News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds by forgotpwtomain on Thursday February 25, 2016 @04:18AM (#11173275)
> You don't "have" any personal liberties. You are not born with rights, you are gifted them by a benevolent society. That society can easily lose its benevolence, and take your rights away, and there is absolutely nothing you'd be able to do about it.

Certainly society is a secondary concept to any strictly individual notion (just formatively speaking) - of course one starts at a point where others have already built up what is currently the case, but certainly that's not saying anything about rights being 'gifted' to an individual - only that there is a threat of violence against individuals by society for all matters not included in said 'rights'.

You're free to play with definitions as you want - but it would help if you had rather spent that time on a clear argument then on statements such as these:

> You might hold a differing view, but the fact is, reality works as I've described.

Re:Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds by Laaw on Thursday February 25, 2016 @12:47PM (#11176147)
I was (and still am) trying to illustrate the "physical reality" that exists independent of the concept of personal liberty.

It can be argued in many different ways, but the actual, consequential mechanisms regarding a person's "rights" are enforced at a legal level, and are done so at the discretion of the state. Reality does work, therefore, as I've described, regardless of what eloquent points you might make about the innate personal liberties each person is "born with". This is my "clear" argument.

Re:Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds by smokeyj on Thursday February 25, 2016 @04:42PM (#11178056)
> Reality does work, therefore, as I've described, regardless of

Holy tautological christ, batman!

> "physical reality" that exists independent of the concept of personal liberty

How about gay rights? Or reproductive rights? Or the right to use Uber? To argue ideology does not impact our legal system is frighteningly ignorant.

It seems evident that if enough people feel entitled to something (justly or not) it's possible the state is forced to adapt or not enforce unpopular laws. The state influencing society and society influencing the state are not mutually exclusive.

Re:Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds by Laaw on Thursday February 25, 2016 @04:58PM (#11178164)
You're the second person to claim tautology, but you've both been wrong. "Reality works as I've described" is not tautological. "Reality works as reality works" is tautological. "As I've described is as I've described" is tautological. I'm further asserting, beyond the givens, that what I've described presents a difference from alternative conclusions, and what I've described represents the set of physical laws of this universe, rather than the ideological so-called "rules" of society, which are not enforced via the physical laws of this universe.

We're talking about "rights" in the context of "what can and can't be done", and I'm concluding that what some people are claiming as "unalienable" or "innate" aren't actually so.

It doesn't matter how many people "feel entitled" to anything. It does not seem that the state is "forced" to do anything. The state can choose to act and behave a certain way, but "forced" is simply wrong, as a way to describe how the state behaves. "Influence" is more accurate, certainly.

It may feel "wrong" or "bad", the fact that the state maintains absolute control, but it's true. Only through the grace of the state's benevolence does the influence of individuals or groups matter. The state gives you many ways to move through its control, and is generally benevolent, but not because it has to be.

[dead]
Re:Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds by dang on Thursday February 25, 2016 @09:22PM (#11179455)
> Real talk. Did you have daddy issues growing up?

Personal attacks are not allowed on HN. We ban accounts that do this, so please don't do this.