It's amazing that their web component is even allowed to dictate what verification addresses are permittable. That should be the concern of a completely separate component of their infrastructure. Says a lot of about their security architecture, I guess.
Why?
Because we had links to a Paypal account set up to take donations. Even though PayPal had its own security, and we were only providing a link to it, that was enough for them to deny us the cert. They refused to understand that WE would be conducting no financial transactions using their service; or that PayPal was a separate entity.
It was maddening, and we ended up abandoning the whole idea of having SSL. Would that LE had existed.
> Class 1 certificates are limited to client and server certificates, whereas the later is restricted in its usage for non-commercial purpose only.
AFAIK simply taking donations counts as "commercial purpose". You are free to dislike their policy though.
Back before I found Gandi.net I came across StartSSL (I was looking for basic SSL certifications.) At the time StartSSL's website was horrible, and I mean ugly, it turned me away because it felt so unprofessional. I see now, even with a new flashy website, that they still remain unprofessional (maybe not in their looks, but obviously in their practices.)