News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:06PM (#1121055)
This morning, I've watched two coworkers open their gmail accounts for the first time since Buzz went live. In both cases, they clicked "No thanks, take me to my inbox" instead of the button to "Check out Buzz", and in both cases, Buzz was enabled anyways, and a bunch of people were listed as following/followers. We looked at their profiles, and all the followers/ees were publicly listed.

What, exactly, should they have done to keep this from happening?

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by cabalamat on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:30PM (#1121126)
> In both cases, they clicked "No thanks, take me to my inbox" instead of the button to "Check out Buzz", and in both cases, Buzz was enabled anyways

That's exactly what happened to me. I'm really pissed off with Google now. If they are going to throw this sort of crap at me, I will have to reconsider whether I want gmail and reader accounts.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by weaksauce on Friday February 12, 2010 @01:04PM (#1121209)
Clicking "No thanks" in this instance is not a command to disable buzz it is actually a dismissal of the tutorial page. Buzz will still be enabled either choice you make. There should be an obvious opt out of buzz on the splash screen page.

The way to turn it off is a very small textual link in the footer of the page that says turn off buzz.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by praptak on Friday February 12, 2010 @04:37PM (#1121840)
"The way to turn it off is a very small textual link in the footer of the page that says turn off buzz."

Important quote from http://news.cnet.com/8301-17939_109-10451703-2.html

"But all this does is remove active links, leaving your profile still publicly available, along with any public buzzes you might have made while trying Buzz out. In fact, you're still technically following people, and they're following you. Not OK."

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by algorias on Friday February 12, 2010 @03:10PM (#1121637)
Obfuscated opt-out is pretty much the definition of 'evil'.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by weaksauce on Friday February 12, 2010 @04:29PM (#1121813)
Hanlon's Razor comes to mind : "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity."

I doubt the google programmers are stupid but I would say that they probably were excited by the new feature that they are proud of and didn't think that people would want to opt out of it before even trying it.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by awa on Sunday February 14, 2010 @03:56AM (#1124327)
So when you have those $19.99 offer pages and small textual link in the footer to cancel or say no, you consider that stupidity and not malice
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by CamperBob on Friday February 12, 2010 @05:18PM (#1121958)
Obfuscated opt-out is pretty much the definition of 'evil'.

(since it didn't seem to come through when the other guy posted it)

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by tsally on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:53PM (#1121182)
I can confirm that this just happened to me as well. In fact, if not for this thread I wouldn't have known to go back to check if Buzz was silently enabled.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by edj on Friday February 12, 2010 @01:59PM (#1121391)
Same thing happened to me.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:15PM (#1121078)
They were using their profile privacy settings, and it violated it, or was it more a case of the feature enabling itself in Gmail and using existing privacy settings?

Edit: And because it needs to be said here: I'm not suggesting enabling Buzz and then using existing privacy settings as a bases for how Buzz works is right. I'm just asking a question.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Friday February 12, 2010 @12:28PM (#1121122)
This was their first interaction with Buzz. There was no opportunity to set any privacy settings.

They are both Reader users, and did have limited sharing enabled there, but under what logic should those permissions ever extend to a completely new, different service with wholly different privacy concerns?

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @04:35PM (#1121829)
"Inferring privacy preferences for new software, based on prior actions in old software, is a recipe for failure."

From this thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1121034

Anyways, here is my take. Buzz isn't a new product so much as it's a new feature of Gmail. It's as much a new product as any new feature of Gmail is. It's also tied into most of the areas Gmail is, and tied into the rest of Google, and uses Google Profiles.

Google made the assumption that because this wasn't so much a complete new product, but rather an extension to an existing one, that it should use existing permissions. And looking at it that way, I can easily see them doing what they did.

What they didn't suspect, or expect I'm sure, is that people would see it not as a Gmail feature, but rather as a completely different system unrelated to Gmail and rather, tacked onto it.

I can see how Google looks at Buzz as merely an extension to Gmail. Gmail is, after all, their communications tool, including email, chat, and eventually (we know this is coming), Wave. Buzz is merely another way to communicate, and because so much of Gmail already includes so many other connections, Buzz being a framework to share things that Email, Chat, and what not are effective at, they built it with a familiar way of doing things. They then assumed (and I'm assuming all of this, mind you) that because they were building on top of an existing structure, that much of the privacy concerns that have arisen were already in use by the people that were concerned with it.

So, the question is, not whether Google was right or wrong, but rather, where do we draw the line? When does a new feature become a new product that requires new permissions, and when is a feature merely a feature that can use existing permissions. After all, there is so much that they do add where we don't blink an eye or concern ourselves with permissions or privacy, despite the potential for problems down the line.

I understand what they did, and why they did it (if my assertions are correct). However, there is more to learn here than to just say "Make everything private." The reality is, most users make assumptions about privacy (this is excellent proof of that), and so do companies. I honestly don't think Google went with Buzz and said "Let's destroy users privacy." I also hope this heightens people's awareness to the state or privacy on the web.

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Friday February 12, 2010 @05:30PM (#1121981)
Any new feature, product, whatever that exposes private information should be opt-in. Period.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @06:47PM (#1122174)
But what if the information wasn't private before, merely public, but not in the same context? This is what I think happened with Buzz. Nothing new was made public. It's just the public things weren't really public before.

This is the question: if up until now, you had an option that set things to 'public', but they weren't really public, should a new feature unset your previous choices? Should a new feature change your privacy settings?

Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Friday February 12, 2010 @09:01PM (#1122375)
What are you talking about? Buzz exposes your up-till-now private email contacts by listing them on your public profile page, unless you take the time and effort to understand that it's doing so and follow the convoluted opt-out process. That's why everyone's upset.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jasonlotito on Friday February 12, 2010 @10:51PM (#1122502)
Where does my contact list appear on my profile page? I can't find it. I can find my followers, but they aren't the same as my contacts.
Re:Automatically followed by abusive ex-husband (and his fri... by jfager on Saturday February 13, 2010 @09:59AM (#1123061)
By default, your followers were auto-populated from your contact list, potentially revealing who you most email.