> Lemke Oliver and Soundararajan’s first guess for why this bias occurs was a simple one: Maybe a prime ending in 3, say, is more likely to be followed by a prime ending in 7, 9 or 1 merely because it encounters numbers with those endings before it reaches another number ending in 3. For example, 43 is followed by 47, 49 and 51 before it hits 53, and one of those numbers, 47, is prime.
> But the pair of mathematicians soon realized that this potential explanation couldn’t account for the magnitude of the biases they found. Nor could it explain why, as the pair found, primes ending in 3 seem to like being followed by primes ending in 9 more than 1 or 7.
The top comment here on HN does not recognise the 'trivial' point that I have made, hence the need to point it out.
And, the "most mathematicians would have assumed..." quote is probably false.
> The primes' preferences about the final digits of the primes that follow them can be explained, Soundararajan and Lemke Oliver found, using a much more refined model of randomness in primes, something called the prime k-tuples conjecture.
So I guess that my observation is just a special case of this "prime k-tuples conjecture".
It's amazing how people can be picky and negative on HN. Someone positive would instead congratulate me for making the gist of what the prime k-tuple conjecture says about the biases easily understandable. Oh well.
Say, there is a fixed and equal probability that each number ending with 9 and 1 is prime. I could go along with that assumption, although the fact that primes get less likely as you go higher is potentially relevant.
What the authors consider here is starting with a prime ending in 9. So the next potential prime ends in 1. If only because 1 is the next number to be checked, a 1-prime is more likely to appear next than a 9-prime. The probability of that can be calculated, depending on your assumptions, as a geometric sequence. In any case, P(next prime is 1) > P(next prime is 9).
"Most mathematicians would have assumed, Granville and Ono agreed, that a [known] prime should have an equal chance of being followed by a prime ending in 1, 3, 7 or 9" So - I'm a definite nope on that.
This result appears to be exactly what I would have assumed was the case.