They usually bill a fixed rate, and even if they do an hourly rate, they try to do them quickly to get through more of them. They don't spend the hours I do playing "what if". Sometimes certain deductions can apply in different places for very different outcomes.
An example: You manage a property for a friend. You collect the rent and then send it over to them minus a small fee for yourself. You can claim this one of two ways: You can file a schedule C or a schedule E. Each has a very different effect on your final total depending on the rest of your tax situation and the other forms you have filed.
For example, the schedule E increases your AGI, even though you can deduct all the rent you paid back to your friend. The schedule C does not, because only the total counts against your AGI, not all revenue.
So now when you go to deduct your medical expenses, the 7.5% minimum is quite different.
That's just one example of how the what-if plays into it, but only a very expensive accountant will spend the time doing those things and/or have enough experience to know how to do it right the first time.
That being said, I'll probably do a bake off this year again to see if the accountant can do better than I with TurboTax.
Good point. Now you've got me thinking about what a simple optimizer could do given the small search space of legal inputs. Why does TurboTax even require you to play "what if"?
Are you saying you believe situations arise like simple property management that do afford a choice?
Could you elaborate?
I send all my documents to a local accountant and he sorts it all out once a year for the equivalent of about a quarter of day's wages, and about an hour of my time to sort the documents.