News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by cptskippy on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @12:46PM (#11246947)
To Microsoft it is. Vulkan and DX12 set out to achieve many of the same goals but DX12 has the added benefit of momentum and market lock-in. DX12 has been available since July where as support for Vulkan is spotty at best. Why drop DX12 for Vulkan besides warm fuzzies?
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @01:17PM (#11247215)
> Why drop DX12 for Vulkan

Because they can make life easier for developers and also benefit from the shared effort. But their whole goal is to make life harder for developers (i.e. those who don't want to be limited to MS walled gardens) as a way of taxing them for not falling in line. A usual crooked monopolistic behavior that MS is so accustomed to.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by cptskippy on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @02:11PM (#11247687)
Prior to Vulkan I would argue that it would make little to no difference. OpenGL is different on every platform you look at and each hardware vendor has produced a slew of proprietary extensions to support features not found in OpenGL. What you end up with is render code written per platform even with OpenGL and on Linux you have different implementations per driver. At least with DX you're only writing 1 renderer for Xbox/Windows.

With Vulkan they finally dropped backwards compatibility, something Microsoft had been doing with each successive version of DX, so it would have been a good time for Microsoft to transition away from DX. But what motivation do they have at this point? OpenGL adoption isn't yet threatening their platform, and with Apple pushing Metal they have even less to worry about. Vulkan has only further fragmented the market because anyone that wishes to use it must also write fallback renderers because of the limited support.

In any case if/when Vulkan does become the industry standard, Microsoft will only need to make an Xbox One API because Windows already has support for Vulkan, better support than any other platform at that.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @02:47PM (#11247960)
> But what motivation do they have at this point?

The motivation can be pretty simple - don't be a jerk. But it's MS. Lock-in is practically in their DNA already.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by pjmlp on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:39PM (#11248910)
Waiting to see Vulkan on the console SDKs....
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @05:04PM (#11249140)
I hope it will happen. But I guess only when competition will be strong enough. I doubt MS will suddenly decide to play nice.
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by pjmlp on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @06:41PM (#11249713)
I was thinking about Nintendo and Sony...
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @08:19PM (#11250178)
I suspect they are in "wait and see" mode. Nintendo did join Vulkan group, unlike MS. They as well might start supporting it. They are smaller, and for them supporting standard technologies is an easy way to attract more developers. Sony also can do it, as a move for reducing MS influence.
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by pjmlp on Wednesday March 09, 2016 @12:54AM (#11251193)
Apple is also on the group, yet it is going with Metal. It is the slowest vendor to adopt OpenGL versions and it has a very bad OpenCL implementation, a standard that they created..

Being on the group means zero if the actions don't follow.

When are you going to properly start bashing Sony, Nintendo, Apple alongside MS?

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Wednesday March 09, 2016 @01:01AM (#11251216)
There is some confusion there. Apple actually aren't in the Vulkan group if I understand correctly.

> When are you going to properly start bashing Sony, Nintendo, Apple alongside MS?

When their influence will be comparable in damage. Apple is probably closest, but not in graphics APIs. Metal is non existent. Apple causes more damage in browsers these days. Remember all the recent articles about Safary is the new IE?

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by pjmlp on Wednesday March 09, 2016 @01:45AM (#11251349)
Sony and Nintendo have much more influence in the consoles and game developers than MS.

Nintendo was the company that introduced the concepts of gated development on the aftermath of 1983`s crash.

Also why not bash NVidia given CUDA or their influential part in DX designs, to the point their cards are almost a mirror of the API?

Google so praised for Vulkan, pushes its own computing API instead of OpenCL.

Intel spends more resources in their DX drivers and their OpenGL support is still pretty shitty. One just needs to delve into the OpenGL developer forums. They were quite known in the games industry for having the driver lie about supported hardware features.

Or by announcing at GDCE 2009 their new graphic analysers tools, with DX only support. To my question what about OpenGL I was given the email of some random dude at Intel.

Yet, only MS gets the bashing.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by KirinDave on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @01:46PM (#11247461)
How does Vulkan make life better for developers today? Isn't that more on hardware devs?
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @02:45PM (#11247937)
> How does Vulkan make life better for developers today?

Assuming Vulkan drivers are ironed out (now they are still fresh), it makes life easier by removing the need to implement different APIs for each platform. By sabotaging such option, MS taxes developers which want to target their Xbox for instance requiring them to use DX12 instead.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by cptskippy on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @03:13PM (#11248205)
How has Microsoft sabotaged Vulkan? They haven't, Windows is one of the very few places that Vulkan will actually run. They offered a competing technology, DX12, that works today... and 6 months ago. Vulkan might work in 6 months... or not.
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @03:16PM (#11248228)
> How has Microsoft sabotaged Vulkan?

By not supporting it on Xbox which is a walled garden. Since Xbox has a significant market share, they essentially force developers not to use Vulkan (and use DX12) if they want to target Xbox. Compare it to browser wars of the past. MS did the same thing exactly, and the only reason they magically started supporting shared Web standards is because they lost those wars. Today it's a real wonder - they even decided to support free video codecs in the browser (while Apple still refuses).

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by Delmania on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:13PM (#11248695)
I'm failing to see how that sabotages Vulkan. As far as I know, Vulkan has only recently reached 1.0, and nVidia JUST started supporting it. Until recently, there was nothing to support.

Your entire complaint is that developers have to do more work if they want to support multiple platforms, which has always been the case. I don't recall the original Final Fantasy getting released on the Sega Genesis. There's never going to be a magical catch-all graphics API because technologies like Metal and DirectX take advantage of known hardware specs and OS features to make the games look good and run fast.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:15PM (#11248714)
> I'm failing to see how that sabotages Vulkan.

In order for cross platform solution to offer value of avoiding duplicate work, it should be really cross platform. MS prevents prevents it by not supporting it on Xbox.

> which has always been the case

Exactly because of such lock-in.

> technologies like Metal and DirectX take advantage of known hardware specs and OS features

Let's not try pretending that MS and Apple do it for any technical reasons. There are none.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by coldtea on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:25PM (#11248800)
I think you just blindly champion Vulkan, an unproven and not read for primetime technology.

The two largest platforms, MS and Apple have their own stacks, Metal and DX12. And they have been maintaining those from years, especially DX12 which comes from decades of DX development.

They should throw all this away (and lose any competitive advantage for their platform in the process) just because there's finally a competent new stack (that's not even ready yet)?

>Let's not try pretending that MS and Apple do it for any technical reasons. There are none.

Would wanting to offer the best possible experience for your platform, to control how and when any new feature is implemented according to your long term plans, and to not mess with lower-common-denominator cross-platform design-by-committee APIs counts as a "technical reason"?

Let's not pretend you ask for this for any technical reason. It's all about developer convenience at best.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:36PM (#11248893)
> I think you just blindly champion Vulkan, an unproven and not read for primetime technology.

It's the only cross platform solution. So yes, it should be pushed forward to make it work. It's not a "blind" push - it's the only reasonable thing out there. Neither Metal nor DX12 plan to do anything comparable. Petty greed of Apple and MS prevents them.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by coldtea on Wednesday March 09, 2016 @06:37AM (#11252304)
>Petty greed of Apple and MS prevents them.

Wanting control of your platform and how it evolves is not "petty greed".

If anything it's the developers that want to save money, by only coding their apps once.

I don't believe platforms should have lowest common denominator standards (and evolve in lockstep) just to make porting easier.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Wednesday March 09, 2016 @03:55PM (#11255681)
Graphics APis should be common. Not making them common is about petty greed. Control of the platform here is done for the sole reason of making cross platform development harder. I.e. hindering competition.
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by cptskippy on Thursday March 10, 2016 @03:11PM (#11261916)
You're asserting that DirectX was developed as a competing API to OpenGL and a lock-in mechanism to hinder competition which is a ridiculous assertion that completely ignores history.

OpenGL started development in 1991 by Silicon Graphics and it's primary focus was on CAD/CAM utilizing expensive hardware accelerators. It was initially only available on IRIX and was never intended for video games. It was not open and the Architectural Review Board that maintained the API was controlled by Silicon Graphics.

Direct3D was developed by a company called RenderMorphics starting in 1992 and was bought by Microsoft in 1994. Direct3D was added to the DirectX suite in 1996 specifically for video game acceleration. At the time Microsoft was shipping their own OpenGL Drivers and would continue to do so until Windows 2000 was released.

Microsoft and Silicon Graphics actually attempted to unify the two APIs under Project Fahrenheit in 1997. Project Fahrenheit consisted of low, medium and high end drivers with Microsoft providing the low-end and Silicon Graphics providing the mid and high end portions. Microsoft abandoned the effort in 1999 because DirectX adoption had taken off and they were focusing resources on the original Xbox console. Silicon Graphics was in financial trouble at the point and it no longer made sense to pursue a project heavily reliant on them.

Silicon Graphics trouble's were reflected in the stagnation of OpenGL development with only incremental releases up to version 1.5 in 2003. SGI would eventually go under and the API would get turned over the Khronos in 2005 but it wasn't until 3DLABS got involved that anything happened and it wasn't until 2007 that OpenGL 2.0 was released. At the point the Xbox 360 has been out for 2 years and Microsoft was heavily invested in DirectX.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by KirinDave on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:57PM (#11249073)
What you are asking for may become a reality, but Vulkan is not something that any reasonable primetime product should have even considered trying to support until what, like... was it 2 months ago now or not yet?

The XBox is not a tech test platform. Neither are the mobile handsets.

Claiming this reality amounts to "sabotage" is somewhat absurd.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @05:06PM (#11249155)
> Claiming this reality amounts to "sabotage" is somewhat absurd.

It's not. MS is not new to sabotaging portability. Learn from history.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by KirinDave on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @05:25PM (#11249295)
I could use that exact logic to point to many other disingenuous working groups and say Vulkan is an attempt to create a new lock-in scheme under the guise of an open technology.

It wouldn't be the first time. "Learn from history."

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @05:45PM (#11249409)
How exactly is it lock-in if unlike MS it's cross platform and cross hardware? Just saying "it's the same logic" doesn't make it the same when it contradicts the facts.
Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by coldtea on Thursday March 10, 2016 @09:03AM (#11259215)
Being cross platform and cross hardware isn't contradictory to lock-in.

Lock-in is about whether, after adopting technology X, it takes substantial effort to go to an alternative technology Y -- not about whether you can take X with you in a different platform/hardware.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by Delmania on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:26PM (#11248811)
>In order for cross platform solution to offer value of avoiding duplicate work, it should be really cross platform. MS prevents prevents it by not supporting it on Xbox.

Vulkan doesn't need to be cross platform because there are tools like Unity which abstract away the graphics API and let developers target a number of platforms.

However, you are lodging a complaint against Microsoft that has been the case for every console device since the first ones were released. However, that being said, not supporting Vulkan on the XBox harms Microsoft more than Vulkan since all that means is some games will not be available on the XBox. Just like there are XBox games that are not available on the PS4, the PC, or the Wii U. There's nothing Microsoft is doing that's out of line with the rest of the console makers. It's the console industry in general.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:32PM (#11248855)
> Vulkan doesn't need to be cross platform because there are tools like Unity which abstract away the graphics API and let developers target a number of platforms.

Unity developers will be doing that double work in such case. And not everyone is using third party engines anyway. Don't think that if something is abstracted, it somehow magically happens for free.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by Delmania on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @04:41PM (#11248927)
> Unity developers will be doing that double work in such case.

I'm pretty sure they're well paid for the efforts.

Re:Microsoft Joins the Eclipse Foundation by shmerl on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @05:07PM (#11249163)
> I'm pretty sure they're well paid for the efforts.

And that cost is passed along the way reaching those who use it including end users ;) Someone will feel the tax.