Couldn't you ? I have no idea if this is workable in Fairhope, specifically, but ... if this is the main feature of a land tax regime, it seems like you could fairly easily game this ...
You gain control of the land (either through purchase or 99 year lease or whatever) and then you create an option to buy (or option to assign lessee) that is transferable to a third party and then you can camp on that appreciating "asset" just like people now do with the land itself.
I'm sorry if it's a bit imprecise or hand-wavy, but you get the idea - you only need to create a derivative of the property (which should be trivially easy) in order to work around the inability to sit on appreciating land.
Am I mistaken ? Am I missing something ?
So, a single unelected and unaccountable entity managing a centrally-planned economy? This is the utopian vision?
As for central management of core elements of an economic system, look up the role of the Texas Railroad Commission (hint: it didn't regulate railroads) and prepare to have your mind blown.
As long as people are interested in eating, drinking, partying, culture, socializing and having casual sex - cities as most desirable places to live are inevitable.
The gentrification could be viewed as a very subtle form of segregation - that you could just price out people you don't want to mix with from the places you deem desirable.
Eating, drinking, partying and casual sex are just that - culture. Culture is subject to change.
And this isn't what drives urbanization. More simple optimization with regards to commute time and employment opportunities dominate this preference, except maybe in very select areas with high density of youth with enough money to have post-materialistic consumption behaviours.
Diversity and plentifulness of nutrition, social/sexual opportunity, and economic opportunity are strong attractions of cities rooted in our core biological needs.
That more general form combines the ideas that the two of you present (I think efficiency is significantly enough intertwined with economic opportunity that it makes sense to treat them as a single factor). Different people may emphasize differing core attractions as reason for wanting to be in a city, but I think all of these factors are core to what attracts significantly large groups of people to cities, and I think you lose a large part of the attractions of cities by leaving out any of these factors.
edit: oops, originally cited the wrong commentor, also fixed a typo
> all of these factors are core to what attracts significantly large groups of people to cities
And these things can change. Or more precisely, technological or social shifts may change these preferences drastically, which is why real estate and land ownership in general has a black-swan style long-tail risk, which is seldom mentioned.
Primary draws of the city may become weaker with better technology. And we might find [more striking and concrete evidence for] significant drawbacks, especially in term of health effects.
As Cutler's article goes on to explore, George may have been on to a good point, but fettishising land over productive foundations may be an error. I found Cutler's mention of Carlota Perez to be of interest, I'm reading the cited book currently.
As for Fairhope:
1. How land values vary relative to comparable areas with different taxation bases.
2. Overal equity / equality. Comparing economic mobility for those of differing parental family wealth, for example.
3. Overall economic activity. Does Fairhope do better or worse than comparable regions.
I've got a hankering suspicion that differences may be too small to measure / matter.
The article ends with the comment that the automobile broke the land ownership monopoly by creating suburbia. It took about fifty years to fill out surburbia, but that's been done.
Henry George's single tax plan has been implemented in two cities in the US. One is Fairhope, AL.[1] The Fairhope Single Tax Corporation owns most of the land in the town, including the downtown area, and rents it out on 99 year leases. The ground rent cover all property taxes, plus some public facilities the Single Tax Corporation runs. The corporation sets the rent based, as Henry George wanted, on the most productive use of the land. This encourages development. This just covers the land; you can build, and own the building, but must keep up the rent payments on the land to continue owning the building.
What you can't do in Fairhope is buy land and wait for it to become more valuable. You cannot get a capital gain out of owning land there. So no one can become rich by owning land.
[1] http://www.fairhopesingletax.com/