> You need a lot of western ideals to make this actually work: free speech, open markets, powerful banking, strong monetary policies, anti-isolationism, free trade, employee protections, anti-corruption, capital protection, strong pro immigration policies, multi-party government, non-corrupt judiciary, etc.
That is an interesting point, I wonder how all the points you have listed are intertwined.
Do you need free speech because it is a prerequisite to have a low level of corruption ? Or could you in some systems have the low corruption without the free speech ? (I don't really believe that but it seems that is what is the PRC is trying to achieve) What would be the more and less important factor if you had to "implement" one first ? And so on.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix
by EliRivers on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:45AM
(#11203894)
As a single data-point, Singapore managed low corruption without free speech (and indeed, economic development without much attendant political freedom).
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix
by jernfrost on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:07PM
(#11204136)
I think a problem with Singapore style solutions is that it is so dependent on having one very wise leader. Democracy is more robust I think in that it can weather even bad leaders. Bad decisions will happen sooner or later. The problem is that a country like Singapore or China has no good way of dealing with that.
Especially with China over a billion people are all dependent on the decision made by one single very centralized government.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix
by neuromancer2701 on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:57AM
(#11204038)
Friedman argued you could use free markets as kind of a trojan. Once they get implemented even in an authoritarian regimes it is easier to transition to an overall free society. Chile is generally seen as having made that transition from Pinochet to full republic by 1990.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix
by Mikeb85 on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @03:35PM
(#11205820)
It's not so much a trojan, but as a way to transition to a free society gradually without the chaos caused by a collapse of the authoritarian system.
I'm not sure all of them are required - to me the minimum package is multi-party government + non-corrupt judiciary + free speech + relative ease of starting a business or NGO legally. Some sort of employee protection or at least representation helps a lot with stability.
A lot of people would say that employee protection conflicts with free trade and free movement of people.
This is why Russia stuggles now. It ignored almost all of the above and has been held up solely by its state-owned petrochemical industry and petrochemical derived reserves. I think there's a reckoning coming for the autocratic BRIC states soon. Either they'll liberalize and migrate to a US/EU model or become economic sob stories. Russia is looking at 1% contraction this year and its oil slump has moved into a real estate slump. China has a chance to fight this I suppose, but I doubt it has the political will to move away from autocracy and political oppression.
The next decade will be interesting for BRIC economies. The low hanging economic fruit in many of these countries has already been snatched up. What happens now is the big question.