News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by jacobolus on Thursday February 25, 2016 @06:24PM (#11178675)
If you aren’t affiliated with a university, scientific papers cost something like $30/each to read.

If papers can be accessed for free, then the only expense required to follow cutting edge science is time, and everyone with an internet connection can join in. At $30/paper, suddenly only the rich (or those with rich patrons, such as tenured professors at rich universities) can afford to play.

Researching a topic, it’s easy to skim 100 papers in a couple days, trying to figure out which ones are relevant and which ones aren’t. Paying $3000 just to sort through and find the 5 out of 100 papers which bear closer scrutiny is very expensive, even for someone who isn’t “financially struggling”. (No, the abstracts alone aren’t sufficient for this.)

And it’s not clear that the money is going anywhere useful. The scientists who wrote the papers never make a profit: all the money goes to a couple of rich corporations, who will use the money to further impede scientific progress.

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by saidajigumi on Thursday February 25, 2016 @06:38PM (#11178755)
Researching a topic, it’s easy to skim 100 papers in a couple days

This, a thousand times. Compounded with the problems of research quality and legitimacy that this essay highlights, it's even worse than looking for mere "relevance". Many published papers are outright dross, serving as filler that further increases the power of a $30-$45/paper paywall.

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by return0 on Thursday February 25, 2016 @06:47PM (#11178794)
>all the money goes to a couple of rich corporations, who will use the money to further impede scientific progress

More problematic , the three major publishers are in UK, netherlands and US, which means the rest of the world's scientists donate their science to make these publishers richer.

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by tzs on Thursday February 25, 2016 @09:01PM (#11179381)
> If you aren’t affiliated with a university, scientific papers cost something like $30/each to read.

It's not quite that dire. DeepDyve [1], which is kind of like Spotify for academic journals, provides online access to 12 million articles from 10000 peer reviewed journals. You can buy access in blocks of 5 articles for $20, or unlimited for $40/month ($30/month if you buy a year at a time). They also have free 5 minute previews so if you are not on one of the unlimited plans you can get some idea if you want to buy a particular article or not.

[1] https://www.deepdyve.com

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by dalke on Thursday February 25, 2016 @08:57PM (#11179369)
There is another solution - interlibrary loan. While it takes longer, you can often get papers for free or for a flat nominal cost. The local college ILL service will make a copy of any article in the world for $10 for the general public. The public library where I used to live would make ILL copies for free.

It's not a great solution, but if you have more time than money, it's a possible alternative.

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by RogerL on Friday February 26, 2016 @12:59AM (#11180029)
Not sure I understand the reasoning here. It's bad to take things for free from scihub, so instead, take things for free from this other source which is much slower. The end result is the same, except the latter impedes research and involves a bunch of busy work for somebody.
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by timthorn on Friday February 26, 2016 @02:45AM (#11180275)
The central reasoning is that the other, slower source is abiding by the law.
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by mcphage on Thursday February 25, 2016 @09:56PM (#11179554)
> but if you have more time than money, it's a possible alternative

Most people in academia have neither.

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by dalke on Thursday February 25, 2016 @10:08PM (#11179600)
I think this is meant for humor, as an expression of feeling overworked.

That's different than "no time."

If someone truly has no time to wait a week or two for an ILL request (I'll assume the local public library offers it as a free service) they they have no time to read the paper, no time to carry out research, and no time to write up the research.

How then do they plan on taking on a new project when they have no time?

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by AnimalMuppet on Thursday February 25, 2016 @07:21PM (#11178980)
arXiv? I mean, you're looking at preprints, and you might have a higher dross-to-gold ratio, but can't you do your research there, without the moral dilemma?
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by Obi_Juan_Kenobi on Thursday February 25, 2016 @08:01PM (#11179171)
arXiv is great, but represents a very small fraction of the total published work, is extremely field specific, and old papers are still very relevant. I find myself regularly relying upon citations from as early as the 1910's.

It's not even close to an alternative.

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by tjl on Friday February 26, 2016 @06:36AM (#11180900)
For my PhD thesis I used some papers from the 1800s along with many from the 1900s to 1950s because those were when the foundation papers were published in one area I was working in.
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by marcosdumay on Thursday February 25, 2016 @07:51PM (#11179126)
What dilemma?

I don't do research, but from my point of view the issue is pretty much settled, there's no reason to doubt. Current publisher are just plain wrong and don't deserve people to feel bad over them.

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by Fomite on Thursday February 25, 2016 @08:06PM (#11179190)
There are whole fields, some of them rather important, that essentially don't use arXiv.
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by return0 on Thursday February 25, 2016 @07:49PM (#11179120)
has almost zero life sciences content
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by codedokode on Thursday February 25, 2016 @08:01PM (#11179172)
If you are not affiliated with Hollywood studios, movies cost $10/each to watch... and so on.