News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by bjackman on Thursday March 03, 2016 @04:07AM (#11215774)
Remember that the sluice gates are seized. Obviously they should still drain it but it's not as simple as making the call.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by rwallace on Thursday March 03, 2016 @04:26AM (#11215836)
Would it suffice to just take a stick of dynamite to one of the seized gates?
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by yiyus on Thursday March 03, 2016 @09:54AM (#11217130)
I am just guessing here, but I would expect that there are better ways to solve the issue with the gate that are easier, safer and even cheaper than dynamite.

The article says only one of two gates has problems, but they cannot open only one because of the asymmetry that would introduce. So, to solve the problem with dynamite, it would be necessary to make very good calculations to be sure you make exactly the hole you want, then actually do it with a very high precision (for an explosion).

I do not think opening that gate is as much a technical problem as a problem of initiative and responsibility.

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by adrianN on Thursday March 03, 2016 @06:52AM (#11216275)
What could possibly go wrong?
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by acveilleux on Thursday March 03, 2016 @09:52AM (#11217118)
Various forms of shaped charges and explosives could be used to open the sluice gates but that would leave them permanently opened.

The main fear here is that if the dam reaches its design head, the water will tunnel underneath and around the dam through the water soluble rocks. The dam can't exceed the design head because of the spillway that is visible to the south east of the dam.

So explosives could well be used to force open the sluice gates.

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by astrodust on Thursday March 03, 2016 @01:43PM (#11218912)
> So explosives could well be used to force open the sluice gates.

This would make for a great Michael Bay movie, but real life doesn't work that way.

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by samstave on Thursday March 03, 2016 @03:16PM (#11219681)
We should use nano-thermite like we did on that other inside job ;-)
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by rwallace on Thursday March 03, 2016 @08:35AM (#11216701)
You (and at least one other) reacted as though I had claimed such an action would come with a guarantee nothing could go wrong. Which is, to put it bluntly, a rather stupid reaction given that:

1. I didn't make a claim. I asked a question.

2. According to the experts, the clock is currently ticking down on a million lives with no idea of how much time is left, so your implied suggestion of doing nothing (which is the implied suggestion when you summarily dismiss a line of thought while providing nothing in its place) is... well, how exactly would you describe the suggestion of just letting a million people die, had it come from someone else?

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by adrianN on Thursday March 03, 2016 @09:07AM (#11216856)
It just seems to me that using explosives on a structure where collapse is imminent in order to fix it sounds like the most dangerous idea one could possibly have.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by rwallace on Thursday March 03, 2016 @09:17AM (#11216919)
First of all, according to what the experts are saying, the most dangerous idea one could possibly have is your idea of doing nothing - that guarantees the worst-case outcome.

Second, one would normally expect the force required to break the dam to be orders of magnitude larger than that required to open a sluice gate. Obviously this isn't a normal situation, but then, what are the figures? If a stick of dynamite isn't the appropriate tool, exactly what would it take to open the gates?

Third, if you could say 'we are going to try this at such and such a time, everyone be prepared' that would be far better than having it fail at an unknown time.

Fourth, now that I think of it, even deliberately blowing up the dam at a known time would be better than letting it fail at an unknown time.

Fifth, I'm sure there is some relevant idea or consideration I haven't thought of, that someone else could think of if they put their mind to doing so.

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by ArkyBeagle on Thursday March 03, 2016 @01:03PM (#11218610)
I'm sure it can be done safely, but a stick of dynamite probably isn't the way.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by foota on Thursday March 03, 2016 @04:17AM (#11215794)
How could they drain it?
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by techdragon on Thursday March 03, 2016 @05:24AM (#11216008)
I would imagine siphoning might be a simple enough process and could be setup in multiple places along the dam to avoid the asymmetric draining issues mentioned further in the discussion here on hacker news.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by tim333 on Thursday March 03, 2016 @07:19AM (#11216365)
You can syphon up about 30ft. The dam is 371 ft.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by Blaque on Thursday March 03, 2016 @07:52AM (#11216514)
Can you explain why a syphon won't work over 30ft?
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by Errsher on Thursday March 03, 2016 @08:05AM (#11216572)
"This siphon effect relies on atmospheric pressure to allow the pressure and pressure potential energy to drop as the water travels upward inside the sealed pipe. But eventually the pressure of the rising water reaches zero and no further reductions in pressure and pressure potential energy are possible. That failure of the siphon effect occurs when the water is about 30 feet (10 meters) above the higher container. You can't use a siphon to lift water higher than 30 feet because above that height, an empty region will develop at the top of the pipe and stop the siphon process."

http://www.physicscentral.com/experiment/askaphysicist/physi...

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by reubenmorais on Thursday March 03, 2016 @10:16AM (#11217278)
It's not atmospheric pressure:

"Here we report an experiment of a siphon operating at sea level at a height of 15 m, well above 10 m. Prior degassing of the water prevented cavitation. This experiment provides conclusive evidence that siphons operate through gravity and molecular cohesion."

http://www.nature.com/articles/srep16790

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by cnvogel on Thursday March 03, 2016 @11:47AM (#11218039)
Quote from the conclusion:

"""Extrapolating these results from even the most conservative experimental measurements of the tension under which cavitation occurs it is possible that the cohesive strength of fully degassed water is able to support a continuous vertical column greater than several hundred meters. While the experiment performed here did not reach anywhere near the absolute limit predicted it does shed light on the stability of flowing water under tensile stress and the possibility of constructing apparatus of suitable dimensions to test such a limit. (...) In view of the many anomalies of bulk water, it would be interesting to explore the physical properties of water in the negative pressure regime of a siphon above 10 m."""

So, as long as we don't break the water column by bubbles (or other impurities in the water that will lead to formations of bubbles on their surface) we could empty the Mosul dam via a siphon.

That's a fascinating result! We only have to remove the rocks, the fish and put the dam under high-vacuum for outgassing for a few weeks ;-). If we don't do that, the old atmospheric pressure model holds, and the siphon will be limited to 10 metres, 30 ft.

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by reubenmorais on Thursday March 03, 2016 @11:56AM (#11218112)
I wasn't implying that the result from the paper is applicable to draining the dam, just that we should stop explaining the siphon effect in terms of atmospheric pressure now that we know it's not the case.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by cnvogel on Thursday March 03, 2016 @12:22PM (#11218304)
I seriously was amazed about the result, with a "block" of water being able to withstand tension. Also the working principle of a siphon, I think, never was about atmospheric pressure. It's only the maximum height limit where pressure comes into place.

As long as you are below the limit, you can still claim that the "two sides" of your siphon are held together by the pressure extorted on both sides by our atmosphere. And only as you exceed this limit you'll require the water to resist actively to be "pulled apart".

Unfortunately this interesting property is pretty irrelevant in real-life situations where water you'd like to siphon contains dirt, rocks, crockodiles... And these impurities will make your "water cable" break as soon as (or probably just a little later when...) you reach vacuum on the top, at 10m.

https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=(1+atmospheres)+%2F+(d...

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by mikecb on Thursday March 03, 2016 @08:39AM (#11216721)
What about running the tube over the dam and down to a lower level than it originates? Then gravity(?) does the trick?
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by taco_emoji on Thursday March 03, 2016 @09:14AM (#11216908)
The issue is that top of the dam is (way) over 30 feet above the water level behind the dam, which prevents the suction from overcoming gravity. A siphon won't work with that much of a rise in the middle no matter what the difference is between the elevations of the ends of the tube.

Also what you're describing is literally how all siphons must work--you can't siphon to a higher elevation.

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by sangnoir on Thursday March 03, 2016 @09:00AM (#11216821)
It would only work if the difference between the water level and the top of the wall is less than rouhgly 30ft (as per xkcd). The bottom line is, the siphon will not work if it has a vertical water column taller than 30ft (water weight per unit area becomes greater than opposing atmospheric pressure)
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by robin_reala on Thursday March 03, 2016 @08:32AM (#11216684)
http://what-if.xkcd.com/143/ has more details (and a rather more fantastical situation).
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by techdragon on Thursday March 03, 2016 @11:49AM (#11218055)
Putting aside the obvious detail that the dam would be empty already if we were trying to siphon water up a full 371 feet... Your correct, the entire thread this spawned was educational, and I learned something new today which was pretty damn interesting. Interesting enough I'm not bothered by the small karma loss my initial comment incurred.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by foota on Thursday March 03, 2016 @04:05PM (#11220028)
Actually though, you could presumably cut holes in the dam as you go. So siphon off the top 30ft, then cut a hole at 341 feet and siphon through there.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by tizzdogg on Thursday March 03, 2016 @02:23PM (#11219280)
Why not use pumps instead of syphoning?
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by hyperion2010 on Thursday March 03, 2016 @04:22AM (#11215819)
Dig an alternate channel.
Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by acveilleux on Thursday March 03, 2016 @10:00AM (#11217180)
That's called a spillway BTW and the problem with spillways is erosion and the energy of the water. So spillways have to be made of reinforced concrete or similarly strong materials when the local rock isn't hard enough and they have to be shaped to dissipate the energy.

The spillway of the Mosul dam is made of concrete the problem with it appears to be that it allows too high a water level for the dam in its current shape even when fully open.

Re:Mosul dam engineers warn it could fail at any time, killi... by foota on Thursday March 03, 2016 @04:54AM (#11215912)
I'm not sure it would be quite so simple. The article mentions the reason that they can't just open one gate is because the asymmetric draining would be harmful to the dam. It's possible that any sort of adhoc draining would adversely affect the dam. Not to mention quickly building a secure tunnel to handle the water pressure at that depth sounds like no mean feat.