Expect much more fear-mongering about drones, and lobbying from the existing aviation industry. This is why much drone research takes place outside the ol' US of A.
100,000 flights per day. 200 people per flight making cell phone calls? How many potential avionics issues are we talking about?
What's the most years we've gone without a major airline accident? Wasn't there a 10 year period at one point?
The FAA regulating, or banning something is them taking a liberty from me. In a free society in order to take my liberty it must only be done after all other avenues of solving the perceived problem have been explored and eliminated.
It damn sure should not be allowed simply out of "an abundance of caution" over a perceived problems that may not actually exist.
Under your world view everything is banned by default unless the government chooses to allow it... That is the opposite of a free society.
Freedom to do as you please is not a real thing - you have to temper that freedom with the requirement to consider the impact on other people. Because you[1] are not special, and your freedoms are no more important than their freedoms.
[1] Sorry I don't really mean to target at YOU but it's a narrative way to make the point. I'm sure you're very special <3
that can be a very dangerous statement depending on how you define or assess "impact on other people"
To me, I should be free to do as I please unless my actions cause or can be proven to likely cause serious injury or death to another person, or cause actual articuable direct damage to another persons legally obtained property.
When you say "impact" another person, that could mean me simply typing an controversial opinion into an online forum, should the government be allowed to ban my opinion simply because it "impacts" a person that reads it?
On the topic of Drones, I believe a more defined Airspace is enough. Carve out simple rules and enforce those simple rules. the FAA today is over complicating the issue, and is putting in place rules that will do nothing to increase actual safety, or address any actual safety issue. The Registration for example is a massive privacy violation with no real world impact on safety.
the FAA, like the FCC has mismanaged the public resource they were charged with managing.
A more sensible solution if we're talking about safety would be to ban human pilots. FWIW I've hundreds of hours of fixed wing and drone piloting experience, respectively, and I have way more control with a drone than with a tonne of grp and aluminium driven by whirling death.
Same with cars.
Huh? There obviously is. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_assessment
There are probably tens of millions of dollars (at least) of lost productivity every year due to the FAA's excessive heavy-handed rules on electronics use during taxi/takeoff/landing.
Banning cell phones during certain parts of flight is essentially just as nonsensical as the example in your last paragraph.
>but there's really no drawback to the FAA for imposing a drone ban.
That is extremely myopic. The most obvious downsides of excessive regulation of UAVs is the suppression of innovation and experimentation with cutting edge vehicle tech. And, of course, most people put some stock in the value of having fun.
I think the point was that FAA does useless and harmful things because they don't have to pay the price themselves.
"taking into consideration the added complexity of design, installing and maintaining an emergency parachute system for a typical passenger jet, the amount of revenue lost by carrying at least 40-45 fewer passengers to compensate for installing such a heavy system, and the extremely unlikelihood such a recovery ever would be required, I can't see trying to scale up a parachute recovery capability for airliner use."
https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-airplanes-have-giant-parachut...
Parachutes increase the cost of ownership, as they have to be replaced every 10 years or so.
A lot of the people buying Cirrus airplanes are taking off into marginal weather and just assume the parachute will save them when their luck runs out.
None! But it could potentially have prevented a lot of the fatalities.
Even if there's one chance in a million of a cell phone affecting avionics or a small drone damaging a plane, the FAA's job is to minimize that risk. They aren't responsible for cost or inconvenience to anyone outside of the aviation industry.
They wouldn't mandate that Boeing install expensive and complicated parachutes in every plane due to the huge cost to the industry and dubious benefit, but there's really no drawback to the FAA for imposing a drone ban.