News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by nostromo on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:14PM (#11205251)
Imagine New York City -- where unless a car appears as if it is ready and willing to kill pedestrians people will jaywalk directly in front of it.

Now imagine New York City clogged up with self driving cars -- frozen at each intersection in fear of hitting someone. It'd be a disaster.

Humans will quickly understand that these cars are easily bullied, and many will take advantage of that. Why wait for your turn when you can just cut off a driverless car?

Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by kps on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:33PM (#11205407)
I'd like to work on Artificial Road Rage. There are some great opportunities, especially for networked vehicles. You cut off one Taxy™? Now there are 50,000 tons of mobile neural net wandering the city looking for ways to make your life miserable.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by brbsix on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:45PM (#11205496)
This has been a free market dream of mine. There's no need for a state to enforce minor traffic violations (and who knows what else) when "the network" is willing to do the enforcement. However this poses a huge problem when the rules are dictated by a central coercive entity rather than by consensus.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by jMyles on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:25PM (#11205343)
> Humans will quickly understand that these cars are easily bullied, and many will take advantage of that. Why wait for your turn when you can just cut off a driverless car?

"bullied?"

This doesn't sound like bullying to me; it sounds like utilizing the roadway properly (whereas 'jaywalking' laws paint a picture of the roadway as belonging to vehicles, which we New Yorkers protest everyday).

If anything, driverless cars might make occupants more patient when dealing with pedestrians with whom they share the roadway. If you can chill and listen to music, read something, etc, maybe you won't be in such a hurry.

Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by david-given on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:54PM (#11205563)
How long's it going to take before someone starts selling T-shirts with pictures of stop signs on them? What's going to happen when a self-driving car sees someone wearing one standing by the side of the road?
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by jMyles on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:57PM (#11205582)
This is an awesome low-tech hack idea, but my sense is that if they can't distinguish a t-shirt from a road sign, there will have been other far more serious computerviz problems.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by kpil on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @04:22PM (#11206165)
The state of the art is actually that the car can't tell diddly squat apart unless it's in the car's map database. So unless you hack the database and stand at the correct spot you can dress as any traffic sign you like...
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by maxerickson on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @08:55PM (#11207633)
This video from 2014 shows the software identifying a cyclist making a hand signal...

https://googleblog.blogspot.co.at/2014/04/the-latest-chapter...

Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by kpil on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:20PM (#11207718)
Yes, obviously the car need to keep track of dynamic objects, but the algorithms are heavily dependent on a very detailed world map. It's a very long way until the three laws...
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:19PM (#11205292)
Unless behavior changes, perhaps because something changed regarding enforcement of laws governing pedestrians which changed the perceived incentives. Which, were self-driving cars to become more common and, consequently, moving violations by human drivers less of a problem for traffic and safety and pedestrian violations relatively more of a problem for traffic, would probably happen.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by Retric on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:52PM (#11205543)
Don't forget people need ~250ms (1/4 second) to react to someone, self driving cars could easily operate at 1/10th that. So, a person needs 9 feet to stop at 10MPH, but a self driving car might only need 5 feet. If anything self driving cars will look like they are going to hit you far more than human drivers. http://www.random-science-tools.com/physics/stopping-distanc...

Also, people don't as a rule physically touch cars when jwalking. Thus, a self driving car rarely needs to stop even with significant number of people jwalking. At worst they slow down, but again less than you might think.

Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by imgabe on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:27PM (#11205360)
All the cops freed up from having to write speeding and parking tickets can hand out jaywalking tickets instead.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by yolesaber on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @03:23PM (#11205744)
If cops start handing out tickets for jaywalking in NYC I can guarantee you there will be hell to pay. If there's one thing New Yorkers hold more dear than their bagels, it's their ability to jaywalk as they please.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by sentenza on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @03:05PM (#11205633)
You don't even need humans for safety features to become a problem: Every day, I drive on a road that goes through the German woods. The road is barely wide enough for two average-sized cars to pass each other. If one car is wider than average, then one of the cars has to go off the road onto the dirt-and-stones shoulder.

The speed limit there is 60km/h. Nearly all the humans drive 80. If you drive 60 there, you will cause a queue to form behind you, because there is so much traffic on that 5km stretch of road.

The reason why I consider this to be such a good example is because there is no solution here for self-driving cars that will work in the real world.

If you just put self-driving cars as they are on that road, then you'll convert it into a giant traffic jam.

Of course, the only _logical_ way forward would be to widen that road so that it can actually sustain its traffic load, but that is not a real-world solution.

Because a) The local levels of government are too broke to fix all the roads like this even on a time scale of decades (!) and b) the road was built on the private property of local nobility in the 1920s (for weird historical reasons) and they have refused to give up the land for the road to be widened on at least one occasion in the past.

Now, this is Germany, possibly the most orderly car-nation on the planet. What about Italy? Or India? Or South Africa?

Self-driving vehicles will become ubiquitous on the Autobahns and in rectangular American cities. I would be very surprised if there were still many human truck drivers doing cross-Europe tours 30 years from now. But human-driven cars will not disappear in the lifetime of anybody reading this, simply because outside of a few well-planned environments, you have to bend the rules to maintain traffic flow.

Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by msellout on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @02:14PM (#11212205)
Or, there might end up being fewer cars on the road because it's so easy to jump on a self-driving bus, then transfer at the station (with no waiting time) to a small pooled ride...
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by Mandatum on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @07:31PM (#11207341)
This is my biggest gripe when it comes to implementing self-driving vehicles. Once it gets to the 80%ish range and a lot of people can spot an self-driving car from a pedestrian-driving car, I just know there'll be so many people that will walk in-front of those cars because it's faster for the pedestrian than waiting to cross the road.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by DrScump on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @08:57PM (#11207641)
<Humans will quickly understand that these cars are easily bullied, and many will take advantage of that.>

I do see a theoretical risk of induced accidents for the purpose of damage/injury claims. For example, jamming the LIDAR and using one's parking brake to stop abruptly without triggering the brake lights.

Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by fixermark on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:17PM (#11205281)
This topic comes up over and over again, and people keep missing a key difference between automated vehicles and human drivers---automated vehicles have cameras and perfect memories.

How many times do people get to play that game until the NYPD is flooded with metrics on where to go to hand out free jaywalking tickets?

Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by jMyles on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:28PM (#11205365)
They won't do that though, because they know that there will then be clamor for repeal of jaywalking laws.

I'm at 32nd and 2nd as I type this, and let me tell you: pedestrian pride is SERIOUS in NYC. We don't give a fuck about jaywalking laws, and if they start making this city impossible to walk in, city hall will hear about it.

Currently, jaywalking laws are (disgustingly) used to target people that police want to target and for no other reason. If you put it to a vote, I think that the vast majority of NYCers will prefer an "implied crosswalk" law, where pedestrians have the right-of-way in all situations except when they jump in front of moving traffic.

Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by coderdude on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:43PM (#11205488)
Let natural selection run its course. At some point humans will evolve an instinct to not walk in front of a moving vehicle.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by the8472 on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:31PM (#11205386)
Or the computer-controlled car could simply keep track of humans in its immediate vicinity and use any momentary gap that arises. It has a much much lower reaction delay than humans. Combine with electric engines and they can practically jump into any gap.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by maxerickson on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @08:57PM (#11207640)
There will frequently be passengers in the car. Comfort puts a practical limit on how much stopping and starting you can do.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by msellout on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @04:08PM (#11206064)
"Jaywalking" was originally a marketing campaign by the motor vehicle industry before it became law. Your description sounds like a return to the way it ought to be. The bully is the human driver who threatens to kill a pedestrian by being inattentive.
Re:The Trollable Self-Driving Car by Lewton on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:53PM (#11205552)
Simple: Just program the AI cars to randomly kill a pedestrian who jaywalks every million miles or so.

Oh wait. That's crazy-talk you say?

Well that's the exact same system we have in place right now