Re:The DROWN Attack
by tptacek on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:52AM
(#11203960)
RSA OAEP and PSS is just as unlikely to win the Internet as ECDH and curve signatures. But if you had to pick one to win, you'd pick curves.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Why argue about which battle to fight, and try to do both? Get widespread support for ECDSA; get RSA implementations up to date with modern padding schemes. We don't need to pick and choose which modern crypto to use; use modern crypto everywhere.
Obviously upgrading old clients is hard, but that's going to be a problem regardless. So in new standards that need RSA (e.g. something where the private key needs to be able to encrypt and sign), push for OEAP. If they don't need RSA, push for modern curves.
Because even if you use OAEP, RSA is more error-prone --- particularly at a design level --- than curve cryptosystems and, for most applications, doesn't allow you to express anything you couldn't express better with curves.
Re:The DROWN Attack
by davidamarquis on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:24PM
(#11204297)
What are the arguments against RSA OAEP?
Public key encryption transforms are one of the biggest foot-guns in cryptography. OAEP is at least not prima facie broken, but using it still exposes you to the the design risks of building with public key encryption.
(There are attacks against OAEP, but they're less common and not intrinsic to the design the way PKCS1v15's are).
Even if RSA does go away, and it will, public-key encryption primitives won't. The post-quantum craze is mostly made up of encryption and signature primitives, so we have that to look forward to. Even the lattice-based key agreement we have is basically fancy KEM, which leads to things like [1].
My impression is that RSA never really got the "djb treatment". The people designing OAEP and friends were mostly theorists concerned with security reductions, not implementation issues. I think an idiot-proof RSA scheme could be devised, but it is now way too late for that.