This seems remarkably unsupported. I don't think of Europe as being very innovative, despite their impressive social safety net. And I think of Asia as being very innovative and entrepreneurial, despite their lack of much of a safety net. Hmmm...
The reality of a great safety net is that someone has to pay for it. Who is that?
I'm a bit of a die-hard let-the-bozos-starve sort of wack-job libertarian. So, what's a bigger infringement of rights? Take hundreds of billions of dollars from US citizens, and spend it enforcing arbitrary rules on a populace that doesn't have representation or a vote? Or take billions from US citizens and spend it patching up said citizens when they fall down or get sick?
I hate taxes. Really, I do, as much as anyone you'll ever meet. And I hope that the market could someday solve this problem more efficiently. But I also think that killing people is a lot more evil than healing people. I voted for Ron Paul largely because he was the only candidate who said outright that he would shut down all unwanted military bases in his first year.
Dismantle the military empire, and you've got money for medical care. Additionally, adding a base level of safety net could be a disruptive force that allows smaller and more agile companies (ie, in the 1-10 employee range) to get more done with less overhead, which is exactly the sort of thing that needs to happen if stuff like this is going to be solved cleverly.
Come on, we're hackers, right? Think about it. This is a complex problem with a ton of moving parts, and that's kind of what we do, isn't it? So, apply the same maxims that serve you so well in dealing with software:
Measure before you optimize. Solve the big problems first. Patch the in-production product, and THEN design its replacement. The perfect is the enemy of the good.
A bit of a false dichotomy, don't you think? I agree with most of the rest of your post, though I think that the primary effect of increasing the safety net will be moral hazard issues, not people jumping to do a startup now that they have a safety net. People who do startups are incredibly rare, and somehow I doubt that's because of any safety net issues.
You've also got, unfortunately, a ton of people that go out of work. Noone will get rid of military programs if it shuts down jobs in their district.
Medicare and Medicaid appear to be similar to the systems that most other countries (e.g. Britain, Canada) have in place to pay for healthcare (except that in most other countries everyone is covered). How do you explain that, in those other countries, the per-capita costs of healthcare are lower than in the US?
I don't recall exactly how Britain and Canada do it, but I'm pretty sure it's not the same way. Here's how it works:
The RBRVS Fee Schedule.[6]Medicare uses the resource-based relative value scale (RBRVS) to pay for physician services. Under this formula, Medicare officials compute the “objective value” of an estimated 7,000 procedures.[7] Each component of a medical service is assigned a weighted value that is calculated by using social science measurements of the time, energy, and effort required to perform a given procedure, including resource inputs such as medical equipment, malpractice insurance, and administrative costs. These weighted “values” are then converted into dollar amounts and used to determine the fees that Medicare pays to physicians for those services.[8] The diagnosis related group (DRG) system reimburses hospitals using a similar strategy.[9]
Most other countries are poorer than the US; the US has a GDP per capita 50% higher than the EU and (for example) 40% higher than France. Since a medical procedure takes the same amount of time in either place, the cost will be proportional to wages.
Additionally, the US is far more unequal than most other countries. At the top of the skill chain, the gap increases significantly [1]. The US costs more simply because doctor's salaries need to be competitive with banker and programmer salaries.
[1] I know a few FOB Indians who had multiple jobs/offers, they say the US can often pay double what the EU does.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_system_in_Japan
So does Korea:
http://www.slideshare.net/manhattanresearch/south-koreas-hea...
And so does Taiwan:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Taiwan
Any other innovative Asian economies you'd like to compare?
Unless you have some kind of condition, is there any situation in which the fear of not having health insurance is actually justifiable? I mean, if you want to avoid paying off a huge hospital bill over time, then ok... but come on, if you're starting a startup, gambling a 0.001% chance (or whatever) that you might have to pay 4-5k off over a few years seems like an insanely good bet.
Also, I heard from a friend (who is very probably wrong about this) that you don't actually have to pay off a hospital bill. It won't count against your credit score. Is this true? I would never do something like that, but... if not paying the bill doesn't count against your credit score, then I can see why people might not pay it.
Two years later, we were doing about 2 million a year. Still, I poured every penny I had into the company "creating" additional good-paying jobs. Then I had a stroke. Yes, at 27. Because the doctors could not find a "reason" for my stroke, the insurance company paid a grand total of $2700, mostly for the ambulance and the care I received in said ambulance.
I was left with a bill of $67,000. Yes 3 zeros. Because of how long I was in the hospital and recovering, and because my business was based on relationships with my clients, the business faltered, and I eventually shut it down. I am now paying off every cent of what I owed on the business, as well as that $67k in medical bills.
Moral of the story: don't think you're invincible because you're young, or because you don't have a pre-existing condition. Also, I can absolutely assure you that medical debt DOES affect your credit.
Here's the crazy part. I'd do it all again in a heartbeat, and I will.
Having treatment refused to my children because they are not insured (or not insured enough) is quite frankly terrifying. The system standing between me and medical machines and professionals is damn near random and I find it terrifying. Enough that I've had serious pause when striking out on my own.
Not everyone who starts startups (or other business) is 23 and single.
Your friend is wrong. Google "medical bankruptcy".
Total bill? $1553.
This is a very significant sum for people with regular, consistent income. For someone subsisting on ramen to launch their next great idea, this is crippling.
Also, I highly doubt the credit score thing is true.
Apparently, a lot of people do... otherwise the nation wouldn't spend such a large percentage of the GDP on medical care.
Be thankful you're not old, yet.
If you want to see public ridicule in action, take a gander at 4chan.
I really wish downvoting was capped at 0. That way, comments still get filtered to the bottom, but people who get downvoted (and spent ~20 minutes writing the comment) don't feel like they just wasted their time for no reason at all. Seeing my (interesting, if inflammatory) comment at -4 when a ridiculing reply was at 5 just set me off.
"I joined 2 days after HN was first opened publicly, and was in the top 10 for a few months a while ago (a year or so), to give you an idea of how times have changed on HN."
Looks like I joined the same day you did, and I think I was also in the top 10 for a while. I don't think us not being in the top 10 any more is evidence of "times changing" on HN (other than the fact that the community has grown a lot and so it's progressively harder to stay in the top-N).
As far as you thinking I'm "dangerously wrong", well, I'm still living and breathing, aren't I? Plenty of people live without health insurance, with no problems. Statistically I'm making a safe gamble, even if I'm "gambling with an unlimited downside" or whatever.
If you're going to say someone is wrong on HN, you better back up your position with facts.
I think we're drifting pretty far away from a HN-worthy topic here, but I just wanted to say (not ridiculing you at all by the way - I was very reckless in my early 20s), you should really stash this comment away somewhere you'll be able to find and reread it in say 10 years. If you're lucky, you'll just smile and cringe a little when you read it.
One last try though, I guess ;) From my perspective, you're arguing "I'll be lucky", and I'm just saying "you might not be". That's it.
That's my point. Posting comments just because you feel that you're right doesn't help anyone. It makes the person you're talking to feel annoyed, and doesn't change their point of view. And if your opinion happens to be the popular opinion, then that will incite a mob downvote of their (possibly insightful or interesting but unpopular) comment, and a mob upvote of your useless "I'm right because I'm right" comment. It's demoralizing to spend a lot of time crafting a comment, only to have it mass-downvoted just because it's unpopular, and to have some thoughtless reply massively upvoted just because it's popular.
I mean, you see where I'm coming from, right?
It's this kind of train of thought that's destroying HN. The thought that it's okay to not put in effort into commenting. The conversation on HN is where the magic is at -- if the conversation goes to hell, then HN is doomed.
And thank you for trying to communicate your position, even if it was just a single sentence. As far as my response, well... I really don't see a significant chance of me getting hurt. I'm basically paranoid when I drive, and a car accident is pretty much the only thing that could seriously injure me. Health insurance is $300/mo that I just don't need to spend.
I got in a car accident in 2000, other driver at fault. Their insurance company agreed to pay the medical bill. I didn't realize until 3 years later, when the collection agency tracked me down, that they never did. That crap finally fell off just a few years ago, but cost me who knows how much in added interest rates over the years.
Not having health insurance is pretty stupid, even if you're healthy, young, broke, and in college. If you're starting a company, it's just completely irresponsible.