.5% minimum is quite different.
That's just one example of how the what-if plays into it, but only a very expensive accountant will spend the time doing those things and/or have enough experience to know how to do it right the first time.
That being said, I'll probably do a bake off this year again to see if the accountant can do better than I with TurboTax.