News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @07:40AM (#1120378)
Not sure what the problem is. I have complete control over the privacy settings of all my accounts. After reading the post, I think the problem is the poster made a choice before this not to use the privacy features.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by dkersten on Friday February 12, 2010 @08:04AM (#1120422)
Google added Buzz to my account automatically and automatically added people form my contact list - some of whom I don't think should have been added - and I had to actively go and search for the privacy/remove/turn off features.

If, on the other hand, Google had said "heres our new Google Buzz feature, heres how to turn it on, heres the privacy settings and heres how you can add everyone|people you talk to regularly|manually add" then I'd be perfectly happy. Opt in is better than opt out, as far as privacy is concerned.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by pavs on Friday February 12, 2010 @08:39AM (#1120481)
>Google added Buzz to my account automatically and automatically added people form my contact list.

To the best of my knowledge they prompt you and ask you who you want to follow. This was the case for me. They don't automatically follow - unless you click the OK button.

Turning off buzz is literally one click away at the bottom of the screen. I know because I used it.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by dkersten on Friday February 12, 2010 @08:43AM (#1120489)
Not for me. They just said "The following people have been added automatically..." At least, I did not manually add anyone and I had a bunch of people added.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by ja27 on Friday February 12, 2010 @10:13AM (#1120711)
The weird part is that of my 6 followers, 2 are people I've never heard of before. One is following 20 and the other 77 and they don't look like spammers, just complete strangers with no reason to have found and followed me.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by praptak on Friday February 12, 2010 @04:41PM (#1121855)
Had the same impression, but searching my mail for their names helped. They were guys like a free software developer whom I had sent feedback about his stuff, people from newsgroups I had exchanged some unimportant e-mails with, etc.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by pavs on Friday February 12, 2010 @08:57AM (#1120523)
I am pretty sure you are mistaken. This is the prompt everyone got when they went to buzz for the first time: http://www.digitaltrends.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/goog...

This is also shown in the Google buzz demo video.

Responsibility lies on you when you decide not to edit the follow users and check privacy setting when its right in front of you the first time. The only way forward is to click OK, thats what you did like everyone else who is complaining and going ra ra about privacy.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by sp332 on Friday February 12, 2010 @09:03AM (#1120540)
Look, people aren't making this stuff up. I'm not sure of the circumstances yet (maybe just the first batch?), but there are a lot of people who were automatically added to Buzz without a prompt.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by pasbesoin on Friday February 12, 2010 @10:21AM (#1120739)
Upon signing in to Gmail, I was directed to some sort of Buzz landing page / prompt. I deliberately chose 'no / continue what I was doing'. (I wasn't aware of any problem, so I didn't make a point of memorizing the presentation.)

Upon proceeding in to Gmail, I found that I was participating in Buzz, with IIRC 14 follows.

My more general reaction to this situation, including a similar, serious security implication for a close family member, I'll comment on elsewhere in this thread.

Briefly: You fucked up bigtime, Google. The people truly responsible for this need to be terminated.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by lutorm on Friday February 12, 2010 @11:08AM (#1120868)
Me too. I just logged into my gmail account (which I don't use) and got a buzz page. I deliberately did not click the huge "Okay" button but instead the tiny "Nah", but then there was still a buzz tab and I had to click the very not obvious link at the bottom to turn it off.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by dkersten on Friday February 12, 2010 @09:22AM (#1120585)
This is the first time I have seen the image in that page. No, I did not get that prompt.

I didn't watch the Google Buzz demo video, because I'm not interested in Buzz. I shouldn't have to watch something I'm not interested in to find out how not to take part in what I'm not interested in. It also took me quite a while to figure out where the turn off button was - since its not in the normal settings, where I would expect to find such things.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by ahi on Friday February 12, 2010 @10:35AM (#1120782)
You didn't actually look at the image you posted did you. It says quite clearly that google autofollowed people. The only button that is there is an "OK". I just clicked on buzz for the first time and I got this: http://imgur.com/ji5lx

There were already messages there. They were almost all about how to turn off buzz.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by pavs on Friday February 12, 2010 @10:44AM (#1120800)
The argument is not so much that you were auto followed (which only happens when you click the buzz tab on gmail) but that you didn't get a chance to do anything about it.

Clearly you have option to edit your followers list and change privacy setting (which was the complain I was referring to). If you choose not to do anything about that and ignore the prompt and go ahead click OK. Should you not take some responsibility for it? I am not denying that google auto following is not in bad form I am just pointing out that changing/editing it is extremely easy and right in front of you.

As for turning off buzz. It is at the bottom of your gmail window. One click away, but not obvious.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by ahi on Friday February 12, 2010 @10:55AM (#1120832)
I don't want to change privacy settings, I just don't want buzz. Where is the "cancel" button? Google should be smart enough to not do opt-out.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by cliveholloway on Friday February 12, 2010 @09:55AM (#1120653)
Nope - I never configured anything and had about 25 followers and was following 25 people - 2/3 of which were just people I had had to email in bursts who I didn't know. Seriously flawed execution here...
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jstraszheim on Friday February 12, 2010 @10:04AM (#1120686)
You're wrong. All sorts of people were following me, and me following them, just by clicking the Buzz link.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by bobbyi on Friday February 12, 2010 @11:41AM (#1120968)
They switched to that when there were complaints. Lucky people like the poster of this blog entry got to be google's guinea pigs so they could figure out that they should have that screen.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by sker on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:13PM (#1121074)
Why is he being down-voted? (-3 at the moment)

Oh right, "we don't like his comment, let's get rid of it." Jesus, people, behave.

He's making his case based on his knowledge of the situation and he's doing so in an educated manner.

Me, personally, I'm in his same situation. I can't understand how people got automatically added to that Buzz thing. The link appeared in my Gmail account and I never clicked it, NEVER. I just turned it off when I learned how.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by bbatsell on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:53PM (#1121183)
Because he's being sanctimonious and judgmental ("Responsibility lies on YOU") while having his facts completely wrong.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by wooster on Friday February 12, 2010 @04:26PM (#1121806)
Because he's saying things which are obviously not true and could be verified as not true with a minimal amount of external research (by, for example, reading the text of the screenshot he posted).
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jeffmould on Friday February 12, 2010 @11:02AM (#1120852)
When I set my one gmail account up it did not prompt me, all my contacts were added. However, I went to look at another account I have and it did not add the contacts from that. Not sure if it is a timing issue, as I set my first account up within 12 hours of them releasing Buzz and waited till yesterday after hearing all the complaints to see what it looked like in my other account and if I maybe missed something the first time. I think they may have either fixed the issue or are working on fixing it.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by moss on Sunday February 14, 2010 @12:02AM (#1124173)
If you clicked that link, you have not actually disabled your public profile.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by sker on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:17PM (#1121087)
I'm not sure what the problem is either. I also have complete control over my privacy settings, but it seems you can't say that in this particular topic because the army of group-thinkers will down-vote you (read: censor your comment) to oblivion.

We can't have two-sided conversations in HN anymore. Either you bash Buzz/Google or get the hell out of this thread.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Saturday February 13, 2010 @09:10AM (#1123019)
Here is where I think the problem lies. First, Google doesn't show your contact list. It doesn't. This was what people were suggesting, and it's not true.

Basically, what is happening is the same thing that happens at twitter by default. People follow other people, and followers, NOT contacts, are shared. People can see who is following you, but they can't see your contacts.

So, when someone joins Buzz, Google suggests they follow certain people, and sets them up. These are people they have in their contacts list. These people in turn have also done the same thing, most likely. Followers, like on Twitter, are shared publicly.

Basically, a lot of people were following people when they really didn't want to be, and despite the ability to prevent it, they accepted the defaults.

Google has made changes to make it more obvious, but from my own experience, and from everything I've read, seen, or done, is that this was all preventable. The problem was, people didn't take the time to read, or understand, what was happening, just happily clicking along.

Of course, that's probably just as dangerous. Should Google have handled it differently? Yes. Did they betray users privacy? Possibly, depending on if you accept that users using software have a certain level of responsibility, or that the software is supposed to assume you don't know what you are doing.

Edit: More information this morning, and I feel vindicated. =)

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by mbrubeck on Saturday February 13, 2010 @10:16AM (#1123071)
I did some of my own experiments with a couple of throwaway accounts, before the privacy improvements on Thursday.

I set up a profile on one account ahead of time. This was very easy to do; Google Reader encourages it at various places.

When I logged into GMail and got the "Buzz" welcome screen, it offered "Try Buzz" and "No thanks." I clicked "No thanks" and it took me to GMail, but the Buzz UI was enabled anyways. When I logged into second account that was a contact of the first, it received a notification that the first account was following the second, with a link to the first account's profile and list of followees/followers.

Now, this part is a bit foreign to many people, but imagine that the fact you email someone is a secret and potentially damaging to you. Maybe you are a whistleblower talking to a government regulator. Someone I know had a stalker added to their Buzz followers along with people she didn't want the stalker to learn about (because stalkers will try to get at their victims through their friends and family). Maybe you don't want certain people aware of your sexual orientation, or your religious or political activities.

At this point, the damage is already done. Before Thursday night, there was no clear notification or way to opt-out of the public followers list until after it had been created and then broadcast to a list of people. By the time you got around to checking out Buzz, realizing that your information had been disclosed, and figuring out how to remove it, it could easily be too late. Note that Google did not "suggest" people to follow and then let users "accept" these defaults. They were added without the user's knowledge or consent.

Worse, if you found the "Turn off Buzz" link in the GMail footer and clicked it before blocking your followers, changing your profile settings, etc., then all your information is still public but hidden from your GMail pages! It's then much harder either to discover the problem or to fix it.

And Google has admitted to some outright bugs that made the situation worse for the "Fuck you Google" blogger. For example, people still appeared in the "Following you" list on Google Reader even after they were blocked and you set your Reader shared items to private; they couldn't actually see your shared items then but it appeared to the user that they could. Also, before Thursday there was no way to block a user who did not have a public profile.

My friends who work at Google are convinced these are real problems[1]. I think you are dismissing them way too quickly.

[1]: http://www.google.com/buzz/mbrubeck/HEN2DyJooNZ/This-looks-l...

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Saturday February 13, 2010 @02:47PM (#1123414)
Couple things here.

First, I stand by what I said: People need to be aware, and made aware, of these things. Privacy is your business, and putting my privacy in the hands of someone else (and I'm not even referring to Google here) means I'm essentially giving up my privacy. Whistleblowers and other people who wished to remain secret should have taken more steps to ensure their privacy (accounts that can't be traced back to themselves).

Secondly, you don't make it clear whether either account said it auto-followed things before you logged in or not. Did it? Did Account 1 follow Account 2 without actually logging in with Buzz enabled, or was it only after logging in it auto-followed? Note: I realize the implications of either way; however, I'm just curious to know which it is for my own knowledge. Again, I'd rather not assume. You also make it seem as if you accepted the default privacy settngs Google set for you.

Next, I realize their were bugs in Reader that "Fuck you Google" made them aware of. Bugs happen. In this case, the bug was just a display bug and from my understanding, didn't actually share anything. In this case, the big problem was merely a display problem. Sure, this is a bug, and a serious one, but not the extent that anyone was suggesting.

Finally, everything I've seen from Google, including the link you sent, suggests that they had these settings in before hand, and that the privacy concerns were more from people that didn't look into the privacy settings before hand and accepted the defaults. The link you posted even described all the issues you described by fixing them merely through making them more visible.

So again, we come to it: The settings were made available. That they weren't flashing and in front of the users with big bold text with sound announcing themselves is a problem, but not to the same extent that "Google was display user's contact lists on their profile page."

However, that all being said, I still think we can learn a lot by this. But looking at it through the eyes of the mob-think that occurred these past few days won't teach us anything, and if anything, only promotes continued ignorance of privacy concerns on the internet.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by lucifer on Friday February 12, 2010 @08:58AM (#1120526)
When you have HN readers complaining about this issue, then we can be fairly certain that the average user of Google's products will have a very difficult time finding their way to the "privacy features" controls, and in effect Google has already made these privacy decisions for them.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @11:50AM (#1120997)
Being an HN reader doesn't make someone immune to being wrong. At some point, the user has to take responsibility. Every complaint I've read that discusses this has mentioned not using Google Profiles to modify privacy settings previously. Either that, or it wasn't mentioned at all.

So, I go back to what I was saying: did anyone using the privacy settings available have their privacy setting explicitly overridden, or was is just people not using the privacy settings available, and then getting run over when they realized what they had allowed opened?

Edit: I get downvoted for asking questions. Apparently, not following the torch-bearers blindly is frowned on.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:06PM (#1121055)
This morning, I've watched two coworkers open their gmail accounts for the first time since Buzz went live. In both cases, they clicked "No thanks, take me to my inbox" instead of the button to "Check out Buzz", and in both cases, Buzz was enabled anyways, and a bunch of people were listed as following/followers. We looked at their profiles, and all the followers/ees were publicly listed.

What, exactly, should they have done to keep this from happening?

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by cabalamat on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:30PM (#1121126)
> In both cases, they clicked "No thanks, take me to my inbox" instead of the button to "Check out Buzz", and in both cases, Buzz was enabled anyways

That's exactly what happened to me. I'm really pissed off with Google now. If they are going to throw this sort of crap at me, I will have to reconsider whether I want gmail and reader accounts.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by weaksauce on Friday February 12, 2010 @01:04PM (#1121209)
Clicking "No thanks" in this instance is not a command to disable buzz it is actually a dismissal of the tutorial page. Buzz will still be enabled either choice you make. There should be an obvious opt out of buzz on the splash screen page.

The way to turn it off is a very small textual link in the footer of the page that says turn off buzz.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by praptak on Friday February 12, 2010 @04:37PM (#1121840)
"The way to turn it off is a very small textual link in the footer of the page that says turn off buzz."

Important quote from http://news.cnet.com/8301-17939_109-10451703-2.html

"But all this does is remove active links, leaving your profile still publicly available, along with any public buzzes you might have made while trying Buzz out. In fact, you're still technically following people, and they're following you. Not OK."

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by algorias on Friday February 12, 2010 @03:10PM (#1121637)
Obfuscated opt-out is pretty much the definition of 'evil'.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by weaksauce on Friday February 12, 2010 @04:29PM (#1121813)
Hanlon's Razor comes to mind : "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity."

I doubt the google programmers are stupid but I would say that they probably were excited by the new feature that they are proud of and didn't think that people would want to opt out of it before even trying it.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by awa on Sunday February 14, 2010 @03:56AM (#1124327)
So when you have those $19.99 offer pages and small textual link in the footer to cancel or say no, you consider that stupidity and not malice
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by CamperBob on Friday February 12, 2010 @05:18PM (#1121958)
Obfuscated opt-out is pretty much the definition of 'evil'.

(since it didn't seem to come through when the other guy posted it)

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by tsally on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:53PM (#1121182)
I can confirm that this just happened to me as well. In fact, if not for this thread I wouldn't have known to go back to check if Buzz was silently enabled.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by edj on Friday February 12, 2010 @01:59PM (#1121391)
Same thing happened to me.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:15PM (#1121078)
They were using their profile privacy settings, and it violated it, or was it more a case of the feature enabling itself in Gmail and using existing privacy settings?

Edit: And because it needs to be said here: I'm not suggesting enabling Buzz and then using existing privacy settings as a bases for how Buzz works is right. I'm just asking a question.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:28PM (#1121122)
This was their first interaction with Buzz. There was no opportunity to set any privacy settings.

They are both Reader users, and did have limited sharing enabled there, but under what logic should those permissions ever extend to a completely new, different service with wholly different privacy concerns?

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @04:35PM (#1121829)
"Inferring privacy preferences for new software, based on prior actions in old software, is a recipe for failure."

From this thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1121034

Anyways, here is my take. Buzz isn't a new product so much as it's a new feature of Gmail. It's as much a new product as any new feature of Gmail is. It's also tied into most of the areas Gmail is, and tied into the rest of Google, and uses Google Profiles.

Google made the assumption that because this wasn't so much a complete new product, but rather an extension to an existing one, that it should use existing permissions. And looking at it that way, I can easily see them doing what they did.

What they didn't suspect, or expect I'm sure, is that people would see it not as a Gmail feature, but rather as a completely different system unrelated to Gmail and rather, tacked onto it.

I can see how Google looks at Buzz as merely an extension to Gmail. Gmail is, after all, their communications tool, including email, chat, and eventually (we know this is coming), Wave. Buzz is merely another way to communicate, and because so much of Gmail already includes so many other connections, Buzz being a framework to share things that Email, Chat, and what not are effective at, they built it with a familiar way of doing things. They then assumed (and I'm assuming all of this, mind you) that because they were building on top of an existing structure, that much of the privacy concerns that have arisen were already in use by the people that were concerned with it.

So, the question is, not whether Google was right or wrong, but rather, where do we draw the line? When does a new feature become a new product that requires new permissions, and when is a feature merely a feature that can use existing permissions. After all, there is so much that they do add where we don't blink an eye or concern ourselves with permissions or privacy, despite the potential for problems down the line.

I understand what they did, and why they did it (if my assertions are correct). However, there is more to learn here than to just say "Make everything private." The reality is, most users make assumptions about privacy (this is excellent proof of that), and so do companies. I honestly don't think Google went with Buzz and said "Let's destroy users privacy." I also hope this heightens people's awareness to the state or privacy on the web.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Friday February 12, 2010 @05:30PM (#1121981)
Any new feature, product, whatever that exposes private information should be opt-in. Period.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @06:47PM (#1122174)
But what if the information wasn't private before, merely public, but not in the same context? This is what I think happened with Buzz. Nothing new was made public. It's just the public things weren't really public before.

This is the question: if up until now, you had an option that set things to 'public', but they weren't really public, should a new feature unset your previous choices? Should a new feature change your privacy settings?

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Friday February 12, 2010 @09:01PM (#1122375)
What are you talking about? Buzz exposes your up-till-now private email contacts by listing them on your public profile page, unless you take the time and effort to understand that it's doing so and follow the convoluted opt-out process. That's why everyone's upset.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @10:51PM (#1122502)
Where does my contact list appear on my profile page? I can't find it. I can find my followers, but they aren't the same as my contacts.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Saturday February 13, 2010 @09:59AM (#1123061)
By default, your followers were auto-populated from your contact list, potentially revealing who you most email.