News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by sikim on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:03PM (#11319621)
As a South Korean who experienced/heard about many government-backed researches, I strongly feel that this will go nowhere. Most of the time, there's always some bribery involved and project never finishes or come even close to that of the tech companies in US. The government then realizes it can't be done even with more money and puts the money elsewhere just to repeat the same thing. The examples that I can think of are when they were trying to build their own operating system and a video game console.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by w1ntermute on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:21PM (#11319699)
That reminds me of what an engineer said about Quaero[0], a Franco-German attempt to create a competitor to Google search:

> Going head-to-head with Google with a project involving well-funded, energetic entrepreneurs would be foolish. Attempting the same with a multigovernment collaboration is beyond description.[1]

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaero

1: http://spectrum.ieee.org/telecom/internet/loser-whats-the-la...

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by tryitnow on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:01PM (#11320180)
Hmmm, that doesn't sound like the problem with S Korea at all. The above commenter was making the point that too many South Korean projects are compromised by bribes and nepotism.

The German/French collaboration just sounds like it was badly organized.

The end result may be the same, but it sounds like the root causes were different.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by endymi0n on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:17PM (#11320242)
Not at all. Every "research" effort that goes money first (and especially throwing it at already established entities), design, goals and culture second is going to end up the same way. It doesn't have anything to do with South Korea or Germany to be honest.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by WhoBeI on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:33PM (#11321663)
Mmm.. the german governments funding of the Max Planck institutes seem to work well. As I understand it the Max Planck Society gets funding and then distributes that to projects meeting certain quality requirements.

I think they do mostly base research, the kind that private companies tend to avoid as there rarely is any direct profit to be had.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by gumby on Sunday March 20, 2016 @03:39PM (#11324301)
That speaks to w1ntermute's point. Max Planck Institutes are dedicated to basic research (Grundlagenforschung). Thus they don't have an "objective" as such. Plus, by the very nature of fundamental research, it's hard to determine "success" (except in the aggregate, and after a long period of time -- which the MPG has had time to demonstrate.

The "google-killer" or "SK AI project" or the "5th generation project" for that matter are quite different. First, they start with an ill-defined yet concrete goal, which makes success well nigh impossible. Second, they start from the position of a large sum of money being necessary -- which naturally attracts inappropriate as well as appropriate bids; the deciders are often more political than with the MPG (which itself, consisting of a group of people, must have its own politics, but presumably less intensely). Also this money is often a one-time or short term allocation rather than a long term investment as with the MPG.

The one example I can think of in which this actually worked was Airbus, but that took decades, massive sums, and a stubbornness to change the structure a lot along the way. Not sure I can think of another example.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by pm90 on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:34PM (#11320569)
I agree with this sentiment. Frankly, govt. sponsored research is very hard to get right. The US Federal Govt. is probably the only instance of a government agency I know of that consistently delivers good value for all that investment (through NSF, DARPA etc.) which is why it pains me whenever Congress announces budget cuts for those agencies.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by vmorgulis on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:57PM (#11319891)
Yes and Exalead was involved.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exalead

I guess they are still widely indirectly funded by the state.

A better strategy would to distribute the money to more companies a bit like VCs do.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by eru on Sunday March 20, 2016 @02:57AM (#11322084)
Or just leave the money with the people in the first place?
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by vmorgulis on Sunday March 20, 2016 @03:46PM (#11324325)
Yes, better.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by ttflee on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:31PM (#11321658)
Has anyone heard of Jike.com, a Chinese state sponsored one that failed after hiring a former world champion of table tennis as CEO and burning out 2 billion RMB?
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by msbarnett on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:41PM (#11319806)
Yeah. Congrats to Samsung in advance on their $860 million donation.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by skypather on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:53PM (#11319869)
Good one. :-)
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by jahpeacelove on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:14PM (#11320233)
Care to provide some examples beyond your feelings? The South Korean government did pretty well with shipbuilding: http://m.koreatimes.co.kr/phone/news/view.jsp?req_newsidx=69...
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by treme on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:44PM (#11320611)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Major_Rivers_Project#Crit...

17 billion $~ spent with little to show for it, with much allegations of corruption between President Lee & his ex-employer Hyundai constructions.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0ANQBP0Cq8 6 million $ spent on "robo-fish" to detect & observe water conditions, 7/9 units DOA; met 10% of targeted spec (speed/data networking bandwidth capabilities)

I think government sanctioned projects can work if the leader in charge has proper intent and skills & leadership to steer the resources.

This is far from the case with current Korean leadership; as Ms.Park was elected mostly based on her name recognition/ positive sentiments left by her dad. She is widely considered to be one of the most incompetent president ever to be elected into office.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by yongjik on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:04PM (#11320698)
17 billion $ spent, s/with little to show for it/which resulted in total ecological disaster in four major rivers/

During the summer these days, the state of the riverwater is humorously called "Nokjo (algal bloom) latte". See: https://www.google.com/search?q=%EB%85%B9%EC%A1%B0%EB%9D%BC%...

I'm actually happy that Park Geun-Hye is babbling about AI's. At least I can't think of any way that could do a long-lasting harm, other than burning taxypayers' $$$, but they're gonna do that anyway, so what's the difference?

Hopefully, in the next election we could find someone who could utter more than one coherent sentence at a time.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by burfog on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:23PM (#11321490)
It does look like a drink we call "green smoothie" made from ground up spinach, kiwi, etc. Sometimes algae is added. The drink is usually overpriced. It looks like you get it for free!

It is normal for politicians to be stupid. Don't you want your country to be normal?

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by sikim on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:53PM (#11320399)
As you probably noticed from the article you linked, strong leadership was what made it possible. President Park is a controversial figure in Korea because of his ruthlessness and dictatorship but nevertheless contributed significantly to the country's economic growth. Under his rule, if people were caught accepting bribes from someone, they would face severe punishments for sure. Currently there is no such leadership (current president is a daughter of the President Park, ironically), and people hear news about corruption and wrong use of government budget all the time, especially in military projects where bribery and nepotism are commonplace.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by hackuser on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:37PM (#11320585)
I don't know much about the old dictatorship. I do know this story is told about many dictatorships.

In the others, the reality is that the dictatorship is even more corrupt but because there is no freedom of the press, nobody reports it and the dictator publishes their propaganda about how clean they are and how they are jailing people for corruption, when really they are jailing their opponents (like President Xi in China today). Who would have dared to report about corruption by the original President Park, or to defend his opponents?

Democracy produces the least corrupt governments in the world. One big reason is that people are free to report it, the leader can hose their job in the next election, and an indepedent judiciary can convict the leaders friends (and protect their enemies). The corruption is there in any government or human institution; if we aren't reading about it, that's when we have a problem.

Democracies also produce the most economically and technologically advanced economies and societies - look at any list; democracies dominate it. The 'strong leadership' approach, for all its appeal to some, doesn't deliver the goods. For all the chaos, giving input to millions rather than to just one person produces much better results.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by treme on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:54PM (#11320658)
Democracy is usually the best, and dictators are usually bad at managing economies, but there are exceptions.

Every once in a while, people luck out and get a competent dictator with proper leadership & economic understanding to direct resources to appropriate areas for economic growth.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Park_Chung-hee

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lee_Kuan_Yew

Both brutal dictators; but widely considered to have done a fine job steering economies.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by hackuser on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:45PM (#11320837)
> Both brutal dictators; but widely considered to have done a fine job steering economies.

One does not balance the other. Stalin industrialized Russia; Hitler rebuilt the German economy.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by argonaut on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:37PM (#11321215)
You missed the part where Stalin ruined the economy through collectivization and and Hitler ruined the economy because of, you know, going to war.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by darkmirage on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:47AM (#11321860)
Calling Lee Kuan Yew a brutal dictator is a very huge stretch of the term.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by yongjik on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:01PM (#11320890)
> Under his rule, if people were caught accepting bribes from someone, they would face severe punishments for sure.

[citation needed]

...Or was that a rhetorical device, meaning if people were caught accepting bribes, then of course they were already out of political favor, so they were heavily punished?

In the late years Park's servants would "recruit" women to serve him. In fact there was a young girl in the last night when he was shot by his own aide while drinking. So I find it very hard to believe Park would have minded his minions doing creating accounting.

Some people say Park wasn't corrupt because he did not amass personal wealth, but that argument misses the fact that he had no intention to retire. The country was his, and would remain his. Moving money to his own bank account would have been like moving money from the left pocket to the right pocket. Why bother?

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by JoshTriplett on Saturday March 19, 2016 @03:37PM (#11320071)
Fortunately. The far worse scenario would be if the first (and last) implementer of AGI is a government, no matter which government, foolish enough to attempt to mandate that the AGI maintain any of that government's rules, goals, or structures, rather than just getting its value function right.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by Eliezer on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:57PM (#11321590)
By default, if somebody without extraordinary competence and paranoia tried to make an AGI that would implement government laws, in practice you'd just get something equivalent to a paperclip maximizer (https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Paperclip_maximizer).

It doesn't matter much whether it's the government accidentally destroying the universe, or a private company or a university research team accidentally destroying the universe. Pointing an AGI in a particular direction is a hard technical problem that we haven't yet seen much interest in solving as a technical problem, in part because people have been distracted over arguing who gets to destroy the universe. This is easier to argue about and activates a lot of fun human political instincts where you get to valorize or devalorize particular tribes, so it's a very dangerous distraction.

You would need to make a lot more progress on the alignment problem, as a technical problem, before it made any difference to actual outcomes who'd built the thing or what they'd thought their intentions were.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by JoshTriplett on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:22PM (#11321641)
Absolutely true. You could substitute "organization" in place of "government" in my comment and it would still hold. And to some extent, funding efforts like these are (hopefully) so far away from the actual problems of an AGI that arguing about which one is more likely to create a paperclipper is somewhat moot. The concept that any such organization could get an AGI close enough to right that it isn't just a paperclipper, while being just wrong enough to create the kind of dystopia imagined in fiction rather than in the imaginations of people who think about AGI failure modes, is almost an uninterestingly small target, and not what I was aiming for with the preceding comment; rather, I was thinking specifically about fail-by-paperclip.

But regardless of the failure mode, my concern is precisely that anyone or any organization with a sufficiently large (and sunk) investment into itself, regardless of what the nature of that organization is, will have a temptation to include their own interests in a value function. And because it's hard to reason about the consequences of errors on that scale, such organizations might also tend to not make a sufficient distinction between "fail by destroying the universe (or worse)" and "'fail' by not preserving whatever principles this organization (thinks it) holds dear". Not distinguishing those two cases would then tend to lead the organization to discount the risk of meddling in the value function, even in the face of warnings that doing so would destroy the universe, because they might view their own obsolescence as little better.

So, among the large number of things that have to go exactly right, one of many will be the need for the organization developing it to very specifically have no goal other than getting AGI right, for a definition of right in terms of sentient life rather than anything distinguishing that particular organization.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by cma on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:37PM (#11321537)
Weren't Samsung and LG heavily government backed?
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by tn13 on Saturday March 19, 2016 @03:38PM (#11320079)
That is true about ALL governments my friend. Obama just threw few billions at self driving cars which will not go anywhere.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by cma on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:55PM (#11321584)
Lots came out of the DARPA self-driving contests. And lots of the teams that did well in that were at universities with massive levels of federally funded research. Many of them went on to head up the efforts at the big companies with that government bootstrapping in place.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by adventured on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:19PM (#11320748)
The billions for self-driving cars, is not for technology, or to build cars, or to compete with Google / Apple / GM. It's to begin establishing a legal and infrastructure framework around the country that facilitates a shift to self-driving cars from the government's position as regulator, and ideally to do so safely. If they do nothing, given the sizable regulations in the US and from state to state regarding vehicles, then that shift is going to be a rolling disaster. They should probably be spending a lot more money to prep the ground for what's coming.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by ConfuciusSay02 on Monday March 21, 2016 @03:12PM (#11330902)
Direct government funding, or indirect funding via guaranteed contracts or similar, resulted in innovations such as:

- The internet

- The microchip

- Cellular communications

- GPS

- Solid state memory

- Capacitive sensors

Just the technologies that more or less every other Silicon Valley innovation is based upon.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by dnautics on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:56PM (#11320670)
Hwang woo suk and stem cells?
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by yongjik on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:31PM (#11320999)
That's different. Hwang's case was the story of a fraudster, who built his empire based on deceit, bribery, using his students like slaves, and generally knowing which buttons to press to incite a wave of nationalism mixed with personality cult.

That is, he was one of his own kind. A legend, if you could call him that.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by dnautics on Monday March 21, 2016 @02:52AM (#11326604)
He wasn't totally a fraudster - snuppy was real after all.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by xianshou on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:52PM (#11319864)
To paraphrase Obi-Wan: I feel a great disturbance in the industry...it is as if a million startups cried out in supplication, and were suddenly funded.

Pure injections of capital may work for basic needs in Africa, but tend to flounder in creative endeavors. From what I've seen, access to resources - a strong entrepreneurial community, top researchers, good hardware, and a flexible and customer-rich business environment - will always trump access to money.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by 1stop on Saturday March 19, 2016 @03:47PM (#11320117)
The Apollo program would be a good counter example.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by ovi256 on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:05PM (#11320911)
The people contributing to the Apollo program were genuinely frightened of the US being behind in the space race and thus defenseless against strategic military applications of space technology, such as surveillance and early warning satellites, ICBMs or fractional orbit bombardment systems. Already deployed bomber-delivered nuclear bombs were an existential threat only countered by mutual annihilation (bilateral use). Unilateral access to space-delivery of atomic munitions would have shattered this equilibrium. This created a feeling of urgency and common purpose similar to that felt in wartime.

Unfortunately, peacetime development lacks that feeling.

Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by tfgg on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:40PM (#11320340)
I feel comparisons to the Apollo and Manhatten projects, often brought up in this context, are misleading because they ignore the massive pure research bases they were building on. Of course they did do more pure research, but a lot of the cost and muscle/size was for solving engineering problems.
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by 1stop on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:37PM (#11320586)
Is this just a true Scotsman fallacy?
Re:South Korea announces $860M AI fund after AlphaGo 'shock' by dnautics on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:58PM (#11320674)
Both projects had clear tangible goals and a timeline to complete them by.