I'm not sure what story you want me to back up is? If you are claiming that the current law requires the SIP to be consistent in the CAP sense, I'll defer to you and ask that you point out why you think so?

If you are asking about evidence that some people have claimed that the SIP being non-consistent is a problem for audit and regulatory compliance, is that not what you yourself are arguing in this post? http://www.nanex.net/Research/IsNBBOIgnored.html

I think maybe you are reading into my comment something that isn't there?