News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by PaulRobinson on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:04PM (#11320904)
Which is the correct answer.

When you spend money, it doesn't disappear. It's just moved.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by lr4444lr on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:12PM (#11320937)
Yes, but the goods it can buy on the next round of division still don't come from the spendthrift vagabond, and if his way of life is incentivized while the producers' is disincentivized by this redistribution, then that circulation won't continue so innocuously.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by audi100quattro on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:37PM (#11321216)
...and if you incentivized the producers (which is also redistribution) while disincentivized the spendthrift you will not be left with much of a population to keep redistributing from. Ultimately this is bad for the producers, I am not sure why they don't realize it. Short-term thinking and greed, maybe?

Increasing inequality does in fact encourage deflation. Redistribution in forms of common services and education (for um.. jobs) is very necessary.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by lr4444lr on Saturday March 19, 2016 @09:44PM (#11321392)
I wouldn't disagree with you, but I think you're reading something into the quote which isn't there. The moral is that redistribution won't bring prosperity - not that it's good in some cases and bad in others. At the risk of adding more complexity to the parable than its pithiness merits for the sake of explanation (as I understand it): the spendthrift wholly consumes whatever he produces, and wants more. The producer generates a surplus. He may well consume an overall greater amount than the spendthrift, but he's still net positive. The "division" however, will only benefit the spendthrift, because producing is chosen for the sake of consumption, but consumption for its own sake.

I know it's still a gross oversimplification, but I think the general truth encoded in the parable should be appreciated for its own sake in general terms.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by marcosdumay on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:33PM (#11321517)
> The moral is that redistribution won't bring prosperity

Except that it does - up to a certain point.

That's one of the few repeatable, tested, and validated economical principle from the XX century. Counter intuitive as it is, there's just no point denying it.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by StephenConnell on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:12AM (#11321770)
If prosperity is "having wealth", then redistributing wealth does bring prosperity. But then you could also say that stealing brings prosperity. Could you not?
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by Retra on Sunday March 20, 2016 @03:37AM (#11322158)
You could, but you should be aware that "stealing" is not an act per se, but a moral qualification of some other act. Namely, the redistribution of goods.

The only difference between theft and charity is your personal moral inflection.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by StephenConnell on Sunday March 20, 2016 @09:51AM (#11322888)
A couple more definitions from Google. Charity: voluntary giving of help, typically in the form of money, to those in need. Stealing: to take without permission

I am an advocate for charity. But redistribution through taxation feels like stealing to me.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by Retra on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:41PM (#11323542)
Redistribution through taxation feels like charity to me. Here's to kicker: why should anybody care about your feelings if they are wrong? Or if they only serve yourself?

If there's a good reason to think that redistributing wealth will improve people's ability to mitigate risk and make good decisions, then your feeling would really be irrational and should be ignored.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by chc on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:42AM (#11321841)
AFAIK places with high rates of crime don't tend to be very prosperous on average. The same is not true for places with systems that help the poor.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by anaolykarpov on Sunday March 20, 2016 @02:13AM (#11321999)
Like north Korea, venezuela and Vietnam?
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by sanoli on Sunday March 20, 2016 @03:37AM (#11322161)
I counter your three with Denmark, Sweden and Norway. Now for the next round you hit me with three countries that have better standards of living than mine and that don't help the poor. 5 bucks a round?
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by sgt101 on Sunday March 20, 2016 @04:39AM (#11322264)
I suppose you are pointing out that these are socialist countries and that poor people in them suffer a lot. Please correct me if I am wrong.

I think that they aren't really socialist countries, I would point to places like Sweden and France as closer to actual socialism than North Korea, which is really a Fascist dictatorship explicitly modelled on pre-second world war Japan.

Vietnam is an odd one out here because having suffered a total catastrophe in the years running up to 1975 (as in the complete physical destruction of the state, mechanisms of production and the labour force via being killed in large numbers) the Vietnamese state has made huge progress to become relatively prosperous. There is a lot to be admired in terms of economic gain, although not much to be admired about freedom and safety for those with contrary views.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by marcosdumay on Sunday March 20, 2016 @11:26AM (#11323273)
So, let me clarify.

Redistribution increases the total wealth, and it is not a small effect at all.

But only up to a certain point. Complete communism still completely sucks.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by iQuercus on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:55PM (#11321585)
Source?
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by marcosdumay on Sunday March 20, 2016 @11:24AM (#11323263)
Well, the first theory is by Keynes, it's on his book.

It's been revised and remodeled several hundreds of times, if you want to search Google Schoolar or something like that, look for "demand side" theories, or crisis of "aggregated demand". Also, if you search for NGDP, the biggest share of the papers will be about this.

There are many other terms that will lead to less results. It's a really widespread concept.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by tarikjn on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @07:01PM (#11340633)
Mainstream yes, as in the majority believe so. But not without controversy. The Austrian School of economics is an opposing view which has brought just as many results of being the correct philosophy, and one may argue, is a simpler and more elegant approach of economics. And as one may say, clear ideas are easily expressed.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by hluska on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:46AM (#11321858)
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by pessimizer on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:48PM (#11321566)
You assume that the rich man was a producer. He actually just plays video games most days, and takes a trip to skydive in Bali twice a year.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by edanm on Sunday March 20, 2016 @03:16AM (#11322118)
As most rich men do? Quite a statement if so.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by naasking on Sunday March 20, 2016 @11:30AM (#11323282)
> and if his way of life is incentivized while the producers' is disincentivized by this redistribution

The idea that producers are only incentivized monetarily is false.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by jjoonathan on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:03PM (#11321114)
> spendthrift vagabond

An obtuse mischaracterization of the poor; a more typical "sin" would be failure to hop over the ever-rising bar that denotes the ability to secure money by threatening to withhold labor.

Circulation goes both ways and it isn't the ability of producers to secure profits that seems to be most endangered at the moment.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by icebraining on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:11PM (#11321144)
An obtuse mischaracterization of the poor

Why do you think it's a characterization of the poor at all?

Circulation goes both ways and it isn't the ability of producers to secure profits that seems to be most endangered at the moment.

The working poor are themselves producers.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by jjoonathan on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:31PM (#11321196)
> Why do you think it's a characterization of the poor at all?

Because they're the ones who the type of policy we are discussing would actually be intended to benefit. Voicing that side of the argument through a "spendthrift vagabond" is disingenuous at best.

> The working poor are themselves producers.

I was using the term with my tongue firmly planted in my cheek, I thought it would be clear enough from context that I was referring to capital-holders.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by kamaal on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:14PM (#11321624)
>>Because they're the ones who the type of policy we are discussing would actually be intended to benefit.

No. To be a spendthrift is a symptom of many problems. One of which means lack of respect for money or the effort required to earn it. Other wise one wouldn't be throwing it away.

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by trophycase on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:56PM (#11321092)
Value and efficiency can disappear though. I could spend 100 dollars on something that falls apart in a month, or spend 1000 for a functionally equivalently something that will last 3 generations. One of these choices is wasteful and hurts economic efficiency, one isn't.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by alanwatts on Saturday March 19, 2016 @09:05PM (#11321284)
One is based on the broken window fallacy assumption, one isn't.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by themartorana on Saturday March 19, 2016 @09:22PM (#11321344)
Well, if the money was to be spent. Half our problem is the extra cash moving towards the 1% is held, not spent, not circulated.
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by alanwatts on Saturday March 19, 2016 @09:32PM (#11321363)
What is the other half?
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by themartorana on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:10PM (#11321619)
Speculative (and unregulated) financial dealings by banks with your cash, leading to ruinous effects on the global economy, ruining much of the middle class in the process?
Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by alanwatts on Sunday March 20, 2016 @11:49AM (#11323344)
So it would seem. But I see a root cause for both of these: the centralized pyramid user hierarchy which is inherent in any paper based information system.

"It is part of the age-old habit of using new means for old purposes instead of discovering what are the new goals contained in the new means."

Re:Golden Rules for Making Money (1880) by lottin on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:53PM (#11321249)
What disappear is the goods the money was spent on, and money is only worth something as long as there are goods that can be bought with it.