News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sarcastic Font by albertsun on Saturday February 13, 2010 @07:13PM (#1123842)
Irony is no fun if it's clearly marked.

In fact it completely defeats the purpose of irony. It's like explaining a joke until you've completely killed it.

Re:Sarcastic Font by rbanffy on Saturday February 13, 2010 @08:36PM (#1123928)
I am assuming a low level of sarcasm in your post.

Isn't it funny when you need a font to mark subtle forms of humour because so many people won't get it without some help?

Damn... It's hard to do this when you don't know how many levels of subtle jokes are piled upon this topic...

Re:Sarcastic Font by SirWart on Saturday February 13, 2010 @07:26PM (#1123855)
With the general level of discourse on the internet, it's hard to be sarcastic and not be taken as a troll. There are subtle intonation cues when speaking face-to-face that can't really be translated well to text. So I would say that the sarcasm is ruined if it is too clearly marked, but it helps if it is marked in some way.
Re:Sarcastic Font by nollidge on Saturday February 13, 2010 @07:48PM (#1123875)
The problem is that sarcasm or ironic speech is meant to subvert the listener's expectations. You say something, people initially hear it straight, but then realize it's ridiculous and you're not being serious, and they find the juxtaposition amusing.

If you demarcate such language beforehand with backtalics or <sarcasm> tags, then there is no such juxtaposition and thus no realization.

Plus, while difficult, there are ways to hint an intonation in text.

I mean, hel-LO, it's so OBvious.

Re:Sarcastic Font by scott_s on Saturday February 13, 2010 @08:46PM (#1123944)
Most people use their tone of voice to indicate sarcasm. When someone uses a sarcastic tone of voice, I submit that we don't initially hear it straight, back up and rethink it.

Your thinking only applies to a true deadpan comment with a straight tone of voice - that's not the majority of sarcastic comments we hear.

Re:Sarcastic Font by ax0n on Saturday February 13, 2010 @08:02PM (#1123885)
Indeed. It's like having to point out irony. The subtlety of well-played irony and sarcasm are part of what makes them so great.
Re:Sarcastic Font by lesterbuck on Saturday February 13, 2010 @10:17PM (#1124066)
Backtalics seems to be a neologism. I kind of like it.
Re:Sarcastic Font by nandemo on Saturday February 13, 2010 @08:55PM (#1123959)
But if it's so hard to get irony from text then how in the world can people read Shakespeare, Swift, Oscar Wilde, etc?
Re:Sarcastic Font by mbrubeck on Sunday February 14, 2010 @12:36AM (#1124200)
You don't think Shakespeare and Wilde had to work pretty hard to get their wit onto the page? The average weblog commenter who tries is rather less successful.
Re:Sarcastic Font by rapind on Saturday February 13, 2010 @11:11PM (#1124122)
Unmarked sarcasm is a higher form of wit.
Re:Sarcastic Font by Confusion on Sunday February 14, 2010 @07:23AM (#1124500)
Irony is no fun if it's clearly marked.

This is clearly false, as both irony and sarcasm are usually delimited by both changes in speech and nonverbal cues. The better you know each other, the fewer of such cues are necessary, but especially among 'new' people, you'd better make sure they get you are being sarcastic/ironic, lest they get a completely wrong impression of you. The lack of cues and subsequent misunderstandings is exactly the problem with speech on the internet and is exactly why things like italics exist: to be able to shift emphasis like you'd do with speech or nonverbal cues.

Re:Sarcastic Font by DrJokepu on Sunday February 14, 2010 @07:39AM (#1124518)
both irony and sarcasm are usually delimited by both changes in speech and nonverbal cues

You've obviously never been to England.

Re:Sarcastic Font by alecthomas on Sunday February 14, 2010 @09:41AM (#1124643)
For the English the delimiters are the start and end of conversation.