News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by LukeB_UK on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @08:55AM (#11202554)
From their own post:

> SongFlip has been banned from Google Play several times in the past for Intellectual Property infringement. After his developer account is banned, the developer keeps on creating new developer accounts to reupload this app. Below is a list of past package names this app has been uploaded under, which have since been banned:

com.seven.songflip

com.fungames.songflip

com.unicornlabs.firetunes

So really Google isn't allowing it, this person just keeps on signing up.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by luso_brazilian on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:39AM (#11202801)
The "mysteriously" qualifier seems to be sarcasm by the part of the original submitter on reddit. He seems to be implying that, by being a former Google employee, this person is getting a pass or using inside information to skirt around the system.

Quoting from the post:

> Here is proof SongFlip was released by someone who used to work for Google:

> His Linkedin and Google+ Profiles list prior employment by Google: https://www.linkedin.com/in/robertdo and https://plus.google.com/+RobertDo/about

> He mentions he created SongFlip here: http://www.meetup.com/The-Brooklyn-iPhone-and-iPad-Developer...

> His Twitter shows extensive SongFlip testing: https://twitter.com/robertdo

> His company "Hype Reactor, Inc.": http://www.bizapedia.com/ca/HYPE-REACTOR-INC.html

> The "Hype Reactor, Inc." developer account shows SongFlip was uploaded to it before being removed: https://www.appannie.com/apps/ios/publisher/hype-reactor-inc...

The conclusion of his post seems to be in line with that:

> My question is why is Google allowing SongFlip to break so many rules? Could it be the case that the SongFlip creator, who is a former Google employee, is using contacts within Google to prevent it from being taken down despite so many violations? We can only speculate...

> By mysteriously allowing it to continue breaking rules and violate intellectual property and ignoring all reports against the app, Google has allowed it to quickly become the #16 Overall app in the USA, which means it is making over $30,000 per day in ad revenue and is as popular as Spotify (#14 Overall app).

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by rtkwe on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:27AM (#11203173)
I think that anyone could probably do the same things that SongFlip is doing. The dev is just slipping through unnoticed because Google isn't particularly vigilant about making sure bans stick because it'd be an annoying overhead and would block some people from getting to upload that might make great apps.

As for the ToS violation clause I think that's there for when they receive complaint from the 3rd party, they don't want to go through every app and figure out all the 3rd party application it's using and how then go to each of those sites and parse their ToS. Does Apple even do that in their review process? That'd be a hell of a lot of work.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by DannyBee on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:31AM (#11203772)
"The "mysteriously" qualifier seems to be sarcasm by the part of the original submitter on reddit. He seems to be implying that, by being a former Google employee, this person is getting a pass or using inside information to skirt around the system. "

Considering Robert was a product marketing manager, and thus, would not have had access to much, it's a pretty silly guess.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by st3v3r on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:30PM (#11204346)
He'd have access to people. He might know some of the people who's heads would need to look the other way for this to happen.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by DannyBee on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @12:18PM (#11211323)
???? Not really, they aren't even in the same org and are in buildings far far away from each other .... It's unlikely he would have ever met them
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by rwmj on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @08:59AM (#11202581)
There is surely a way to determine if one app is substantially similar to a previously banned app, eg. by fuzzy comparing the binary, or running it and comparing screenshots.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by robhu on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:05AM (#11202611)
Or suing developers who intentionally violate the ToS in a repeated manner like this. Make it financially far more costly to screw Google and the users over than it is currently profitable.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by mc808 on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:09AM (#11202635)
It sounds like the people being screwed are SoundCloud and possibly some of the musicians who use it, not Google or the millions of users downloading the app. So if someone should sue, it should probably be them.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by frogpelt on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:04PM (#11204104)
If the Play Store gets the reputation for being the wild, wild west it's bad for Google's developers and thus their business.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by sdca on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:37PM (#11204409)
Yes. OP is literally "soundcloud_musician" on Reddit complaining about copyright infringement that's not taking place.

However forced ranking, deep linking, and previous ban evasion are all real concerns for Google's reputation as a corporate friendly gatekeeper.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by chiph on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:02AM (#11202603)
If you do that, you'll wipe out hundreds if not thousands of "Candy Crush" and "Bejeweled" clones.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by bsharitt on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:06AM (#11202622)
This plan keeps getting better.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by toyg on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:07AM (#11202628)
And that would be bad because...?
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by Klathmon on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:14AM (#11202661)
Just because you don't like an app doesn't mean it doesn't or can't provide value and deserves to be removed.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:09PM (#11204153)
What if an app provides negative value? Right now every successful app has a few dozen knockoffs that are deliberately confusingly similar, and functionally identical or inferior; it makes discovery considerably more difficult, especially if you're looking for something that isn't a hit or a ripoff of a hit.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by Klathmon on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:27PM (#11204327)
I'm pretty sure nobody is advocating for warez or exact copy apps, but you need to be careful drawing that line.

Just because to you it's "just another bejeweled clone" doesn't make it so. A layperson would probably think that HN is "just another reddit", and that's not any more valid.

Luckily (or unluckily depending on which side you are on) we already have laws that define this for us. Trademark, copyright, and patents. For better or for worse, that's legally what we have to work with.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by chiph on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:52AM (#11202901)
Not bad, as such. I'm all for someone writing an app that adds value/entertainment and makes them some money. But at the same time.. how many do we really need?
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by piker on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:03AM (#11202979)
As many as a fully-informed, rational-acting market will bear.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by emodendroket on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:31AM (#11203205)
So, something other than the Google Play store, you mean?
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by st3v3r on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:32PM (#11204368)
So we'll never know, because such a thing has never existed.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by KirinDave on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:43AM (#11202827)
Or just matching the title. Because that seems to be pretty constant.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by robhu on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @08:57AM (#11202563)
Does Google not have an app approval process when a developer wants to submit an app to the store? Surely the resubmission of a banned app would be detected at that step?
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by FussyZeus on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:12AM (#11202653)
Android dev here: There is virtually no submission review. As long as the bundle ID is correct I could upload pretty much whatever I wanted, the only things they check for are matching bundle ID's, correct version numbers, basically anything that could damage the Play store in some technical fashion. Everything else is up for the users to report, which is why the Play store is FLUSH with garbage apps.

Windows Phone doesn't seem a ton better, the only ones that have any handle on crapware are Apple, and even then it isn't as good as it used to be.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by bitmapbrother on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:40AM (#11203296)
iPhone user here. You must not have an iPhone or iPad. The App Store is littered with crapware.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by fixermark on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:07AM (#11203547)
It's a control / scale issue. Apple clamps harder on apps that infringe on its rules (it appears they have humans in the loop doing some active checking, if "My app got banned for ridiculous reasons" stories that hit HN periodically are to be believed). But Apple's developer base is so much larger that the amount of work needed to control against crap is proportionately higher.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by hyperpape on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:24AM (#11203711)
It's true that there is crapware in the iOS app store, but this app would face at least some pain there. Since there's app review, you couldn't have the app taken down then just upload it again without waiting through the long process of app review.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by FussyZeus on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:29AM (#11203761)
I have both. I'm not saying it's the Eden of apps (Like I said, especially recently the App Review seems very lax) but the ratio of crap to useful apps is much better in the App Store in my experience.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by ropiku on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:43AM (#11203869)
But it's clearly not banned quick enough if he can get to #16 and have >1M downloads. I can't believe that happened in a few days. Every reupload would start from 0 users.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by Symbiote on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:07AM (#11202630)
Matching using the developer's bank details, name and/or address shouldn't be too difficult.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by chinathrow on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:19AM (#11202681)
Setting up new bank details, fake names and/or addresses isn't difficult either.

Some people cheat wherever and whenever they can.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by robhu on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:26PM (#11204318)
Google could hold the money for X days (30? 60?) and ensure they respond to complaints within that time so if a new app appears and people complain it can be taken down and the money not sent on. That would prevent the ToS breaking developers from profiting.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:52AM (#11202900)
Which countries, that Google allows bank deposits to, don't bother checking your identity when opening a bank account?
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by evan_ on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:00AM (#11202950)
Probably none but what banks share your address with whoever asks? You can open a new checking account with your bank online and get a new P.O. box and as far as Google is concerned you are a different person/company.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by jsjohnst on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:01AM (#11202959)
There isn't a way for a normal company to verify the name who registered a bank account. They can verify your claim to have access to it, but not the actual name on the account.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by spyder on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:29AM (#11203189)
The bank account can be on the name of a business and they can just keep creating new companies.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by Someone1234 on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:17AM (#11203092)
Setting up a bank account under an assumed name is pretty blatantly illegal in most countries.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by xkcd-sucks on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:11PM (#11204169)
Very few companies match sensitive info like cc numbers, account numbers etc.

My guess is that it would allow an attacker to get account numbers belonging to existing customers??

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by st3v3r on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:27PM (#11204324)
But why can't Google tell it's the same damn app that they've banned?
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by amyjess on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:45AM (#11203901)
Google could still take legal action against them.

Repeatedly signing up for new accounts after being banned is trespassing on private property, and I'm fairly sure Google could sue for TOS violations if they wanted.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by wahsd on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:34AM (#11202764)
And here one of the many huge flaws of Google's lazy approach to gate-keeping it's app ecosystem is exposed.

Hell, who WOULDN'T do that for $30,000 daily ad income.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by _nedR on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @09:50AM (#11202882)
Both as a user and a developer, I would prefer a lenient, lazy approach over an over-zealous over-pedantic approach.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by wahsd on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:43AM (#11203875)
I find that statement weirdly irreconcilable. Can you really be a naive user and a developer worth his mettle? I get your point, but there is a huge chasm between what users think is good for them and the actual capacity they have to not harm themselves.

I get that you as a "power user" are probably not interested in the restrictions and rules that the Apple ecosystem "imposes", but there is a humongous gap between you who is probably very competent and skilled at protecting yourself from all the numerous and plentiful risks that the Android system exposes you to; and the other end of the spectrum, the 99.99% of users who couldn't protect themselves even if they wanted to and wantonly download and install and follow prompts (if they read them at all) to expose themselves.

I find it rather ironic and rather reckless really from the developer perspective too that you seem to totally eschew all the risk considerations that Apple takes into account, just ignoring the business decisions they make. It is unarguable that the Apple ecosystem is not astronomically more secure and safe and a better user experience than Android for 99.999% of users.

You may be upset that you don't have access to low level device or OS features, but ultimately those are also largely security restrictions and in no way there to annoy you. What you should ask yourself is why the devs like you seem to be wholly unappreciative that Apple doesn't leave massive, humongous, gargantuan security and privacy vulnerabilities just gaping wide open all over their OS and devices. It's rather telling that people with your kind of mentality have no understanding for practical considerations and justifiable limitations and boundaries.

Sure, I'm not a huge fan about all of Apple's decisions, but conversely, your type of mentality is the equivalent of saying that there should be no guards in prisons and bank vaults should be open to the outside 24/7 where everyone can take out money on the honor system.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by _nedR on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:50PM (#11205032)
To address some of your arguments (the others are quite orthogonal to my original point) :-

>I find it rather ironic and rather reckless really from the developer perspective too that you seem to totally eschew all the risk considerations that Apple takes into account, just ignoring the business decisions they make.

I am not advocating for the abandonment of all security in favour of freedom. And I think there a better balance of security, convinience and freedom is possible than that currently provided by Apple. Still there is a certain trade-off involved between freedom and security. We have to compromise on one to gain the other. Given the choice, I would rather sacrifice a bit of security for greater freedom than vice-versa. (which is ultimately why i chose the android ecosystem over Apple's)

>It is unarguable that the Apple ecosystem is not astronomically more secure and safe and a better user experience than Android for 99.999% of users.

I will agree that from a security and privacy perspective iOS is miles ahead of Android. But i can argue that the iOS doesn't provide a better user experience for 99.99% of users. I will give just one example from my country India (there are many more). Here we are undergoing a explosive growth of smartphone usage driven by low-cost android devices. A lot of this growth is driven by poorer users from rural areas. The thing is even if they could afford Apple devices, they would get a sub-par experience to that provided by Android. Why? Because they often lack the necessary literacy, connectivity or bankability needed to utilize the Apple ecosystem (Or even the Play store for that matter). Instead they use apps like Xender and bluetooth to share music, apps, videos, etc. It is an entirely decentralised, p2p, shadow ecosystem operating in parallel to the playstore-ecosystem. Sure, it is rife with piracy (one of the main considerations behind Apple's locked-down model) and is riddled with insecurity. But i would argue that benefits far outweigh the risks. And isn't bringing the benefits of technology to the poor, one of the professed goals of Silicon Valley?

Which brings me back to my original point- Android's lenient security model allows for new and novel uses of technology that wouldn't have otherwise been possible.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by rogersmith on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:01PM (#11204068)
OT but arguably, the world could possibly be a better place if we didn't have prisons or banks at all.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by st3v3r on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:36PM (#11204402)
So we'd all have to keep our money under our mattress, and the punishment for any crime would be death?
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by oneeyedpigeon on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:52AM (#11203419)
Have you done it?

Which would you prefer, a locked-down walled-in garden, ensuring you can only run a certain piece of software if company x tells you you can; or a more open marketplace that everyone can take part in, that occasionally has bad apples?

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by waspleg on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @10:59AM (#11203484)
Neither. I prefer a completely open non-marketplace aka PC minus Windows 10. Phones in their current iteration are the death of device freedom. Sure there are work arounds for some things but they're band-aids on bullet wounds.
Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by fixermark on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:09AM (#11203567)
It's a death of device freedom that is on-track to have over 2 billion adopters this year.

Sounds a lot like "device freedom" isn't a feature people actually want.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by waspleg on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:36PM (#11204397)
Only because they don't know what it is, nor largely that it exists, nor what it means for them to not have it.

Most of the big tech companies prey on ignorant users these days in the most insidious and pernicious ways for their profits - to a far greater extent than the seemingly innocent things like making a quick buck because someone doesn't know how to snap in a DIMM.

EDIT: Nor any viable alternative in the same form factor.

Re:Why is Google allowing this popular app to violate so man... by st3v3r on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:37PM (#11204406)
No. The existence of marketplaces have absolutely nothing to do with device freedom.