News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by DataJunkie on Friday March 18, 2016 @11:25PM (#11317135)
Disclaimer: Aviation hobbyist but not an expert.

It depends on the size of the drone and where it hits.

I am not sure how large these drones are, but if they have the mass of a flock of large seagulls, say, it could disable an engine (like the US Airways jet).

A collision with a wing could cause substantial damage to the wing which would change the aerodynamics, and that could be potentially dangerous at low altitudes because of the neighborhoods underneath. Debris could fall from the sky and injure or kill someone. I doubt it would come close to tearing off a wing.

A collision with the fuselage could breach the cabin which is dangerous in itself, but would not cause a decompression at that altitude.

A collision with the windscreen of the flight deck would be dangerous for obvious reasons. In the minor case, it can blind the pilots temporarily. In the worst case, debris from the drone would incapacitate the pilot during the most dangerous phase of flight: landing or departure.

What is really dangerous is the speed at which the aircraft hits the mass of the drone. It may seem like the aircraft would just kill the drone, and that is probably the case with most drones, but if it has large mass, it wouldn't.

The most dangerous scenario is if a drone hits the control surface like the flaps (very important for landing), or the horizontal stabilizer in the tail, it could be disastrous.

Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by hanniabu on Saturday March 19, 2016 @12:14AM (#11317273)
Anybody know what the protocol is in the event of a blown out windshield/windscreen?

Would the pilots be sucked out even at a low altitude such as 5k feet? Whether they are our aren't, how will the plane be landed?

Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by MaxScheiber on Saturday March 19, 2016 @12:43AM (#11317350)
Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by hanniabu on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:10PM (#11319646)
That is damn impressive on both pilot's accounts, thanks for the link
Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by iofj on Friday March 18, 2016 @11:55PM (#11317217)
The airflow would be trying to prevent a collision with the front of the wing, and a drone would simply go where the wind blows. Which is to say if a drone flew straight for an airplane wing, it would fly around the wing and suddenly explode in the massive turbulence behind the wing. This would look very surprising because to the naked eye there is nothing behind the wing.

Hitting the fuselage, or entering an engine is probably more realistic. Both would be expensive, but won't be a threat to the passengers. Maybe hitting the wingtips would be doable ... not sure.

Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by tzs on Saturday March 19, 2016 @12:43AM (#11317345)
30 seconds of Googling turns up numerous examples of bird strikes on the leading edge of wings, some with very substantial damage.

Why would airflow around the wing keep a drone from hitting it but not a bird?

Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by nether on Saturday March 19, 2016 @12:46AM (#11317360)
Nothing. Upstream flow stagnates at the leading edge, excess bug splatter there attests to that.
Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by mveety on Saturday March 19, 2016 @01:25AM (#11317458)
It can stagnate to the point of bugs not having much of an issue staying on the wing during flight. I remember a case when I was flight training where we had a little spider as a passenger on the top of the starboard wing for the duration of the flight. The little guy didn't fall off until the wing stalled out when we were landing.
Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by ajross on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:10AM (#11317546)
That's a different effect. The region just above the surface is a turbulent boundary layer without much net flow. But it's very thin.
Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by nether on Saturday March 19, 2016 @12:41AM (#11317341)
There isn't really any "turbulence" behind any modern wing in typical flight regimes. They're very low drag, so flow off the trailing edge is as smooth as the upstream flow.
Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by nightski on Saturday March 19, 2016 @01:24AM (#11317457)
This was near landing, so I assume flaps were deployed. That changes things a bit.
Re:Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX by throwaway_xx9 on Saturday March 19, 2016 @01:13AM (#11317425)
Well, except for those pesky wingtip vortices that can down a smaller airliner.