News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by _delirium on Saturday February 13, 2010 @02:49AM (#1122722)
That's not the only reason to cut work weeks, though I agree it's a bad one. This old article by Bertrand Russell starts out by pointing out that the "fixed pie" view is not a good reason to work less, but that there are others: http://www.zpub.com/notes/idle.html

The gist of it is that you can take the dividends of increasing productivity in a lot of ways. As computers get faster, you can keep paying $2k for a new computer every 3-4 years and get a better one, or you can take some of that technology-advancement dividend in cash, and buy a netbook that's still better than your old computer. He's basically arguing that you should take some of the modern era's productivity dividend in leisure time, instead of just in more income and material wealth.

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by ryanwaggoner on Saturday February 13, 2010 @03:20AM (#1122739)
Oh, don't get me wrong, I think there could be a great case for cutting work weeks. The article caught my eye because I was hoping that they had done an actual study that indicated that working fewer hours would lead to higher overall productivity (though I think that cutting them by 50 - 70% is probably wishful thinking).
Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by breck on Saturday February 13, 2010 @11:10AM (#1123128)
I think it was focused more on productivity, and not focused on the unemployment rate. I think the BBC added that twist.

From the author of the report:

"So many of us live to work, work to earn, and earn to consume, and our consumption habits are squandering the earth's natural resources.

"Spending less time in paid work could help us to break this pattern. We'd have more time to be better parents, better citizens, better carers and better neighbours.

"We could even become better employees - less stressed, more in control, happier in our jobs and more productive.

"It is time to break the power of the old industrial clock, take back our lives and work for a sustainable future."

Basically, it seems the argument is that the more hours we work, the externalities of work increase sharply (you don't have time to spend raising your kids, taking care of your health, and you do have more money to spend on things you don't need).

Basically, at 21 hours, the marginal return from working another hour at your job equals the marginal return from spending an hour doing your own stuff. Beyond 21 hours the marginal return from working (minus externalities), is less than the return from focusing on your own activities.

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by yummyfajitas on Saturday February 13, 2010 @09:44AM (#1123047)
You can take the modern era's productivity dividend in leisure time. About 37 million Americans do.

For this group of people, the average family is supported by only 800 hours of work/year (about 16 hours/week).

This group of people has all the food they need (in fact, they typically eat vastly more than they need), a house to live in (about half own the home), most own an AC, a car, a TV, all the basic comforts.

You can read about this group of people, their lifestyle and their choices here:

http://www.heritage.org/research/welfare/bg1713.cfm

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by jbooth on Saturday February 13, 2010 @10:50AM (#1123104)
There are not 37 million people collecting welfare. Go look at some budget graphics, welfare and human services are a tiny, tiny slice of our budget. It's a small dividend that they're getting.

(FYI: For things regarding welfare, do not read heritage unless you're applying a skeptical eye. Everyone has an agenda, but their entire purpose of being is an agenda.)

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by yummyfajitas on Saturday February 13, 2010 @11:04AM (#1123117)
Neither I, nor the article, made the claim that there are 37 million people collecting welfare. Perhaps you should read sources before declaring them incorrect?

Incidentally, this article is simply an aggregations of statistics available from various government sources (e.g., census, BLS). Regardless of their agenda, their facts seem well supported.

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by jbooth on Saturday February 13, 2010 @03:42PM (#1123515)
The article's an aggregation of ridiculous statistics designed to justify instinctive conservative feelings that the poor are siphoning away their wealth.

"Average poor american has bigger living arrangements than the average Paris resident" -- really? The average subsistence farmer has bigger living arrangements than the average Manhattan banker, as well.

The US is a very capitalistic country (in a good way) and we have very little in the way of social welfare (in a sometimes inefficient way) -- being poor here isn't easy, even if it's not an automatic death sentence.

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by yummyfajitas on Saturday February 13, 2010 @05:25PM (#1123672)
I'm not sure what your consider "ridiculous" about the statistics. They are simply indicators of material wealth. Could you tell me which statistics you feel are "ridiculous" and why?

What the article shows is that in terms of living conditions, the American poor do not suffer much. Most of them have enough space to live in (more than Manhattan bankers you probably consider rich), enough food to eat (also more than those Manhattan bankers, judging by waistlines), a car to drive and all sorts of household appliances. In short, the poor have all their material needs met, and they manage this with only 16 hours of work/week.

In fact, the article shows that the modern poor are richer than the middle class of the recent past. In short, you can take the modern era's productivity gains and spend it on leisure rather than material wealth. Millions of people already do so.

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by jbooth on Saturday February 13, 2010 @06:16PM (#1123762)
Well, I think the use of the word "leisure" is really what set me off here. Most underemployed people aren't underemployed by choice. Given that we just went from 5% to 10% unemployment by the official numbers, a whole bunch of people are underemployed through no choice of their own. They may own a home but they're probably having trouble making payments and living with a ton of anxiety, especially if they have families.

What I consider "ridiculous" about the statistics is that they aren't indicators of anything -- they're just ways of slicing things so that they appeal to the mindset I described above. In reality, many of these people keep trying harder and harder but good jobs are fewer and farther between -- not everybody is in technology or the service economy.

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by yummyfajitas on Saturday February 13, 2010 @10:38PM (#1124093)
Most poor people are not underemployed. In 2007, out of 37 million poor people, there were only 2.5 million people who were underemployed (see Table 8 of my source below).

Additionally, out of 37.3 million poor people, only 7.5 million were either employed or seeking work for more than 27 weeks/year.

http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2007.pdf

I'm also curious why you are bringing this up again: I already pointed out your mistaken beliefs about the working habits of the poor 9 days ago.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1102216

As for the statistics given in my previous source, they are indicators of the fact that the modern poor are richer than the middle class of recent history. All of which proves my original point: "You can take the modern era's productivity dividend in leisure time."

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by jbooth on Saturday February 13, 2010 @11:17PM (#1124132)
Do you honestly believe that this whole group of people is out there, kicking back, and content/happy about not having productive employment?

I mean, I'm sure there are some, but you really think that, let's say, a majority of the people you're painting with this brush are saying to themselves "yeah man, why get a job, it's not like I'm gonna starve to death"? What % of the poor would you say they are, ballpark? Honest question, or if you'd prefer, how else am I missing your point?

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by yummyfajitas on Sunday February 14, 2010 @09:15AM (#1124610)
I have no idea if they are content and happy. I never claimed that using productivity gains for leisure would make anyone happy, I just claimed it's possible to do without serious material suffering.

But the fact that 80% of the poor are not even looking for a job suggests they are not that unhappy about lacking productive employment.

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by sb on Saturday February 13, 2010 @08:34AM (#1122993)
Thank you very much for the interesting link to Bertrand Russel's take on this issue. Some time ago, another very interesting piece of Betrand Russel was linked by another HN user, and I have to say that reading Mr. Russel's essays should be required reading for some classes; probably in addition to reading some of his mathematical work, which is highly recommended, too.

That aside, I think that the article does not address another important (probably too recent) reason/ambition for increased work load: improving ones social status. As already indicated this probably was a non-issue when the article was authored, but then again my comment would fall into the just-for-the-record category...

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by gridspy on Saturday February 13, 2010 @03:02PM (#1123441)
Increasing your status at work is seductive and easy, but temporary. Increasing your status in society at large requires investment of time and/or money in your local community, open source or building a community on-line.

Spending less time at work makes it possible to do all these things and it is something that I would very much like to do.

Of course, since I am working 60-70 hour work weeks, perhaps doing other stuff is just seductive to me right now.

Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by olefoo on Saturday February 13, 2010 @03:51AM (#1122759)
Not only that but in an era where one's productivity is directly tied to one's creativity, more downtime is more productive.
Re:Report suggests 21 hours is the ideal work week by gaius on Saturday February 13, 2010 @08:58AM (#1123007)
That isn't the case for the vast majority of the workforce.