News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by Karunamon on Monday March 21, 2016 @04:39AM (#11326828)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but as I understand it, you cannot contract your way out of criminal law.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by dchest on Monday March 21, 2016 @05:08AM (#11326918)
In this case, every giving would be stealing. If I gave you something, you didn't steal it from me. Likewise, if I gave you the right to impersonate me in particular circumstances, it's not a criminal offense if you do.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by notalaser on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:44AM (#11327650)
It depends on where you are in the world, but in most places in the civilized world, criminal law does not work that way. If something is illegal, we cannot sign a contract that says it's ok between you and me, and magically make it legal. E.g. if I kill someone, the state will prosecute me for murder, regardless of whether or not that guy and I signed a contract that said it was fine.

If impersonating someone is a criminal offense in a particular jurisdiction, then -- assuming that jurisdiction has a sane criminal code -- there is no way to make it legal through a contract.

Edit: there are good reasons why this is in place, the most relevant of which is that it provides protection against abuses. Otherwise, we'd have things like employers that would still be at liberty to use lashing and beating as disciplinary action against employees who don't really have a choice about signing a contract or not.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by vidarh on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:42AM (#11327967)
The point is that the specific criteria defining what is criminal can include whether or not there is consent.

A contract can establish consent.

E.g. if I go into your house without permission and take stuff, then it is theft. If I have a contract saying that I have permission to go into your house and take stuff, then it is not.

I have not contracted my away from something illegal. The contract has established consent, which meant the criteria that otherwise would have made my actions criminal are not fulfilled.

> If impersonating someone is a criminal offense in a particular jurisdiction, then -- assuming that jurisdiction has a sane criminal code -- there is no way to make it legal through a contract.

That depends whether or not the criteria that needs to be met for it to be a crime requires lack of consent. If it requires lack of consent, then a contract can document that the consent has been given.

All jurisdictions I'm aware of (not a lawyer) have the concept of agents that may act on your behalf with consent. To what extent such agents can act using your name (with consent) vs. using their own name but on your behalf, varies greatly.

E.g. some places your agents (say a PA) will sign letters "[agents name] for and on behalf of [your name]" or similar, while other places they will use a signature stamp with your signature, or do "p.p. [their signature] [your printed name]" (the p.p. stands for "per procurationem"). Many other variations are in use, and how obvious signs there are that a document was not personally signed by the person the letter is from varies greatly.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by notalaser on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:52AM (#11328908)
Yes, but consent is not something that can be universally declared in a credible manner. There are things that remain illegal even after you have consented to them. For instance, having sex with someone below the age of consent is illegal even if they have consented to it (the idea being, of course, that they may be coerced into expressing that consent).

> All jurisdictions I'm aware of (not a lawyer) have the concept of agents that may act on your behalf with consent. To what extent such agents can act using your name (with consent) vs. using their own name but on your behalf, varies greatly.

They do, but things are not as simple as "can act on your behalf with consent". Around here, for instance (but I'm in Europe), they can only act on your behalf if:

a) You have explicitly given them consent to act on your behalf in that specific situation (i.e. you told them "you can go to the bank on this date and cash in this much in my name"), or if you have explicitly given them consent to act on your behalf with that particular party and for a specified period of time (i.e. you can go to this bank and do anything in my name for this period of time), and

b) The contract that states this has been validated by a notary and recorded by authorities, and

c) The party that they are acting on your behalf with knows about this, has been explicitly informed that they are acting on your behalf, and agrees to work with them under these conditions.

If they fail to do any of these, it's flat-out illegal. I think this is covered under civil law here, though, so it can be voided by a contract -- but the idea is that consent is not as trivial as signing a sheet of paper that says yeah, do whatever you want. It's bound by specific terms, too, the breach of which makes the whole thing illegal, even if on the whole the operation was consensual (i.e. if an agent, with my consent, goes to the bank to cash in a deposit, but does not explicitly inform the cashier that they are acting on my behalf so that they record the transaction accordingly (i.e. done by X on behalf of NotALaser), he's breaking the law).

(Edit: or, to make it clearer: he can represent me, but he cannot claim he's me. He has to explicitly inform the other party that he's acting on my behalf, declare his identity and present the proper authorization etc.)

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by vidarh on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:52PM (#11330094)
> There are things that remain illegal even after you have consented to them.

Yes, I pointed that out.

> They do, but things are not as simple as "can act on your behalf with consent"

I believe that was exactly the point I was making.

> Around here, for instance (but I'm in Europe), they can only act on your behalf if:

While I'm sure you're right for your location, "Europe" encompasses not only ~50 distinct legal systems, but also half a dozen or so distinct legal traditions (with e.g. Common law, Germanic law, Napoleonic law and Roman law as the biggest traditions), which is one of the reasons I specifically pointed out that it varies greatly how clear one has to be about whether or not something is signed by an agent.

Worldwide it gets even more complicated.

To be very clear: I agree that some places the agent will need to specifically sign and state their own name and specify they are acting as an agent. Exactly in line with the examples I gave, a couple of which are from Europe.

In others they can stamp or use a machine to "fake" the name of the person they are acting on behalf of -- as long as they have that persons consent to do so.

In the US we have perhaps one of the most famous examples of the latter: The office of the US President frequently uses an Autopen [1] to sign documents on behalf of the president, such as autographs or letters to constituents. The purpose of it is to duplicate the signature precisely, making actual pen strokes in order to make the signature seem more authentic than e.g. the use of a stamp or seal.

But US presidents have used it for much more important things than letters and autographs, including several times that Obama has had staffers use an Autopen to sign laws on his behalf.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autopen

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by notalaser on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:25PM (#11330442)
> While I'm sure you're right for your location, "Europe" encompasses not only ~50 distinct legal systems, but also half a dozen or so distinct legal traditions (with e.g. Common law, Germanic law, Napoleonic law and Roman law as the biggest traditions), which is one of the reasons I specifically pointed out that it varies greatly how clear one has to be about whether or not something is signed by an agent.

Of course. I mentioned I'm in Europe just to ensure that it's clear I'm not referring to any law that apply in the US, as this is what HN is most familiar with. Europe is, indeed, very diverse when it comes to law.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by jwiechers on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @10:45PM (#11341751)
> It depends on where you are in the world, but in most places in the civilized world, criminal law does not work that way.

I'm sorry, but: no. "In most places in the civilised world" there are these guys called hairdressers and they could routinely - technically - be charged with committing assault causing bodily harm. It's a pretty clear cut (sorry) case that gets trotted out in most any first year criminal law class. The reason they aren't charged is simple: you consent to that bodily harm being inflicted upon you. There are variously defined limits to your ability to consent, especially with regard to duress or excessive harm, but your reasoning is otherwise completely incorrect.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by SilasX on Monday March 21, 2016 @01:11PM (#11329628)
The parent's point was that obviously some rights (even on criminal matters) are obviously waivable in this manner.

Normally, I can't take your stuff or enter your property, but if you make a contract granting me the right to take (specific things among) your stuff or enter your property in specific cases, that's enforceable.

Can you similarly sign away your right not to be murdered similarly? To be impersonated? Maybe not, but it depends on the circumstances, and isn't simply a matter of "that's illegal so you can't sign it away".

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by _asummers on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:47AM (#11327993)
If Alice and Bob enter into a contract that says Alice will kill Carol for $1m, can Bob sue her for breach of contract if she does not? Or does the legality of the contract supercede the body of the contract such that the contract is void?
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by Zak on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:24AM (#11328222)
The court will not enforce the contract against Bob because it is illegal to do the act specified by the contract. Furthermore, Alice and Bob could both be prosecuted for conspiracy to commit murder.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by iopq on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:05AM (#11327466)
If your Windows EULA said "Microsoft can take any of your property" they still can't steal from you just because you agreed to it.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by donatj on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:16AM (#11327517)
It would no longer be stealing because you agreed to it. This is why repossession is legal.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by Karunamon on Monday March 21, 2016 @03:30PM (#11331098)
Such a contract would likely be ruled unconscionable (invalid) if anyone challenged it. I don't think there's a judge in the country that could be convinced that any piece of code is good enough consideration for random tangible property.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by dchest on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:04AM (#11328529)
Yes, you can agree to transfer all of your property to Microsoft in exchange for a Windows license. But including this in EULA will not work though, as there are limits on what you can agree to without signature or notary.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by IanCal on Monday March 21, 2016 @05:51AM (#11327024)
The comparison to stealing is frankly ridiculous, as the law doesn't say you can't transfer money. It will explicitly talk about consent. If contracts allowed you to agree to anything then minimum wage laws couldn't work. Which side the impersonation laws fall on will depend on how they're written.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by OJFord on Monday March 21, 2016 @06:25AM (#11327143)
What about boxing, martial arts sparring, fencing, assisted suicide, and voting by proxy?

The point here is that you either _can_ contract your way out, or (what I suspect is the case) there re exclusions in the law were relevant.

Either way, it suggests this might not be illegal if covered by something blindly tick-boxed.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by IanCal on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:42AM (#11327635)
You cannot, uniformly, give people the ability to do anything to you. That's the point I'm making.

> What about boxing, martial arts sparring, fencing

Consent only works up to a point. I cannot consent to you stabbing me or beating me into a bloody pulp.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_(criminal_law)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R_v_Brown

It's worth noting that bare knuckle boxing is illegal in the UK, and you can't just sign a document to do it.

> assisted suicide

Assisted suicide is illegal in the UK. It does not matter if the patient signs a contract to say it's OK, it's still illegal.

Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by OJFord on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:01AM (#11327735)
Again, my point about AS was that it has it's own legislation, implying to me at least that that of murder, manslaughter, suicide do not necessarily cover it by default.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by ams6110 on Monday March 21, 2016 @08:24AM (#11327540)
You seem to be opertating under the delusion that the law is logically consistent. It isn't. There are some things you can allow by contract/permission and some things you cannot, and circumstance matters.
Re:Tell HN: AngelList told my employer that I'd updated my p... by OJFord on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:00AM (#11327723)
No, I'm not. I'm responding to the blanket statement to the contrary. I fully expect that it's a case of cased exclusions as I've said in another comment.