Being able to self-fund isn't always reason enough to self-fund. In this case, Joel may want to expand into 10,000 niches, but may worry whether the venture will be profitable. I'm just speculating. If there is VC willing to take some of the risk with him, for an equity share that he accepts and thinks is a good deal, is it still wrong for him to accept it? I don't think so.
One possible way to still make a good return off it is take the Twitter path of getting VC money with the hopes of finding some revenue stream down the road. Maybe they can come up with a similar search deal?
Even then, almost none of their SE customers could afford the proposed fees based on their current income.
It is like Twitter in the early days
It's like Twitter now.These are the precise questions that we can't presume to know the answers to. Joel probably has very good answers to these and more questions, and is using them during VC pitches right now. Just because his ideas are not obvious to us doesn't mean he doesn't have something good in mind.
Why not? You say yourself that the 1 in 20 shot at a lot doesn't usually make sense for an entrepreneur with other options. If you prefer a partial cash while betting big with the other piece, why should this mean you don't "believe in the business prospects that they're asking everybody else to invest in?" It doesn't mean this when anyone else does it.
Fred Wilson (avc.com) disagrees. He thinks that letting founders take money off the table is a great idea in several circumstances.
You don't want founders looking for/taking an exit too soon.
http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2010/01/the-tug-of-war-between-ma-an...
Joel listed all these vague reasons that sort of sound good without actually saying concrete steps / changes that would come out of VC funding. I would definitely like to hear what it is that he, despite being one of the most popular tech bloggers with a boatload of notoriety and savings, can't do with Stack Overflow that somehow VC money can.