Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by _delirium on Sunday February 14, 2010 @05:59AM
(#1124419)
I think textual descriptions of child sex are, strangely, still legal, if only because a lot of literature has included them.
Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by wheels on Sunday February 14, 2010 @06:43AM
(#1124454)
According to the article, both textual and visual depictions are still legal if they serve "serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value". What seems problematic is deciding that a Hollywood blockbuster is art, while anime is not.
Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by frederickcook on Sunday February 14, 2010 @10:33AM
(#1124715)
Exactly, it seems very likely that he could be acquitted in higher court on the basis that the comics serve 'serious artistic value,' but again, it is easy to see that a 40 year old man will not risk 15 years in prison when he can be out in one, guaranteed.
Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by iamelgringo on Sunday February 14, 2010 @09:59AM
(#1124663)
There's been a lot of discussion about this over time. Take Vladimir Nabokov's Lolita, for example. It's frankly some of the best prose I have ever read, ever.
The book is written from the perspective of a pedofile lusting after a young girl. Stanley Kubrik's film of the movie in 1962 won an academy award. There was an immense ammount of controversy surround the movie and the book, and they still are. Art or obscenity? We'll be having this discussion for years to come.
Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by BearOfNH on Sunday February 14, 2010 @12:06PM
(#1124850)
One of the few movies where I consider the (1997) remake to be superior to the original. With the absolutely creepy scene where a conversation is punctuated by insects getting bug-zapped.
Neither movie contains anything explicit beyond kissing, as I recall. But there's no doubt what's going on.
Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by jrockway on Sunday February 14, 2010 @06:03AM
(#1124423)
I would not bet fifteen years of my life on this.
Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by _delirium on Sunday February 14, 2010 @06:28AM
(#1124445)
I'm not sure how solid it is either, but for text there are at least some more constraints on what Congress could ban. Fanny Hill (1748) is a very explicit novel about the sexual exploits of a 15-year-old girl, and despite being frequently banned, it was ruled protected by the First Amendment in the U.S. in 1966: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memoirs_v._Massachusetts
Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by jrockway on Sunday February 14, 2010 @10:07AM
(#1124678)
The decision claims that the it ultimately came down to how the book was marketed. Shaky legal ground.
Re:‘Obscene’ U.S. Manga Collector Jailed 6 Months
by pfedor on Sunday February 14, 2010 @04:25PM
(#1125301)
Not necessarily: http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08138/882650-85.stm
I'd like to write some sarcastic reason for this, but I can't even think of one. I have a feeling that "one nation under God" has something to do with it, though.