100+ people like it. ~200 comments from quality people.
This is game over for Facebook for everyone who doesn't play Farmville.
I've never seen pickup like that, and that is with just 2,000 followers.
I have 25k followers on my fanpage on Facebook and 5k on my normal facebook page.
in fact, i've never seen pickup like that on my blog with 250k uniques a month.
the only thing close to that i've seen is Twitter, but those responses are limited to the 90k followers i have and 140 characters each.
Also, it's not just this thread... scoble is having the same experience: more activity than ever.
it's a targeted network: people you've spoken to + 100% reach for your comments with that network since they HAVE TO go to their inbox.
this really is unprecedented: the reach of email with the power of social networking.
My Android phone email alerts me every time someone comments, likes, or writes on my page on FB. This is not unprecedented.
Right. The day when every bored geek in the valley gives it a spin.
Mark my words, a year from today Facebook will be in no weaker position than it is today, and Buzz may or may not be relevant, but it certainly won't be dwarfing Facebook—not by a long shot. If you disagree name your metrics, and I'll do a writeup a year from today and whore it up here on Hacker News.
Typically I don't consider you to be as much of a koolaid-drinker as Scoble, but man you really went off the deep-end this time.
But that's not the same niche as Twitter, and it's certainly not the same niche as Facebook.
Your right about facebook though, it doesn't seem the kind of thing that will pull in the less tech inclined. Although some people would have said that about facebook, with it's plain unchanging layout compared to all the things people could do on myspace.
I really can't agree with your assessment. You and Scoble - and I like you both a lot - are in a vastly different position than the people Google made Buzz for.
You guys are pundits (not in a bad sense - you're thought leaders).
Google made Buzz for end users and enterprise. I really don't think it's useful for end users at this point. Too many are reporting problems and dissatisfaction with the UI. As for enterprise, we'll have to see what they end up rolling out.
I appreciate that Buzz has worked well for you so far, but I feel you're being overly enthusiastic about the product.
don't know of anyone ever doing that...
I mean, I might be exaggerating, but among my friends I can name at max 10 people who don't have a Gmail and a Facebook. I'm guessing that the true proportion lies somewhere between the extreme situations we're in.
I presume they'll have a standalone Buzz application at the 2.0 or something similar. That will let an established gmail-only social graph generate lots of activity and use, seeming enticing to yahoo and hotmail (and all third-party email account providers) users that can now join/be invited in on the social-web-2.0-sharing fun.
Most people associate facebook with procrastination\lols.
More people prefer to procrastinate\lol than to work.
Therefore more people will prefer to Facebook than to Buzz.
Of course they don't always win, but this is what everyone said when MySpace was on top of the world. If Buzz is genuinely better then Facebook needs to be worried. Google has every other ingredient necessary to win.
Let's assume Google Buzz is undeniably better than Facebook.
Let's also assume no one is really invested in the 90% of Facebook functionality that Google Buzz doesn't address.
Hell, let's assume any user who tries Google Buzz will instantly declare eternal allegiance to Larry and Sergey and immediately delete their Facebook account.
Even with all those dramatically dubious flamebait claims, how the hell is Google going to get everyone to try Buzz. Since when do better products automatically win in the tech marketplace? If Calacanis is going for pageviews then I say well-played, but if he actually believes this tripe then he's dumber than he is arrogant.