News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by henrik_w on Monday March 07, 2016 @07:58AM (#11238611)
I agree that there are many problems with LinkedIn, but my (contrarian) view is that it is still useful for me:

- contact information for professional contacts in one place, updated by them

- job offers (yes, mostly good or at least decent)

- can look up people to see their experience and common contacts

- updates on what previous colleagues are up to.

More here: http://henrikwarne.com/2013/08/21/linkedin-good-or-bad/

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by ryandrake on Monday March 07, 2016 @10:05AM (#11239247)
I don't know what LinkedIn you're using that provides you with job offers, but the one I'm on has only lead to recruiter contacts which may or may not lead to interviews, which (so far) have never lead to an actual job offer.

LinkedIn is great if you just want to endlessly socialize with recruiters. Don't worry about finding them: They'll all try to connect with you and chat you up about one of their jobs that is just like the one you have but at another company. Hell, you might even get an interview out of it, but good luck turning that into an actual job in today's picky environment.

And if any of those LinkedIn recruiters are reading this, Try This One Neat Trick That Candidates Love: Instead of approaching someone with a job posting that's basically what he did 2 years ago or what he's doing today, approach him with what he might want to be doing 2 years from now. You'll get better responses, I guarantee it.

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by vonmoltke on Monday March 07, 2016 @10:11AM (#11239282)
> I don't know what LinkedIn you're using that provides you with job offers, but the one I'm on has only lead to recruiter contacts which may or may not lead to interviews, which (so far) have never lead to an actual job offer.

I think it is a language thing. I have noticed that non-native English speakers tend to refer to job ads, recruiter contacts, and such as "job offers". I think it comes down to what sense of "offer" you are using: "to give someone the opportunity to accept or take something" or "to make something available".

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by henrik_w on Monday March 07, 2016 @10:34AM (#11239404)
You're right, they're trying to get me interested in other jobs, which would then lead to an interview etc. Maybe "recruiter proposals" or something would be better.

As for how they should approach you, I recently got annoyed enough by bad approaches to write a blog post about it: http://henrikwarne.com/2015/11/22/recruiting-software-develo...

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by k-mcgrady on Monday March 07, 2016 @10:48AM (#11239484)
>> "LinkedIn is great if you just want to endlessly socialize with recruiters"

Why do you socialise with them? Every few days I check in and accept all connection requests (almost all recruiters). I have email notifications turned off so their messages to me just get ignored. Then when it came time to find a job I replied to three or four of them with my requirements, picked a few companies I liked from each, and had interviews setup. Much more efficient than me having to find these companies myself.

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by _drFaust on Monday March 07, 2016 @04:27PM (#11241838)
That is exactly how I got my current job and how I continue to use linkedin too. It's extremely effective. 3+ recruiters a week, just let em know that now is not a good time but in the future. Network grows and more recruiters hit me up per week. Offers quite a bit of mental security knowing I have an army of recruiter contacts waiting to do my bidding so I can say fuck you to my current job if I wanted.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by qihqi on Monday March 07, 2016 @11:01AM (#11239573)
Except, companies want to hire "experts". They want to hire people who have done X to do X, instead of people who haven't done X but want to do it.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by SOLAR_FIELDS on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:14PM (#11243160)
As an anecdotal opposite I went from working in local government to an engineer in Fortune 5 company because a recruiter hit me up on LinkedIn. Now I'm not saying that my hard work didn't help but I don't think I'd be on the remotely same path had that not happened.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by mooreds on Monday March 07, 2016 @10:24AM (#11239342)
I agree with you about everything except the job offers. But even just the other three points are very good.

I have gotten to the point that whenever I consider a client, job offer or employee, I:

- google them for general information

- look them up on LinkedIn to see what they've done professionally and/or if we have anyone in common. (Yes, they may see I have checked out their profile--so what?)

- look for them on twitter (much lower hit ratio)

All this gives me a much rounder perspective on a person than I would have without these resources.

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by rrdharan on Monday March 07, 2016 @10:35AM (#11239410)
Agreed, I basically follow the same process when I'm going to interact with someone professionally.

> Yes, they may see I have checked out their profile--so what?)

You can actually turn that off - it means you won't be able to see visitors to your own profile, but I don't care about that information either so I have it disabled.

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by mooreds on Monday March 07, 2016 @11:35AM (#11239787)
> You can actually turn that off

I actually like to see who has looked at me (I guess it is an ego thing), but yes, that's a good point.

Speaking of ego, one of the developers I worked with recently said, jokingly, that LinkedIn is where she goes when she's feeling down, because she has recruiters contacting her all the time (she has a number of years of Angular experience).

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by jfoster on Monday March 07, 2016 @08:17AM (#11238674)
My feeling is that you have to compare it with other sites in the same category. If you do that, I think it comes away looking really, really good. Pretty much everyone is on it, it does the things you listed, and the level of bs compared to any other site in the category is actually low, in my opinion.

Caveat: I'm unfamiliar with the US/EU status quo for this category; maybe there are better options in those markets?

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by blowski on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:26AM (#11239007)
I find a combination of attending meetups, having a personal website, and contributing to StackOverflow to be much more effective than LinkedIn. There's less spam, because the people and jobs are much more interesting.

Your mileage may vary, but as a WASPish male mid-level dev based in London, this is true for me. I can appreciate that people outside that circle may get more value from LinkedIn.

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by henrik_w on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:51AM (#11239175)
I have an (admittedly not very active) account on SO (1400 karma), but over the years I've only received one job offer via SO.

LinkedIn on the other hand gets me maybe one offer per month on average.

I also have a blog at http://henrikwarne.com/ but I have never received any job offers via it.

I go to very few meet-ups, but the ones I've been to have never generated any offers. So in my experience, LinkedIn wins hands down in that respect (I'm in Stockholm, Sweden).

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by mixmastamyk on Monday March 07, 2016 @12:40PM (#11240203)
I don't think he's saying that the webpage attracts job offers, just that by having an easy to find presence online, people are able to find him.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by blowski on Monday March 07, 2016 @04:44PM (#11241969)
Exactly. I have had a few cold interview offers through StackOverflow, even fewer from my website. But after meeting people at events, they check my website, and in some cases this leads to further discussion. The 'spam-vs-interesting' ratio of those discussions is much better compared to what I used to get when I had a LinkedIn account.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by x1798DE on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:11AM (#11238905)
For developers specifically, I feel like Stack Overflow Careers our jobs or whatever) is about a million times better than LinkedIn, but it doesn't have the social aspect, I guess.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by cullenking on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:23AM (#11238988)
Haven't used it while looking for a job, but we've used SO to post and have not had good luck. Craigslist yields better results for a mobile dev in Portland, and costs one tenth of SO. Additionally my business partner and I received no less than 20 unsolicited recruiter and contract services spam emails each, and I wasn't even on the job posting!
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by mooreds on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:39PM (#11241026)
> I wasn't even on the job posting!

Maybe they found you on LinkedIn :)

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by vzip on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:20AM (#11238966)
I appreciate that it's not 'social'. I don't think I'd use it if it resembled a social network.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by dev360 on Monday March 07, 2016 @08:49AM (#11238804)
>> the level of bs compared to any other site in the category is actually low, in my opinion

I remember trying to figure out how to unsubscribe to emails from (I think) careerbuilder a few years ago and it was an absolute mess.

>>> maybe there are better options in those markets?

One site that seems most nimble right now would probably be indeed. They are growing a lot particularly here in europe and are more flexible in their partnering agreements. I work at the moment for a SaaS recruiting product, and I know all the big players are a pain to work with for integrations.. just reams of red tape.

Another thing that is far more common in europe is that the job sites are much more fragmented. There are so many craigslist type sites that are driving lots of traffic that recruiters want to integrate with.

Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by toong on Monday March 07, 2016 @08:56AM (#11238840)
Europe is using LinkedIn as well. I don't even know about any alternatives ?
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by eamsen on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:17AM (#11238940)
Xing is a popular alternative for the German-speaking markets.
Re:Ten years on LinkedIn by realusername on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:15AM (#11238926)
In France Viadeo is really strong, it's probably 50/50 with LinkedIn and most people have both, I guess every country has their own local equivalent.