News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The smart home freak show stops here by mschuster91 on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @08:44AM (#11209830)
> my gas stove would not have a pilot light

A gas water heater usually has an always on pilot light to avoid leaking unburned gas in case the main valve is stuck-open (or not fully closed). It's a failsafe, not a bug. (Which is why many heating systems refuse to turn back on automatically if they detect the pilot light goes off)

> Commercial buildings have had computers driving heating and cooling systems for a couple of decades

And they're expensive as fuck, and even today companies manage to mess up their setup (Berlin Airport cough).

Re:The smart home freak show stops here by officialchicken on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @05:42PM (#11213645)
Always-on systems constantly burning petrofuels are an engineering failure. Solar radiators acting as heat exchangers have no pilot light. Neither do "instahots" or on-demand water heating systems that waste energy keeping 50+ gallons at 82+ degrees F. As for your stove, well, let's just say that there are other options for lighting them, including a bic or more "exotic" electric heat.

They're only expensive "as fuck" because they're more like an overpriced SCADA system with multiple fail-overs and backups than the 12-20v system you have in your home. But that happens when you have 10 - 250 tons of heating and cooling for 500 - 30,000 people in a building.

For every over-engineered Berlin Airport (Siemens runs there, right? Arup won't make that make mistake) I can show you 10,000 buildings, factories, and warehouses done right. Or one Viipuri library (1935).

Re:The smart home freak show stops here by mschuster91 on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @06:35PM (#11213959)
> Solar radiators acting as heat exchangers have no pilot light

Depending on the technology used, not entirely true. If molten salt is used as heat exchange medium, it must be kept above its melting temperature at all times or you can scrap all the pipework.